YouTube12m· Sep 2020· cataloged

Intersubjectivity, Social Objectivity, and the Free & Equal Other | Existential Basics ep.6


What this covers

This is the closing episode of Mark's Existential Basics series on The Modern Existentialist channel, delivered as a single-speaker talk of about thirteen minutes. It begins with a puzzle: if experience is subjective, each person might be a brain in a vat with no guarantee that others see the same world, yet people routinely report a similar reality. His answer runs through intersubjectivity, the connections subjects form with one another. He draws on Edmund Husserl to argue that these connections aggregate individual subjectivities into social objectivity, and he ties this to Sartre's facticity, the shared reality people build together.

The middle of the talk takes up what kind of reality that is. Mark rejects metaphysical objectivity, meaning absolute truths knowable with certainty, and describes reality instead as aggregate fiction: a "social cloud consciousness" resting on faith, in which people trust that one another's experience is valid. He argues that any claim to objective truth must be epistemic, so it can only refer to social objectivity. He also proposes a dualism of subjectivities to replace Cartesian dualism: people are isolated minds and parts of a collective mind at once. From this he derives three simultaneous modes of existence, mapped onto Sartre's terms. These are individual subjectivity (nothingness), metaphysical objectivity (being), and social objectivity (facticity).

The conclusion is the most contentious turn. Mark reads Sartre's claim that people are free and equal as an empirical description rather than a moral prescription. On that reading, denying another person's status is factually wrong, since the other is demonstrably a subject who acts on us as we act on them. He frames this as a rebuke to nationalism, xenophobia, and genocide, and warns that such denial invites reciprocal dehumanization in which "we all become monsters together." He also says that people have long overweighted individual perception and forgotten that they were never alone.

Sharpest takeaway

Human reality is fundamentally constituted by intersubjectivity—the shared creation of social objectivity through collective agency—which makes our common world real not through metaphysical truth but through collective belief and agreement, and this interdependence obligates us to recognize the freedom and equality of others as an empirical fact, not a moral prescription.

  • Individual subjective experiences become collectively verified through intersubjective connection, creating social objectivity that is real because we believe in it together
  • Humans occupy three simultaneous modes of existence: individual subjectivity, metaphysical objectivity, and social objectivity, making us both subjects and objects in relation to others
  • Denying the free and equal status of others is empirically false and creates mutual dehumanization, while recognizing their humanity is the factual basis for ethical coexistence

The claims · ranked20 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.74

Intersubjectivity is the relationship and connection that individual subjects form between one another, fundamentally defining how people relate to each other.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Mark (Modern Existentialist)

“husserl gives us a concept that we call inter-subjectivity the relationship which individual subjects will form between one another in other words inter-subjectivity is the connection between people”

0.74

If experience is fundamentally subjective in nature, it is paradoxical that individual people can report experiencing a similar reality, since each person could be a brain in a vat with no certainty that others see the same world as they do.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Mark (Modern Existentialist)

“truth is knowledge that we create and value that we assign at least that's what we've said but if this is really the case if our experience is fundamentally subjective in nature then how can it be that we as individual people can report that we experience a similar reality if we could all just be brains and vets if there's a sense in which no horses are ever real and if we can never know or confirm with absolute certainty that when you and i look outside we actually see the same world how is it that we can say with any degree of certainty that we exist in a common space that we really even live in the same world”

0.74

Husserl's concept of intersubjectivity shows that because intersubjectivity is the aggregate subjectivity of individuals, it is what allows for the formulation of social objectivity created through the collective exercise of individual agency.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Mark (Modern Existentialist)

“this is what husserl says that in its nature as the aggregate subjectivity of individuals inter-subjectivity is what allows for the formulation of a type of objectivity a social objectivity created by means of the collective exercise of individual agency”

0.66

Facticity, in Sartrean philosophy, refers to the fact of the world and the reality which humans create together through their aggregate subjective experiences.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Mark (Modern Existentialist)

“in sarswords this is what we call facticity the fact of the world and of the reality which we create together”

0.63

Through intersubjective connection, individuals form a social cloud consciousness founded upon faith and fiction—a collective subjectivity in which people choose to trust and believe that the experience of the other is valid and true, and that this belief confirms the validity of their own experience and world.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Mark (Modern Existentialist)

“after all we've already become a part of a social cloud consciousness founded upon a faith and a fiction a collective subjectivity we choose to trust to believe that the experience of the other is valid and true and is thus in turn capable of confirming the validity of our own experience and of our own world”

0.61

Individuals come together to form societies, create culture, and establish law; through this collective endeavor they forge a social consciousness and social memory in which individual experience joins with others to form a collective fantasy—the nature of our reality, intersubjectivity, facticity, and social objectivity.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Mark (Modern Existentialist)

“we as individuals come together to form societies we create culture and establish law together we forge a kind of social consciousness and a social memory our individual experience joins itself with the others in order to form a collective fantasy this is the nature of our reality our inter-subjectivity our facticity and our social objectivity”

0.60

Reality is not composed of metaphysical objectivity or concrete absolute truths knowable with certainty, but rather composed of aggregate fiction—subjective experience shared among members of an interconnected society.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Mark (Modern Existentialist)

“it's not a world of metaphysical objectivity not a world of concrete absolute truths which we can know with absolute certainty instead it's a world composed of aggregate fiction of subjective experience which is shared among the members of an interconnected society”

0.60

Humans are subjects which exist and live in a world of social objectivity—an objective world not because it exists beyond our ability to experience and perceive it, but because it appears collectively to all of us.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Mark (Modern Existentialist)

“we are subjects which exist and live in a world of social objectivity a kind of objective world not because it lives beyond our ability to experience and perceive it but because it's the world which appears collectively to us all”

