factual

Worst-Decision-Since-Dred-Scott as Benchmark

Constitutional history is not as neat as 'these people were right, these were wrong'; certain decisions are unequivocally wrong from a modern vantage and were extremely controversial at the time, with Dred Scott (1857) functioning as the recurring benchmark—FDR called the New Deal strikedowns and others invoked Lochner as 'the worst since Dred Scott'—whereas no comparable national consensus exists about the Roberts court's ACA decision.

factualpending

Speaker

Jill Lepore

Evidence Quote

“FDR in the 1930s, when the court strikes down a lot of the New Deal, he says, "This is the worst thing since Dred Scott." Or Lochner in 1905. People say, "This is the worst decision since Dred Scott."”

Source

Jill Lepore— Conversations with Tyler
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:19:01 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...