What this covers

This 1977 episode from Bryan Magee's Modern Philosophy series is a conversation between Bryan Magee and William Barrett (the transcript renders his name as "Will Marit"). They present existentialism mainly through Martin Heidegger, whom Barrett considers more profound and original than Sartre, though Sartre became the famous name. Barrett begins with the early twentieth-century revolt against Cartesian dualism. Magee adds that the subject-object split is peculiar to the West of the last few centuries and has to be learned in school. Barrett's argument is that anyone who asks how we know the external world is already in it, so knowledge becomes one mode of being-in-the-world among others, and philosophy's job is to describe those modes.

The middle of the discussion works through the features of human existence that Heidegger describes. These include thrownness), the lack of choice over parents, era and circumstances, and existence as an ongoing task of self-creation. Time is oriented toward the future, which Barrett illustrates with the way clocks presuppose our planning. Death is treated as a present possibility that cancels all others, and we can either flee it or ask what our lives mean in its light. Barrett links this to a remark of Socrates and to different kinds of anxiety, including a creative yearning, while evasion of anxiety produces alienation. He argues that treating alienation as fashionable is itself an evasion.

The later part turns critical and sometimes contentious. Barrett contrasts Sartre's radical freedom, a leap of choice that can leave one as blind as before, with Heidegger's quieter freedom of letting truth happen. He reads Francis Bacon's image of putting nature to the rack as an expression of the will-to-power behind Western science and technology, which the later Heidegger opposes. Barrett also addresses the loss of cosmic roots in technological society, the poem as something we must submit to, the capacity to "let be" in personal relations, and the treatment of language as a calculus, which he presents as technical thinking extended to language.

Sharpest takeaway

Heidegger's existentialism represents a fundamental rebellion against Cartesian dualism and shifts Western philosophy from the problem of knowledge to the problem of being, grounding human existence in concrete everyday experience rather than abstract epistemology.

  • Heidegger rejects the subject-object split inherited from Descartes and modern science, insisting we are fundamentally 'beings-in-the-world' rather than minds observing external reality
  • The central philosophical task becomes descriptive analysis of how we actually exist (our thrownness, finitude, anxiety) rather than solving knowledge problems
  • Later Heidegger extends this to critique technology and the Western will-to-power as manifestations of losing connection with being itself

The claims · ranked47 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.80

When one proposes an epistemological question about how we know the external world, one is already in the world and already admitted to that world; one's ticket of admission to the ordinary world is not contingent upon solving the epistemological puzzle.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Will Marit

“when you propose an epistemological question you are already in the world to propose it your ticket of admission to the ordinary world is not contingent upon your solving that puzzle”

0.80

Even when we torture nature to compel it to answer our questions in the experimental method, we must listen to nature's responses and give ourselves over to whatever nature reveals; there is a point at which our will to master must submit to what is given.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Will Marit

“even if we put poor nature to the rack poor tortured nature we have to listen to responses we have in some sense to give ourselves a breeze there's a point at which are twisting you say has to submit to to whatever is they had to be this really does represent a basic break with the tradition doesn't it”

0.80

Heidegger has an insight that goes beyond Sartre's view of freedom: while the individual hurls themselves into precipitous choice, they may remain utterly as blind as when they started; Heidegger's view of fundamental freedom is more quiet and subtle—the freedom to become open and let truth happen.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Will Marit

“except now here's where you see I think Heidegger has an insight which is beyond him in this respect because the individual hurls himself into this precipitous choice may him tearing off in that sudden direction be remain utterly as blind as when he started using then as a rather curious and his view of a freedom is a very quiet and subtle and soft it our fundamental freedom is the freedom if we can manage it to become open to let truth happen”

0.78

Once we realize that death is a possibility that inhabits our existence and dwells within it, we can either collapse and scurry away from it in fear, or we can face up to it and ask ourselves what meaning my life has in the face of that possibility.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Will Marit

“in this sense is the most extreme of possibilities but his point is once you realize that this particular possibility inhabits your existences sort of the Walker dwarf of it in some way that then you can either collapse and scurry away from it and fear or you can face up to it and then you ask yourself the question there is that possibility in the face of that possibility what meaning does my life have”

0.76

Clock time and watches are constructed because we are planning to use time; we are projecting ourselves into the future, and on that basis we can calculate time, which means the most compelling dimension of time for Heidegger is the future in the sense that the present has meaning only insofar as it opens toward possible futures.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Will Marit

