Cartesian dualism
The philosophical view that mind and body are separate, here applied to AI researchers who implicitly treat intelligence as residing only in the brain.
As defined in 68 | Melanie Mitchell on Artificial Intelligence and the Challenge of Common Sense
Where it comes up · 7
- Heidegger and Existentialism with Bryan Magee (1977)2 claims
- Tom Cruise's Body of Work (with Aled Maclean-Jones)2 claims
- The Revolution of Systems Thinking: Why It Changes Everything We Know About Reality2 claims
- Intersubjectivity, Social Objectivity, and the Free & Equal Other | Existential Basics ep.61 claim
- AI: Intelligent, Conscious, or Merely Evil? Peter Thiel | COSM 20221 claim
- 68 | Melanie Mitchell on Artificial Intelligence and the Challenge of Common Sense1 claim
- 83 | Kwame Anthony Appiah on Identity, Stories, and Cosmopolitanism1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 10Search all claims for “Cartesian dualism” →
- There exists a distinct kind of knowledge—tacit or embodied knowledge—that we acquire and apply instinctively but cannot fully verbalize or codify; as Polanyi put it, we know more than we can tell, and life consists largely of learning to do things in the real world with such knowledge rather than through book learning.Tom Cruise's Body of Work (with Aled Maclean-Jones)
- In ordinary life, people do not experience themselves as minds attached to bodies with doubtful existence of others; instead, we move back and forth between mind and body in a perfectly recognizable fashion without philosophical puzzles, revealing that the Cartesian dualism is contrary to actual lived experience.Heidegger and Existentialism with Bryan Magee (1977)
- At the beginning of the twentieth century, a number of philosophers began to feel uncomfortable with Cartesian dualism and initiated a rebellion or revolt against it, represented in different schools in both England and the continent, including American pragmatists and Heidegger.Heidegger and Existentialism with Bryan Magee (1977)
- René Descartes in the 17th century split the world into two fundamentally different substances: the mind (res cogitans) and matter (res extensa), creating Cartesian dualism that separated the inner world of thoughts, feelings, and consciousness from the outer measurable physical world.The Revolution of Systems Thinking: Why It Changes Everything We Know About Reality
- The deeper danger of screens is not merely attention or concentration but alienation: when deeply absorbed in scrolling, one quickly forgets one's own body exists, and a person can live largely as a 'brain in a vat' fueling the mind with content while neglecting embodied existence.Tom Cruise's Body of Work (with Aled Maclean-Jones)
- AI researchers are secretly Cartesian dualists who believe intelligence is all in the brain, but human-like intelligence is very much rooted in the body — we think in terms of metaphors derived from the body, physical space, and time, and understand abstract concepts and analogies physically — so we likely cannot have human-like intelligence without a body.68 | Melanie Mitchell on Artificial Intelligence and the Challenge of Common Sense
- Consciousness is probably not a meaningful category for AI evaluation because the epistemological problems (Nagel's 'what is it like to be X', Searle's Chinese Room) are hard to resolve, and historical Cartesian dualism was itself a theological distraction invented in the 17th century, not a deep metaphysical truth.AI: Intelligent, Conscious, or Merely Evil? Peter Thiel | COSM 2022
- There exists a dualism not of bodies and souls (Cartesian dualism) but rather a dualism of subjectivities: humans are simultaneously alone as isolated minds (brains in vats) yet fundamentally connected as aspects of a collective cloud mind.Intersubjectivity, Social Objectivity, and the Free & Equal Other | Existential Basics ep.6
- From Cartesian dualism followed the practical consequence that if matter is completely separate from mind and has no soul or inner perspective, then you can take it apart, measure it, and analyze it without having to account for anything immaterial, enabling the reductionist motto that the whole is the sum of its parts.The Revolution of Systems Thinking: Why It Changes Everything We Know About Reality
- There may be a connection between being a member of a 'slightly othered' identity and rejecting Cartesian dualism, as seen in both Anton Wilhelm Amo (an African in Germany) and Princess Elisabeth of Bohemia, who both produced notable arguments against Descartes' dualism.83 | Kwame Anthony Appiah on Identity, Stories, and Cosmopolitanism