0.59

Social reality is indisputably real not because it cannot be fake in a metaphysical sense, but because truth is value that we create, and because we believe in the truth we have imagined, we have made it real.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Mark (Modern Existentialist)

“this social reality our reality is indisputably real not because it can't be fake in some arcane metaphysical sense but because truth is value that we create because we believe in the truth we've imagined we have made it real”

0.59

Sartre's empirical existentialist philosophy provides a rebuke directed toward nationalism, xenophobia, and genocide based on the empirical fact that denying the free and equal status of others is ontologically and practically incoherent.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Mark (Modern Existentialist)

“what do you think of sart's construction of an empirical existentialist rebuke directed toward nationalism xenophobia and genocide”

0.56

To deny the free and equal status of another person is empirically wrong because the other is demonstrably an other subject who acts upon us as objects in the same way that we act upon them as objects.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Mark (Modern Existentialist)

“we as subjects must acknowledge the humanity the free and equal status of the other this is because we're not only subject not the only agent in the world and they aren't only object not just things of the world that we act upon to claim such a thing would be empirically wrong because we can observe that in reality the other is an other subject who acts upon us as object in the very same way which we act upon them”

0.56

There exists a dualism not of bodies and souls (Cartesian dualism) but rather a dualism of subjectivities: humans are simultaneously alone as isolated minds (brains in vats) yet fundamentally connected as aspects of a collective cloud mind.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 4/4durability 3/4· Mark (Modern Existentialist)

“here we find a different kind of dualism not a cartesian one with nothing to do with bodies or souls but instead a dualism which says this that we as human beings at once both do and do not occupy a common space of experience a dualism of subjectivities we are alone as brains in the vat trapped within our own minds yet at the same time we are fundamentally connected to one another as nothing more than just simple aspects of a collective cloud mind”

0.55

Humans simultaneously occupy three distinct modes of existence: individual subjectivity (conscious agency within a world of objects), metaphysical objectivity (physical existence in an unknowable world), and social objectivity (existence as objects in the eyes of others, within a perceivable world).

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Mark (Modern Existentialist)

“man must also be the thing which exists in between thus we can observe that man simultaneously occupies three distinct modes of existence the first is individual subjectivity the sense in which man acts and exists as a conscious agent of individual within a world of objects the second is metaphysical objectivity the mode in which we must infer that we exist as physical objects and constructs of a world which we can't perceive and therefore can never have absolute knowledge of the third is social objectivity the result of our inter-subjective status and the mode in which we exist as objects in the eyes of the other as constructs of a world which we can and do perceive an objectivity of a subjective kind”

0.52

When individuals connect and form bridges with others, they exchange information and construct experiences together, forming a network in which they can no longer consider themselves to be isolated individuals.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Mark (Modern Existentialist)

“when we connect when we form those bridges we begin to exchange information and to construct our experiences together we form a kind of network and at that point we can no longer consider ourselves to be just isolated individuals”

0.52

Sartre's claim that all people must be free and equal agents is not a moral prescription but an empirical statement describing a fact of reality—that all people are fundamentally free and equal agents by virtue of being human.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Mark (Modern Existentialist)

“when he says that all people must be free and equal agents he must be issuing some kind of weird pseudo-metaphysical system of ethics what these people fail to realize though is that sart's philosophy isn't a moral one but instead that it's strictly empirical and telling us that all people must be free and equal agents sartre isn't trying to say that all people should be treated as though they're free and equal what he's doing instead is simply describing a state of reality that it's a fact that in a very real sense all people are already basically just people”

0.52

Objective truth is necessarily epistemic in nature, meaning that if something can be stated or expressed, then it can be known, and therefore any claim to objective truth must refer to social objectivity rather than metaphysical objectivity.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Mark (Modern Existentialist)

“the idea of objective truth is implicitly epistemic in nature what that means is that if you can say something then you can know it in other words that when we say the phrase objective truth we must be referring to a social objectivity because it's impossible at least to the best of our knowledge to express or know something that's a metaphysical objectivity”

0.51

Humans exist as subjects in a world of objects; humans exist as objects to other subjects; humans exist as objects in a world of objects; and humans simultaneously occupy all three of these modes of existence.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Mark (Modern Existentialist)

“after all we are subjects in a world of objects we are objects to other subjects we are objects in a world of objects and we are at once all of these things”

0.51

While individuals are alone in their subjective experience and personal conception of the world, they have lived their entire lives in the company of others, reaching out to one another, shaping each other into people, and seeking to bridge the gap between their own reality and the experience of the other.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Mark (Modern Existentialist)

“sure we're alone in our experience in our subjectivity and our individual conception of the world but it's also equally true that for our entire lives we've lived in the company of the other we reach out for one another we shape and we mold each other into people we form connections and we seek with other desperation to bridge the gap that we see between the appearance of our reality and the experience of the other”

0.48

If we deny the free and equal status of others, they will respond by denying our free and equal status, creating mutual dehumanization where we all become monsters together, having made each other so.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Mark (Modern Existentialist)

“if we deny the free and equal status of the other if we act to remove their humanity from them then they will do likewise to us and then so too will we also be no longer free and equal no longer human in their eyes then we'll all just be monsters together because we'll have made each other so”

0.47

Humans have historically overemphasized individual experience and personal perception, placing too much weight on what individuals believe and perceive, rather than recognizing that we have never been alone in our existence.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Mark (Modern Existentialist)

“i think that maybe we've always thought of ourselves a little too much as individuals we place too much emphasis on our own personal experience too much weight on what we ourselves believe and perceive but you and i we've never been alone”