“as a matter of fact is is a counter we construct the notion of clock time we make watches and other chronometer because we're planning to use that time so we're projecting ourselves into the future and on that basis we can calculate time so then again the the dimension of time that is most compelling for him is the future in the sense that the present has meaning only insofar as it opens toward a possible future”

0.75

The fact that modern civilization has great means of information and people know what is going on everywhere contributes to making alienation an empty banality; by making alienation fashionable and trendy, we evade its reality—one way of escaping anxiety is to make it frivolous or trendy.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Will Marit

“there's a saint in this position and part of some philosophers when they're examining language to treat it as a calculus it's an instrument which can be manipulated...I think is a point you say perfectly valid they the mere fact that we have civilization which has a great deal of means of information and its disposal so people know what do you know what's out what's going so the word alienation is tossed around and the mere fact that we make it into an empty banality in a sense promotes our imagination it's one of her horses I mean one way of escaping anxiety is not to take it seriously I make it frivolous or trendy or yes”

0.75

The subject-object dualism between mind and world inherited from Cartesian thought is peculiar to Western civilization and the last four or five centuries, not a universal feature of human thought, contrary to what most Western people assume.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Bryan Magee

“in fact contrary to what probably most Western men and women suppose it's really a view of reality which is peculiar to the West and peculiar to the last four or five centuries”

0.74

Knowledge is simply one other mode of being-in-the-world among various modes in which we exist; we are in the world in various fashions—sometimes anxious, sometimes theoretical—rather than knowledge being the primary or central mode of existence.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Will Marit

“knowledge is is simply one other mode of our being in the world and the various modes in which we are in the world I mean some of them are a much more urgent and less theoretical knowledge we're in the world in various fashions where anxiety-ridden”

0.74

Heidegger connects the technological centre of Western civilization with the Faustian will—the demand for mastery and determination that is the basis of modern culture, science, and technology—and the later Heidegger is in rebellion against this will-to-power principle.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Will Marit

“a lot what Heidegger connects the technological center of this civilization is with its Faustian wheel which becomes eventually the new demands determination by master made right which is the basis of our whole modern culture modern technology modern science and so on mission is in rebellion against”

0.74

Heidegger's task of philosophy is primarily one of description: once one is planted in the world as a being-in-the-world, philosophy aims to describe the various modes and ways in which we exist within this world, rather than solving epistemological problems about knowledge.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Will Marit

“once you're planted in in the world we are beings in the world then the task of philosophy becomes primarily one of a description...the philosophy then aims to describe the various modes of ways in which we exist within this world”

0.74

A fundamental characteristic of human existence in Heidegger's philosophy is 'thrownness' (Geworfen in German)—the fact that we are thrown into the world without choice regarding our parents, genetic structure, historical time period, or circumstances of birth.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Will Marit

“one characteristic of human existence...this notion of what he calls the the thoroughness of human existence the word in German looks very imposing...it is rather simple notion we're thrown into the world...we simply find ourselves here without as it were a by-your-leave anybody does we didn't take our parents we are born of those parents we are born at this particular time we are born with whatever genetic structures given to us”

0.74

Human existence is not a neutral fact; existence is ongoing and something we must constantly create ourselves—we are always involved in the task of creating ourselves continuously from this contingent base, projected into an open future where the future tense is the predominant temporal dimension.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Will Marit

“we begin our existence as a task in this sense is something we take upon ourselves because you see existence is not a neutral fact when you concern with human existence existence is ongoing it has to be we are always involved thus in the task of as a while creating ourselves always from this contingent moving back into an open future right all the time the future is the predominant tense and hide again he sees what he sees man is essentially a so to speak an ongoing right creature”

0.74

Socrates' remark that all philosophy is a meditation on death can be interpreted liberally to mean that human beings would not philosophize if they did not have to face the fact of death; without mortality, we would not philosophize seriously but would simply exist contentedly.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Will Marit

“there's a response to this question of death there Socrates remarked that all philosophy is a meditation on death which we might interpret liberally in this fashion that man wouldn't philosophize if he didn't have it have to face the fact of death if law had him living eternally in the Garden of Eden we just saunter along and death ruminate about this or that but not any serious philosophical issue”

0.74

Francis Bacon was a prophet of new science and a publicity man of genius for the new science; he articulated the principle that 'we must put nature to the rack to compel it to answer our questions,' which dramatically endorses the experimental method but reveals its underlying will to domination.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Will Marit

