Adam Smith Problem
The alleged inconsistency between the benevolence-centered Theory of Moral Sentiments and the self-interest-centered Wealth of Nations.
As defined in James Otteson on Adam Smith 06/27/2011
Other definitions
The 19th-century German claim ('das Adam Smith Problem') that Smith's two books are inconsistent because one emphasizes self-interest and the other sympathy.
Vernon Smith and James Otteson on Adam Smith
Where it comes up · 3
- James Otteson on Adam Smith 06/27/20115 claims
- Vernon Smith and James Otteson on Adam Smith2 claims
- Dennis Rasmussen on Hume and Smith and The Infidel and the Professor1 claim
Most important claims · 8 of 8Search all claims for “Adam Smith Problem” →
- The 'Adam Smith Problem' — the 19th-century German claim that the Wealth of Nations (self-interest) and The Theory of Moral Sentiments (sympathy) are inconsistent — is a problem of imagination, not reality, arising because economists read the Wealth of Nations without having read or knowing of The Theory of Moral Sentiments; read against that backdrop, qualifications in famous Wealth of Nations quotations clearly hark back to the moral framework.Vernon Smith and James Otteson on Adam Smith
- The two books are not in conflict but deeply connected: in The Theory of Moral Sentiments Smith developed a marketplace-like model in which people exchange judgments and sentiments to give rise to rules of propriety, and with few modifications this same model transfers to the larger-scale market economy where rules of property and exchange procedures also emerge unintended from the exchanges themselves.Vernon Smith and James Otteson on Adam Smith
- There is a harder second version of the Adam Smith Problem. TMS repeatedly calls the pursuit of wealth a fool's game (the beggar sunning himself is as happy as the rich man, anticipating modern happiness literature), while WN praises people's efforts to better themselves as the driver of growth. Smith seems ambivalent about whether the desire for acquisition is healthy.James Otteson on Adam Smith 06/27/2011
- The familiarity principle resolves the Adam Smith Problem. WN focuses on self-interest because it studies large-scale cooperation among strangers, where self-interest bounded by justice naturally predominates (primarily, not exclusively). TMS studies the full range of relations, including intimate ones. The books differ in tone, not in theory of human nature.James Otteson on Adam Smith 06/27/2011
- The Adam Smith Problem cannot be a genuine contradiction. Smith published only two books and revised both side by side throughout his life: six editions of TMS (1759–1790) and three of WN (1776–1789). Attributing a contradictory account of human nature to him is therefore uncharitable and implausible.James Otteson on Adam Smith 06/27/2011
- The so-called 'Adam Smith Problem'—that the Wealth of Nations is built on self-interest while The Theory of Moral Sentiments is about regard for others—is overstated; the two are simply books on different topics (moral philosophy vs. political economy) so emphases differ, and the Wealth of Nations itself contains many worries about commercial society, while empathy plays little role in it precisely because trade largely involves strangers with whom our limited capacity to empathize is small.Dennis Rasmussen on Hume and Smith and The Infidel and the Professor
- The Adam Smith problem was first identified by 19th-century German scholars as 'das Adam Smith Problem'. English-speaking scholars took it up in the late 19th and early 20th centuries.James Otteson on Adam Smith 06/27/2011
- The 'Adam Smith Problem' is the apparent contradiction that The Wealth of Nations praises self-interest while The Theory of Moral Sentiments praises benevolence and altruism, as if the books were written by two different people. German scholars first identified it in the 19th century as 'das Adam Smith Problem'.James Otteson on Adam Smith 06/27/2011