factual

Book grew by keeping a refuted theory and changing the topic

Callard's book Aspiration originated as a theory of weakness of will that kept getting refuted by good objections; she eventually realized the theory was actually a good theory of a different, previously-unnamed phenomenon, which she later named 'aspiration'—so the work came about by keeping a theory but shifting its topic.

factualpending

Speaker

Agnes Callard

Evidence Quote

“the weirdest way someone ever came up with a theory of something is try to make a theory of something else and then just keep the theory, but shift the topic. So, that's how this book came about.”

Source

Agnes Callard on Aspiration— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:06:54 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...