“if I if I I think we'll the key quotation here would be Francis Bacon we must learn the overall ways I'm really a prophet of the new science in this I always think I'm bacon in this respect this being a publicity man for the new science but a publicity plan of genius we must put nature to the rack to compel it to answer our questions which is very dramatic wave of endorsing the experimental method”

0.73

My death is uniquely mine and essentially cannot be invented as an event in the world for me; the meaning of death is that it is a present possibility—the possibility of not being, or as Heidegger puts it, the possibility which cancels all my possibilities.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Will Marit

“my death is is as an assent as essentially mine is something which cannot be invented an event in the world for me but it's a compelling possibility for me now I mean the meaning of death is that it is a present possibility I may not be at anytime that the meaning of death is that it's the possibility of not being or it's as he puts it it's the possibility which cancels all my possibilities”

0.70

In Heidegger's view, a poem makes demands of our will that we cannot fully control or will; the poet cannot will to write a poem (it comes) and readers cannot will their response to it—we must submit to it and be passive in relation to it.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Will Marit

“the thing about a poem in heidegger's view is that it lose the demands of our will we cannot the poet cannot will to write a poem II cannot will it it comes and actually we as his readers can't we'll our response we have to submit to it and be passive do it you see”

0.69

There are different modes of anxiety, and anxiety can take the form of a peacefulness of creative yearning; without anxiety, humans would never create anything, but people's attempts to evade and run away from their anxiety and the reality of their mortality leads to alienation.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Will Marit

“there are all sorts of modes of anxiety and then in some forms it has the kind of peacefulness of a creative yearning if we weren't anxious we would never create anything but men's men's attempt to evade to speak run away from his own anxiety to evade the reality of his own mortality leads doesn't it to the next existentialist theme namely alienation”

0.69

Among existentialist thinkers, Heidegger is more profound and original than Sartre, and Heidegger preceded Sartre in time, yet Sartre became the most famous name associated with existentialism in popular culture.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Heidegger and Existentialism with Bryan Magee (1977) [27bo4FMP3vo]

“the most famous name associated with that development both then and now is that of jean-paul Sartre but the existentialism of this century really began not in France but in Germany...there's virtual unanimity among students of modern existentialism that Heidegger as well as preceding Sartre in time is the more profound and more original thinker”

0.69

At the beginning of the twentieth century, a number of philosophers began to feel uncomfortable with Cartesian dualism and initiated a rebellion or revolt against it, represented in different schools in both England and the continent, including American pragmatists and Heidegger.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Will Marit

“at the beginning of this century a number of philosophers began to feel that in some sense it was uncomfortable and we find that the a kind of revolt or rebellion against the cartesianism takes place among different schools both in England and on the continent as a matter of fact with the American pragmatist till now Heidegger is one of those rebels”

0.69

In ordinary life, people do not experience themselves as minds attached to bodies with doubtful existence of others; instead, we move back and forth between mind and body in a perfectly recognizable fashion without philosophical puzzles, revealing that the Cartesian dualism is contrary to actual lived experience.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Will Marit

“in ordinary life we move back and forth between mind and body is perfectly recognizable fashion without proposing to ourselves any particular philosophical puzzles in these transactions so that it becomes somehow contrary to our ordinary feel of things to proceed in this way as if the mind and the external world was set-off against each other”

0.69

The notion that reality is split between observer and observed or subject and object is something that one must learn in school or as a student and is not something that naturally presents itself; individual experience accords much more with being embedded in a shared world.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Bryan Magee

“I find this a very congenial starting point because the notion that reality is split between observer and observed or subject and object isn't something that ever presented itself naturally to me it was something I have to learn so to speak in school or as a student”

0.69

Some contemporary philosophers treat language as a calculus—an instrument that can be manipulated and controlled—which represents an extension of technical thinking into the domain of language itself.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Will Marit

“there's a saint in this position and part of some philosophers when they're examining language to treat it as a calculus it's an instrument which can be manipulated and controlled it's a form of calculus and so on and in this sense this represents an extension of technical thinking you see even to the domain of language”

0.69

Most people in their lives are shut off and resistant in their personal lives and dealings with others; they have resistances that cannot be breached, but sometimes there is a crack in the wall of resistance and we become able to 'let be'—to no longer seek to compel others or reality.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Will Marit

