Hilbert space
An abstract vector space of possible quantum states; the quantum state of the world is a vector in it.
As defined in ms_215
Where it comes up · 56
- 300 | Solo: Does Time Exist?11 claims
- 355 | Solo: Looking Quantum Mechanics in the Eyeball11 claims
- 349 | Daniel Harlow on What Quantum Gravity Teaches Us About Quantum Mechanics7 claims
- AMA | March 20226 claims
- 323 | Jacob Barandes on Indivisible Stochastic Quantum Mechanics5 claims
- 63 | Solo -- Finding Gravity Within Quantum Mechanics5 claims
- AMA | April 20214 claims
- AMA | June 20224 claims
and 48 more
Most important claims · 10 of 128Search all claims for “Hilbert space” →
- The intuitive picture of a particle's Schrodinger wave going through both slits in physical 3D space is actually very misleading, because for N particles the wave lives in 3N-dimensional configuration space (six dimensions for two particles), so the familiar wave-through-holes story only works for a single particle and breaks down completely for multi-particle systems.323 | Jacob Barandes on Indivisible Stochastic Quantum Mechanics
- The listener's chain of reasoning—that fermion wave functions must have exactly zero overlap, requiring arbitrarily high frequency components and thus infinite-dimensional Hilbert space, contradicting black-hole energy bounds—goes wrong because the Pauli exclusion principle does not require fermion wave functions to be exactly non-overlapping in position space; antisymmetrization, not strict spatial exclusion, is what fermionic statistics demands.AMA | April 2025
- The Heisenberg uncertainty principle is not fundamentally a statement about measurement or experimental disturbance; it is a statement about how quantum states relate to observables, namely that complementary observables (like Z-spin and X-spin, or position and momentum) correspond to axes in Hilbert space rotated relative to each other, so no single quantum state can be perfectly localized along both simultaneously.AMA | November 2021
- In the enormous-dimensional vector spaces describing quantum states, two random vectors are almost always nearly perpendicular (their overlap is near zero), so adding even a single particle to a many-particle box yields a state orthogonal to the original; this counterintuitive fact lets one in principle reverse-engineer which states were summed, enabling time evolution to be encoded in and extracted from a single static state.300 | Solo: Does Time Exist?
- Ordinary Schrödinger evolution combined with a finite-dimensional Hilbert space inevitably produces a Boltzmann brain problem: time is eternal, the system cycles ergodically through all its finitely many states (Poincaré recurrence time of order 10^(10^122) years), so the most common observers are isolated brains fluctuating out of thermal equilibrium rather than ordinary observers, which is empirically self-undermining—so one of those two assumptions must be wrong.300 | Solo: Does Time Exist?
- Against David Albert's wave-function realism (which takes a function on 3N-dimensional configuration space as fundamental), Carroll argues the truly real thing is just the abstract vector in Hilbert space, because the wave function can be equally represented in position space, momentum space, or infinitely many other bases — none privileged, like coordinate systems in relativity — and there is just enough structure in Hilbert space to reconstruct the world.AMA | March 2021
- Applying black hole methods (path integral counting and holography) to count the degrees of freedom of a whole closed universe gives the answer zero — equivalently, a one-dimensional Hilbert space — because holography says fundamental degrees of freedom live on the spatial boundary, and a closed universe has no spatial boundary; multiple independent calculations developed for black holes quantitatively confirm this.349 | Daniel Harlow on What Quantum Gravity Teaches Us About Quantum Mechanics
- Everettians do not know whether there are a finite or infinite number of branches of the wave function (a question tied to unresolved quantum gravity and whether Hilbert space is finite or infinite dimensional), but there is ample room for branching since the minimum dimensionality of Hilbert space is 2 to the 10 to the 122, so there is no danger of running out of room.55 | A Conversation with Rob Reid on Quantum Mechanics and Many Worlds
- A one-dimensional Hilbert space for a closed universe means there is only one possible state of the universe — not that it happens to be in one state, but that no other state is possible and there is no fact about which state it is in — which appears to conflict with the richness of human experience and with time evolution.349 | Daniel Harlow on What Quantum Gravity Teaches Us About Quantum Mechanics
- Unlike brane-theory or cosmological multiverses where other universes exist in higher dimensions or far-away regions of physical space, many-worlds branches exist nowhere in physical space; they reside, if anywhere, in the abstract mathematical vector space called Hilbert space (the set of all possible quantum states), where branches are not nearby or far but perpendicular and extremely isolated from each other.55 | A Conversation with Rob Reid on Quantum Mechanics and Many Worlds