83 | Kwame Anthony Appiah on Identity, Stories, and Cosmopolitanism
What this covers
Kwame Anthony Appiah and Sean Carroll discuss the nature of identity and its relationship to cosmopolitanism, with Appiah—a philosopher and cultural theorist—developing the argument that identities like race, nationality, and gender are socially constructed yet exert real force in the world. The conversation moves from the historical origins of modern identity categories through their contemporary stakes, exploring how identities work structurally and how they can legitimately change. A recurring tension surfaces: identities matter enough to organize political action and self-understanding, yet they are not fixed essences but rather contested social arrangements that reshape themselves across time.
Appiah traces how the modern concept of race emerged only in the 18th and 19th centuries as a scientific classification scheme, displacing older theological frameworks, and shows how nations themselves were largely created by state bureaucracies rather than preceding them. He examines the Three-Part Structure of Identity—labeling, internal meaning to bearers, and external differential treatment—and argues that all identities are fundamentally dialogical: changing what an identity means requires negotiation among all stakeholders, not unilateral redeclaration. The discussion addresses intersectionality, cultural appropriation, the economics of identity-based politics, and contested questions around reparations and free speech. Throughout, Appiah defends cosmopolitanism not as a rejection of local attachment but as its necessary partner—a framework combining universal moral obligations with genuine respect for difference, and one that makes effective cross-cultural moral persuasion possible precisely because it builds on relationship and listening rather than imposition.
Appiah argues that identities (race, nationality, gender) are socially constructed labels that nonetheless do real work in the world, and that cosmopolitanism—universal moral obligation combined with respect for difference—requires treating identity change as a negotiated, dialogical process rather than a unilateral declaration.
- Identity has three structural properties: labeling, internal meaning to bearers, and external treatment by others—and all identities are contested.
- Changing what an identity means requires bringing all stakeholders along through persuasion, because identities form a mutually-defining system.
- Cosmopolitanism pairs universal moral obligations with a non-compulsory openness to difference, enabling effective cross-cultural moral criticism.
Affirmative action, despite flaws, efficiently builds black middle class by directing capable students to quality colleges.
- Affirmative action, despite its problems, is one of the cheapest and most efficient ways of creating a black middle class—by sending black people who otherwise wouldn't attend to good colleges, who then return and improve their communities—but it is much easier to do along racial categories than along class categories.
“affirmative action, which has all sorts of problems, but it's one of the cheapest and most efficient ways of creating a black middle class.”
Constructed morality, though not objectively fixed in the universe, legitimately grounds cross-cultural moral judgment.
- Following the fact-value distinction, morality is not fixed by the universe or objectively 'out there'; you construct it, but it still exists and can be used to legitimately judge other people and cultures, refuting the relativist argument that outsiders shouldn't judge other societies.
“you cannot think that morality is fixed by the universe or objectively out there. You can construct it, but it still exists and you can use it to judge other people.”
Members of othered identities produced notable philosophical arguments rejecting Cartesian dualism.
- There may be a connection between being a member of a 'slightly othered' identity and rejecting Cartesian dualism, as seen in both Anton Wilhelm Amo (an African in Germany) and Princess Elisabeth of Bohemia, who both produced notable arguments against Descartes' dualism.
“And I wonder if there's any connection between slightly othered identities and rejecting Cartesian dualism. I just made that up, but...”
Episode structure and transcript availability information.
- The host introduces the episode's topic and structure, noting that listeners can find complete transcripts on the website.
“Remember, you can get complete transcripts for everything that we say here at the Mindscape podcast”