“most of us in our lives so shut off and our personal lives in one way or another then the matter which from truth in our dealings with other people we have resistances which can't be breached and that one but sometimes there is a fish in this wall that shuts us off and we are able to let be we no longer seek to compel”

0.69

The loss of cosmic roots and connection with the whole has happened specifically in modern culture because we have built up a much more intricate technical society with more complex replication and encasement in a human-created environment—we live more and more in air-conditioned technological nightmare and urban complexes rather than in connection with nature and countryside.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Will Marit

“why should this have happened specifically in modern culture isn't it part of the human condition as such it it is part in the sense that man is a being who flies away from truth even as he pursues it but I think in one of the reasons it happens specifically modern house is of course what we we build up a much more intricate technical society were more encased in the sheer human framework of things than people worried because we live in a much more complex replicate it we live in AI a conditioned nightmare to borrow but we live more and more in a man created environment”

0.68

Sartre's most famous and popular doctrine is the notion of absolute and total freedom—that as human beings, we have absolute freedom, nothing prevents us from doing anything at any moment, and we are precipitously dangerous beings who are free to remove our clothes and jump out of a window.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Will Marit

“to come to do you say soccers and then most famously positive doctrine is its notion of Liberty and it's the doctrine which actually I think caught on most in public eye that as as human beings we have an absolute and total freedom nothing prevents us at the Swick moment from from doing is I'm very precipitous I am a dangerous thing I am in the literal sense free now to take all my clothes off and jump out of the window I can actually do these things”

0.68

Descartes, one of the founders of modern science, based his scientific scheme on a split between consciousness and the external world, schematizing nature for quantitative measures and calculation, which created a foundational dualism between mind and external world that has persisted through Western philosophy.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Will Marit

“Descartes was one of the founders of the new signs...part of his scheme for launching this science depended upon like the same kind of split between consciousness and the external world the mind schematized nature for quantitative measures for calculation for the purpose of manipulating nature and at the same time the human subject the consciousness doing that was set off against it so you what came out of it was a second kind of dualism between mind and the external world”

0.68

Alienation is not a modern fashionable concept but one of the deepest themes of modern culture, preoccupying Hegel, Marx, and serving as a main theme in 20th-century literature, yet the term has been misused and tossed around until it became an empty banality.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Will Marit

“alienation is unfortunate one in terms that's been tossed around so that if the word is used people will say oh that boring subject but it does happen nevertheless to be one of the deepest themes of modern culture and it and preoccupied Hegel Marx and I think has been their main item in contemporary literature literature of the 20th century”

0.66

Anxiety is not a pathological condition or something to be eliminated; rather, it is our human existence in its contingency coming to the level of consciousness—the sheer contingency of human existence vibrating through us. Anxiety is simply part of the condition of being human.

definitionhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Will Marit

“if we've followed our previous description of deaths we realize that anxiety is there anyway as my fact anxiety is is simply our human existence in its contingency coming to the level of consciousness it is the sheer contingency of human existence sort of vibrating there through us on the other hand you see the other modern attitude which is partly the result of our being a technical society which commands certain instruments we have a command of drugs or remedies of various kinds we imagine that there should be some instrument means by which we can simply press a button and get rid of our anxieties that they're not something which which have to be faced and live through”

0.66

Heidegger felt that one of the tasks of philosophers in the modern period is to think through what technology involves and the meaning of modern technology; most modern thinking is either too superficial about technology or treats it inauthentically.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Will Marit

“Heidegger feels that or felt since these is dead now the one of the tasks of philosophers in in this period is to try to think through what technology involves they felt I think modern thinking is either too superficial to in inauthentic with regard to the subjective technology”

0.66

Death is not an experience in the sense that we live through it; as Wittgenstein says, death is not an experience in life because we do not live to experience death; therefore, we cannot have death as a lived experience.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Will Marit

“if I start to think of it as my death now my death is will never be a fact in the world for me I will never read my obituary which is a very significant little fact so it can never be a public event in the world for me well as Wittgenstein says death is not an experience right in life that's because we don't live to experience death it's not live through”

0.66

Heidegger does not call for a traditional religious explanation of existence; instead, he points out the structure of human existence and the framework within which one has to pose existential questions, showing that the dimension of human existence which confronts death must be faced, but what answer one gives depends upon the particular individual.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Will Marit

“does Heidegger calling a day traditional religious explanation of existence so what does he do no he has no no way and said all he's pointing out is the structure of human existence or the framework within which one has to pose these questions he's showing them this is a dimension of human existence which has to be faced what answer you give to the question what meaning do I have will depend upon the particular individual”

