Akrasia
The Greek philosophical term for weakness of will—acting against one's own better judgment; from a-(without) + kratos (strength). Also translated as 'incontinence.'
As defined in Agnes Callard on Aspiration
Other definitions
Weakness of the will—acting against one's better judgment; Callard's theory treats it as a way of being able to do something when one lacks good enough reasons to do what one ought.
Agnes Callard
Where it comes up · 2
- Agnes Callard on Aspiration4 claims
- 16 - The Dark Side1 claim
Most important claims · 5 of 5Search all claims for “Akrasia” →
- Weakness of will (akrasia) is best understood as arrested aspiration: an earlier, aspiration-resistant self that was never fully transformed remains within you, so acting against your better judgment is not external compulsion but seeing the world from the recalcitrant point of view of the old you that the newer valuing only partly overrode.Agnes Callard on Aspiration
- Large transformations in people's lives are rational, but their rationality is not captured by the framework of decision-making; rather than picking among fixed pre-articulated options with fixed information and desires, the aspirant undergoes a temporally-extended learning process in which information, desires, and the mode of evaluation are all changing, so its rationality can only be seen across a stretch of time, not at an instant.Agnes Callard on Aspiration
- Both speakers participate in a factory-farming system that is ethically indefensible while knowing the moral case against it, but the right term is not hypocrisy but akrasia - weakness of will - because they know and will openly state the right thing to do, yet cannot do it, which is what it feels like to knowingly do evil.16 - The Dark Side
- Callard's book Aspiration originated as a theory of weakness of will that kept getting refuted by good objections; she eventually realized the theory was actually a good theory of a different, previously-unnamed phenomenon, which she later named 'aspiration'—so the work came about by keeping a theory but shifting its topic.Agnes Callard on Aspiration
- Part of life's learning process is learning who you are and your limits: the self does not simply let itself be molded into whatever you want, and accepting some recalcitrant traits (like distractibility) can be wise because such traits may carry advantages, such as a connection to creativity.Agnes Callard on Aspiration