Community Reinvestment Act
A 1977 US law encouraging banks to lend in underserved communities, cited by McWhorter as a form of reparations.
As defined in John McWhorter
Where it comes up · 5
- Russ Roberts (and Robin Hanson) on Truth and Economics 01/26/20093 claims
- Russ Roberts on the Crisis 05/17/20102 claims
- John McWhorter1 claim
- Richard Posner on the Financial Crisis 11/16/20091 claim
- Daron Acemoglu on Inequality and the Financial Crisis 02/21/20111 claim
Most important claims · 8 of 8Search all claims for “Community Reinvestment Act” →
- Research by Neil Bhutta finds that the Community Reinvestment Act and the GSE underserved-areas goal provisions (setting Fannie/Freddie targets for mortgages in lower-income and minority areas) had only very small effects, suggesting these specific policies were not decisive causes of the housing boom.Daron Acemoglu on Inequality and the Financial Crisis 02/21/2011
- Material reparations for African Americans already occurred under different names—affirmative action, the late-1960s expansion of welfare aimed especially at black women, and the Community Reinvestment Act of 1977—some of which worked and some did not, so the claim that nothing counts as reparations is mistaken.John McWhorter
- From 1992 onward, under both Clinton and Bush, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac were pressed to finance a growing share of mortgages for low-income borrowers, using mortgage originators like Countrywide, Wachovia, and Washington Mutual as intermediaries.Russ Roberts on the Crisis 05/17/2010
- Brad DeLong's critique that government-driven explanations of the crisis fail because Fannie, Freddie, and the Community Reinvestment Act all existed long before 2008 is weak, because Fannie and Freddie's affordable-housing mission expanded sharply around 1995.Russ Roberts (and Robin Hanson) on Truth and Economics 01/26/2009
- Lax regulation and subsidizing regulation are both 'stupid regulation' and equally culpable regulatory failures: the Community Reinvestment Act and the implicit government backing that let Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac borrow cheaply encouraged subprime mortgages, though these were not the critical factor conservatives claim.Richard Posner on the Financial Crisis 11/16/2009
- Roberts once came to the financial crisis as an ideologue assuming government caused it, but investigating Fannie and Freddie's role convinced him it was substantial, while he now believes the Community Reinvestment Act was not the source of the problem.Russ Roberts (and Robin Hanson) on Truth and Economics 01/26/2009
- The crisis is like the blind men and the elephant: each commentator blames the part of the story they know best, such as Fannie and Freddie, the Community Reinvestment Act, or mark-to-market accounting, so competing narratives are each partly relevant but none is the fundamental cause.Russ Roberts on the Crisis 05/17/2010
- The Community Reinvestment Act was given real teeth in 1995 under the Clinton administration, creating a large incentive for banks to make loans to people who previously would not have qualified, though its magnitude as a cause of the crisis remains uncertain.Russ Roberts (and Robin Hanson) on Truth and Economics 01/26/2009