0.66

A second major contribution of existentialism is making people aware that modern society tends to depersonalize to a certain extent—society gets larger and more intricately organized, and the problem of the person and the individual as a unique being who cannot be completely assimilated into any framework (bureaucratic, conceptual, systemic) becomes increasingly important.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Will Marit

“the second point I think that's made aware of make people aware of like that modern society tends to D personalized to a certain extent that we it gets larger and larger more intricately organized and that the problem of the person the individual as a unique being who cannot be completely assimilated into any framework whether it's bureaucratic or conceptual a systemic something of him is left out”

0.65

The everyday life experience has a dual nature: it is simultaneously banal, over-familiar, and platitudinous, yet at the same time mysterious and extraordinary—a profound contradiction that most people feel but rarely articulate.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Bryan Magee

“our everyday life is at one in the same time sort of banal over-familiar and platitudinous and yet at the same time mysterious and extraordinary I have that double feeling about life”

0.63

The split between subject and object in philosophy was unknown to Greek and medieval philosophers; it did not appear in philosophy until formulated during the modern period following Descartes.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Will Marit

“the split between subject and object doesn't appear in philosophy until you get really at formulating they kind is unknown to the Greeks and the medieval philosophers”

0.61

In Heidegger's analysis of human existence, there are sudden abrupt gaps and extraordinary experiences that interrupt ordinary everyday experience, and these discontinuities are central to understanding authentic existence rather than just describing the banal and familiar.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Will Marit

“if I compare hiding in this respect with another philosopher of the everyday...Vik and styling is the task of philosophy to be unraveling the snores of our ordinary language...now in this sense we almost envisage with vacance and possibility if we unraveled all this Nelson language philosophy would disappear...but now you see the Heidegger's case we move along that plane of ordinary reality and there suddenly or extraordinary gaps abrupt kinds of experiences which are very extra”

0.61

Alienation occurs at multiple levels, including losing oneself in the impersonal social self—a person burying themselves in their persona or social roles—and also more fundamentally, the way people lose themselves in the demands of getting and spending and social conformity.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Will Marit

“animation occurs for hide against several levels one that one is this level which we may lose ourself in the impersonal social self a man buries himself in his persona is social roles...but you see animation is really quite a real problem in this sense I I must say I I have a feeling of very acutely for the moment I'm putting this slightly humorously but I think you will understand this here I descended from the skies into London I haven't quite found myself and it seems rather strange the alienation feeling slightly detached reality”

0.61

Heidegger felt that in Being and Time he had riveted his attention too exclusively on man, and this philosophy was a powerful form of humanism, but there was no systematic grasp of what the human being is rooted in—the world of nature, matter, and cosmos.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Will Marit

“this thing which is the height of Goering sky was called the care of a turd he felt in some sense that in being in time he had riveted his attention to exclusively a man and that this this philosophy was a powerful form of humanism but there was no there was no systematic grasp of what the human being is rooted in and though of course the world of nature yes material the cosmos”

0.61

Modern attitudes toward technology split between flippant dismissal (saying machines are fine and make no sense to worry about) and serious concern, but the atomic bomb showed humanity that technology has drastic and fearful possibilities—that mankind could suddenly self-destruct—revealing the hidden dangers of the technical complex.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Will Marit

“on one hand you find people very flippant attitude there against machines or therefore technology makes no sense he said for man at this particular juncture of history before against technology we obviously committed to technology I mean if you've removed it the whole thing would collapse we are that's that's part of the stake of our existence is part of our gamble on the other hand you see there is a point which I think the atomic bomb has brought forth for human consciousness generally that technology has drastic possibilities is hidden to people who protest against this local nuisances or causing unemployment sabotage and so on but the notion that suddenly mankind could self-destruct suddenly showed us the the fearful possibilities within the the technical complex”

0.61

Philosophers like A.J. Ayer, Karl Popper, and Rudolf Carnap dismiss Heidegger's work as nonsense, rubbish, and garbage—all rhetoric and words—but this dismissal stems from professional deformation: they have a certain philosophical vision with certain blinders that prevents them from seeing the validity in Heidegger's different vision.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Will Marit

“other philosophers including very able and prestigious ones like AJ Aeron karl popper or rudolf carnap all sorts of people pour scorn on Heidegger and the kind of philosophy that he's trying to do they dismiss it they've dismissed it in their published writings as nonsense rubbish garbage it's all a lot of rhetoric...there is a certain kind of professional deformation the man has a certain vision then he carries with this there's sort of blinders to somebody else's a vision”

