causal

Removing Hell Shrinks Coercive but Not Sacramental Religion

Hell is a profoundly unconvincing doctrine, and once a church stops persuading people of hell's real existence, attendance falls—as in Scotland, where Calvinism without hell amounts to little—so a Eucharistic, sacred-place faith is more sustainable than reformed Protestantism because removing the stick of hell leaves the carrot looking less compelling.

causalpending

Speaker

Diarmaid MacCulloch

Evidence Quote

“once you remove the stick from religion, and maybe the carrot doesn’t look so interesting, fewer people are going to be involved in it. That is inevitable.”

Source

Diarmaid MacCulloch— Conversations with Tyler
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:22:27 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...