skandhas
In Buddhist philosophy, the five 'aggregates' or 'heaps' (one material form plus four kinds of mental states) considered the most fundamental kinds of things that exist, used to argue there is no underlying self beyond these transient states.
As defined in 319 | Bryan Van Norden on Philosophy From the Rest of the World
Other definitions
Five aggregates or components of human experience in Buddhist psychology: form, feeling, perception, mental formations, and consciousness; Buddhist analysis uses these to demonstrate that none constitutes a permanent self
The SELF vs NO-SELF: Jung & Buddha's Greatest Debate
Where it comes up · 3
- Ep. 102 - Soul Complex2 claims
- 319 | Bryan Van Norden on Philosophy From the Rest of the World2 claims
- The SELF vs NO-SELF: Jung & Buddha's Greatest Debate1 claim
Most important claims · 5 of 5Search all claims for “skandhas” →
- The Buddha used the metaphor of a disassembled chariot to explain the illusory nature of self: when a chariot is taken apart, 'chariotness' exists only as a convenient label for the parts working together, just as the self is a useful convention without permanent essence.The SELF vs NO-SELF: Jung & Buddha's Greatest Debate
- The 'soul complex' is never the same for two consecutive moments but is in constant change like the body; yet each momentary state is a transformation representative of all past states and the generator of future ones, providing a unifying bond that is not interrupted by death—a continuity of transformation rather than a breach of consciousness.Ep. 102 - Soul Complex
- After death, change continues in the skandhas other than the gross body, but the after-death change merely results from accumulated past karma and does not create new karma, because a physical body is necessary to generate new karma.Ep. 102 - Soul Complex
- In Huayan Buddhism, things are defined entirely by their relational qualities with no ultimate substratum—'turtles all the way down'—a view illustrated by the Rafter Dialogue where a rafter is the building and the building is the rafter because identity depends on relational roles and parts, paralleling how even one's physical existence is relational through quantum entanglement, gravity, and causal history back to the Big Bang.319 | Bryan Van Norden on Philosophy From the Rest of the World
- Nagasena's chariot argument in the Questions of King Milinda shows there is no self as a thing: just as 'chariot' is merely a linguistic convention for a collection of parts (not the wheels, not the parts taken together, not something beyond them), 'Nagasena' is just a label for a collection of parts, demonstrating there is no substantial self—an argument that, read alongside Descartes's Meditations, makes Descartes's case for the self look less compelling.319 | Bryan Van Norden on Philosophy From the Rest of the World