Eucharist
The Christian sacrament of bread and wine, understood in the Western church as becoming the body and blood of Christ through the priest's action.
As defined in Diarmaid MacCulloch
Where it comes up · 3
- Diarmaid MacCulloch2 claims
- Ross Douthat2 claims
- 346 - The Best Kept Secret In History2 claims
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “Eucharist” →
- Viewed from the outside, Christianity resembles a cannibal cult of human sacrifice—worshippers ritually eat the body and drink the blood of Jesus, who is sacrificed for humanity's sins—an innovation that swapped the Old Testament's animal sacrifice while retaining the sacrifice-and-consumption logic.346 - The Best Kept Secret In History
- In a letter to the Corinthians, Paul chastises the community for partaking of the 'table of demons' and a version of the eucharist that left some weak, sick, and dying—suggesting some early Christians were using a dangerous, possibly drugged version of the sacrament that Paul opposed.346 - The Best Kept Secret In History
- Because the Western church increasingly emphasized that the priest's act in the Mass transforms bread and wine into the body and blood of Christ, the desire for that priest to be as pure as possible led, for the first time in the 11th-12th centuries, to a requirement that all Western clergy be celibate virgins—a short leap from ritual purity to sexual purity that amalgamated the celibate monk's role with the priest's.Diarmaid MacCulloch
- Hell is a profoundly unconvincing doctrine, and once a church stops persuading people of hell's real existence, attendance falls—as in Scotland, where Calvinism without hell amounts to little—so a Eucharistic, sacred-place faith is more sustainable than reformed Protestantism because removing the stick of hell leaves the carrot looking less compelling.Diarmaid MacCulloch
- Douthat's objection to a therapeutic shift on Catholic divorce teaching is primarily that the church would risk betraying its connection to Jesus, not merely the sociological argument that stricter churches weather modernity better; the New Testament presents marriage teaching as a radicalization of Jewish law, and the church has maintained that radical fidelity, which Douthat would rather not see softly surrendered.Ross Douthat
- The heart of Catholicism lies not in abstract theology but in the link between the New Testament and the ordinary liturgical life of the church — the aha moment comes from connecting the Eucharist and the everyday life of Catholic churches to the startling things Jesus says about his body and blood, rather than from theological commentary.Ross Douthat