What this covers
Diarmaid MacCulloch, the Oxford historian of Christianity, speaks with Tyler Cowen about how medieval church institutions—often treated as timeless doctrine—were actually contingent historical inventions that remade European society. The conversation traces how changes in Eucharistic theology in the eleventh and twelfth centuries drove the requirement for celibacy among Western clergy, which in turn forced a redefinition of marriage around procreation rather than companionship. MacCulloch argues this was not inevitable: Christianity adopted monogamy from Greco-Roman culture to convert that world, not from its Jewish roots, which permitted polygyny for centuries. The Protestant Reformation, he contends, inverted this entire order by making married clergy the model of Christian life, transforming sexual ethics and family structure across Europe.
The conversation moves across interconnected terrain. MacCulloch explains how the parish system—designed as a territory one priest could visit in a day—allowed the Western church to achieve an unprecedented continental integration, and how the theology of purgatory turned medieval cathedrals into "factories of prayer" funded by the nobility seeking intercession. He distinguishes between religions of correct belief and religions of correct practice (orthopraxy versus orthodoxy), showing how Scandinavian countries sustain baptism and belonging without doctrinal attendance. On contested historical ground, he challenges Foucault on sexuality, argues the New Testament's dismissal of Jesus's family mirrors Sunni-Shia succession conflicts, reassesses claims about cousin-marriage bans breaking clan structures, and reconsiders what early Christian texts on same-sex relations actually addressed—the temporary pedagogical pairings of classical society rather than modern equal relationships.
MacCulloch argues that Christianity's structures around sex, marriage, and gender are not fixed doctrine but historically contingent constructions—most decisively the 11th-12th century shift toward clerical celibacy and a procreation-centered theology of marriage—which were later inverted again by the Protestant Reformation's married clergy.
- Christianity adopted monogamy from Greco-Roman culture rather than from Judaism to win converts in that society
- Changing Eucharistic theology drove clerical celibacy, which forced marriage to be redefined around procreation
- The Reformation reversed this by making married clergy the model of Christian life
MacCulloch holds senior academic credentials in church history at Oxford.
- MacCulloch is emeritus professor of the History of the Church at Oxford and a senior research fellow, with a new book Lower than the Angels: A History of Sex and Christianity.
“He is emeritus professor of the History of the Church at Oxford and now a senior research fellow at Oxford.”