Commerce Clause
The constitutional provision granting Congress power to regulate commerce among the several states and with foreign nations; its scope has been hugely contested.
As defined in Richard Epstein on the Constitution
Other definitions
Constitutional provision granting Congress power to regulate interstate commerce; interpreted narrowly in early American history but reinterpreted during the 1930s New Deal to allow broad federal regulatory power over economic activity
Trump’s First 100 Days and What Comes After | Neil Howe
Where it comes up · 5
- Richard Epstein on the Constitution4 claims
- Trump’s First 100 Days and What Comes After | Neil Howe1 claim
- Jill Lepore1 claim
- Conversations with Tyler - Luis Garicano1 claim
- Clint Bolick Defends Judicial Activism 10/31/20061 claim
Most important claims · 8 of 8Search all claims for “Commerce Clause” →
- The Constitution itself has a history of punctuated equilibrium with periods of relative stasis interrupted by major redefinition events: the 1787-88 founding, the Civil War amendments (13th, 14th, 15th) that settled the supremacy clause, and the 1930s reinterpretation of the commerce clause that enabled unlimited federal regulation.Trump’s First 100 Days and What Comes After | Neil Howe
- State legislation forbidding direct interstate shipment of wine, pushed by a cartel of distributors, was exactly the protectionist trade barrier the Constitution's Commerce Clause was designed to prevent; the 21st Amendment lets states regulate alcohol for health/safety but does not authorize economic protectionism, so such laws were rightly struck down 5-4.Clint Bolick Defends Judicial Activism 10/31/2006
- The original constitutional design limited federal power to regulate activities within states largely because of the slavery question: to bring the union together, the great compromise let southern states keep slavery and northern states keep abolition, which required powerfully limiting federal authority over intrastate activity—giving the federal government only powers like regulating foreign and interstate commerce and Indian relations while leaving the rest to state police power.Richard Epstein on the Constitution
- Constitutional history is not as neat as 'these people were right, these were wrong'; certain decisions are unequivocally wrong from a modern vantage and were extremely controversial at the time, with Dred Scott (1857) functioning as the recurring benchmark—FDR called the New Deal strikedowns and others invoked Lochner as 'the worst since Dred Scott'—whereas no comparable national consensus exists about the Roberts court's ACA decision.Jill Lepore
- By the 1930s the necessary-and-proper clause was reinterpreted to legitimize the administrative state, so that instead of three branches of government there is now a 'fourth branch'—the agencies—and combined with reading the Commerce Clause to reach things that merely 'affect' interstate commerce, these seemingly verbal shifts expanded federal power by at least an order of magnitude.Richard Epstein on the Constitution
- By 1937 everything changed: separation of powers was viewed with suspicion, the administrative state rose, and the enumerated-powers limit (especially the Commerce Clause) was scrapped for a system of concurrent jurisdiction in which the federal government can act on any important economic issue and the state can too—a huge shift from a lean classical state of small government and strong property rights to a law state with heavy administrative law and broad discretion at all levels.Richard Epstein on the Constitution
- Garicano would press the button to replace unanimity with majority rule on EU core state functions, though he notes even the US does not have that and it would require Europe to accept a commerce-clause style union.Conversations with Tyler - Luis Garicano
- The 'age of miscalculation,' in which presidents appointed justices who later defied their expectations, is now over: every one of the current nine justices is reliably aligned with the appointing party's expectations except possibly Kennedy (appointed 25 years earlier), who nonetheless transformed the Commerce Clause argument by asking whether Congress has the power to create commerce in order to regulate it.Richard Epstein on the Constitution