0.61

Heidegger's vocabulary, while initially jarring, is actually fairly straightforward German prose, and when compared with other German philosophers (like Hegel), Heidegger writes with considerable lucidity; the problem is not obscurity but unfamiliarity for those trained in different philosophical traditions.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Will Marit

“there is a certain kind of professional deformation...there's sort of blinders to somebody else's a vision and I think one of the things is that highly visible vocabulary you see is initially rather jarring and but if I think if you read him in German he writes a fairly straightforward German and it was certainly if you compare him as his German prose with that let's say of a Hangul this it seems to me how to gives lucidity itself”

0.61

Sartre's major philosophical work, Being and Nothingness, is not really about being or nothingness; Sartre does not have much sense of being the way Heidegger does, and the book is really about the melodrama of two Cartesian consciousnesses misunderstanding each other.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Will Marit

“his major work is called Being and Nothingness it's a gigantic minima it's not about being and it's not about nothingness as softer doesn't have much of a feeling for being whatever whatever one may object to in the hiding that one has to acknowledge that man is really saturated with the sense of being in some sense what Sartre this book is errata is about is really the kind of melodrama of two cartesian consciousnesses and naturally they're cartesian because he's French every Frenchman is a Cartesian”

0.55

Existentialism has made a significant academic contribution to the history of thought: it has exhumed and established Søren Kierkegaard as a major figure (previously virtually unknown) of considerable philosophical importance and power, even if he is not strictly called a philosopher.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Will Marit

“from the point of view of the history of thought or the history of philosophy existentialism has brought forward a kind of revaluation of 19th centuries so for one thing it has exuded God who was virtually unknown and he was speaking countries it's established him as a as a major thing I don't know whether you'd call him a philosopher but I think of considerable proportions and power in the ninety one of the major figures of the century”

0.40

Serious philosophies periodically sweep into intellectual fashion as a result of particular historical circumstances—Marxism after World War I due to the Russian Revolution, and existentialism after World War II in response to Nazi occupation in Europe.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Heidegger and Existentialism with Bryan Magee (1977) [27bo4FMP3vo]

“every now and again a serious philosophy sweeps belatedly into intellectual fashion usually as a result of some particular set of circumstances between the two world wars this happened to Marxism mainly as a result of the Russian Revolution after the Second World War it happened to existentialism”

0.37

London serves as an example of modern urban transformation: Shakespeare's London was much closer to the countryside and maintained connection with nature, but modern London is very different, being a fully urbanized human creation.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Will Marit

“I can't help but think coming to London that London is a very different city from Shakespeare's London which existed that much closer to the countryside but ya know very sure it did walk out you know”

0.34

Heidegger was born in southern Germany in 1889, studied under a famous philosopher, became a professional teacher of philosophy in 1927 at age 38, and published his most important work 'Being and Time' which was far more influential than anything he wrote afterward despite living another half century.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Heidegger and Existentialism with Bryan Magee (1977) [27bo4FMP3vo]

“Martin Heidegger was born in southern Germany in 1889 and lived in the same small area of Europe that virtually the whole of his life...becoming a professional teacher of philosophy in 1927 at the age of 38 he published his most important book called being and time he was to live for getting on for another half century after that and he wrote a great deal more some of it very interesting but nothing else of his was ever to be as big or as good or as influential as being in time”

0.29

Most Western philosophy in the subsequent two centuries after Descartes accommodated itself to the Cartesian framework of subject-object dualism, which became the default orientation of Western thought.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Will Marit

“most philosophy nearly all philosophy in the subsequent two centuries accommodated itself to the Cartesian framework”

0.17

Being and Time was presented as the first volume of a two-volume work, but the second volume never came out; Heidegger left a manuscript of the second part which he himself deemed non-publishable, and Barrett suspects Heidegger essentially said what he intended in Being and Time and his later work on Kant.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Will Marit

“being on time is the first its presented as being the first volume of what is to be a two-volume work but the second volume never came out...it turns out from recent information I've had his a month or so ago in United States that the Heidegger has left the manuscript of the second part which he himself does exist and it will be published I don't know it'll be published as a kind of knock Lhasa as something he's left behind but in I don't think it was publishable I myself tend to think that I'd know what he was going to say in that he said it in this book on Kant”