
Sam Harris vs Jordan Peterson | God, Atheism, The Bible, Jesus - Part 1 - Presented by Pangburn
What this covers
This is the first live stage meeting of Sam Harris and Jordan Peterson, recorded at the Orpheum Theatre in Vancouver in June 2018 and moderated by Brett Weinstein. The talk starts from what they share. Both treat dogmatism as the real hazard, and both put the machinery of error correction, meaning open dialogue and free speech, above loyalty to any particular doctrine. Peterson adds that chimp raiding shows tribal violence predates religion, so atrocity cannot be blamed on belief alone. Harris answers that sincere conviction can still drive good people to evil, citing secular recruits to ISIS who turned to literalist justifications for slavery.
Most of the rest tests how far religious texts and frameworks deserve credit. Harris argues from the Quran's punishment for theft and from Biblical passages on stoning and slavery that some content cannot be reinterpreted away. He adds that looser theological readings leave interpreters free to project whatever they like, which gives fundamentalism an edge. Peterson counters that scripture is a developmental narrative to be read as a whole, that the prophetic strand in the Bible criticizes its own dogmatic rules, and that incompatible traditions can both work because of shared deep structure. Weinstein contributes a pointed case: taboos on sexual license may have been adaptive heuristics in ancestral conditions yet misfire among 7.5 billion people.
The deepest disagreement concerns foundations. Harris, a self-described moral realist, grounds ethics in well-being and in the worst-possible-suffering scenario from The Moral Landscape, claiming that all moral claims bottom out in irreducible intuitions, as mathematics does in axioms. Peterson reads that scenario as a story and argues that a priori intuitions and narratives always mediate between facts and values. He also holds that some intuitions are more universal than others, and that Enlightenment rationalism grew out of older traditions. The two also discuss prayer as a psychological process and Harris's claim that Islamic doctrine is harder to update than Christianity.
Peterson and Harris debate whether morality can be grounded in objective facts versus whether it requires foundational narratives and intuitions shaped by evolutionary and cultural history, with Weinstein mediating their disagreement about the role of religious frameworks in ethical reasoning.
- Harris argues morality derives from facts about suffering and well-being, while Peterson contends that interpretive frameworks (including religious narratives) are unavoidable mediators between facts and values
- Both agree dogmatism is dangerous and free speech corrects it, but diverge on whether religious heuristics remain useful despite their factual falsehoods
- The debate hinges on whether moral intuitions about 'bad' (extreme suffering) are facts or foundational claims that cannot themselves be derived from lower-level facts
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Chimp raiding behavior demonstrates that tribal violence and in-group aggression predate human culture and religious belief, so the capacity for atrocity cannot be attributed solely to religious dogma or culture—it is rooted in primate evolutionary psychology that humans must actively work to correct.
“Jane Goodall's discovery about chimp behavior you know because there was this idea that was really rooted in Rousseau Ian's thinking that the reason that people committed atrocities in the service of their group identity let's say they're tribal identity was because culture had corrupted us so it was this uniquely human thing but then of course Goodall showed in the 1970s that the chimps at Gombe would go on raiding parties right and so there'd be like four or five adolescent chimps usually male sometimes with a female in there they would patrol the borders of their territory if they found an interloper on the border near the border from another troop even if it was a member of their troop that had emigrated so to speak and that they had had some history with they would tear them to pieces”
The process of updating belief in response to evidence and dialogue is more important than the specific dogmas one holds; systems of governance that properly constitute themselves must elevate the mechanism of error correction (free speech, open dialogue) above adherence to any particular doctrine or ideology.
“I also think that systems of governance that are laying themselves out properly have to eval have to elevate the process by which dogmatic errors are corrected over the dogmas themselves which is why I think the Americans are right say with regard to their first amendment is the process of free speech is the process by which dogmatic errors are rectified and so it has to be put at the pinnacle of the hierarchy of values”
The core problem with religious dogma is not religion per se but dogmatism—the belief in things without compelling evidence and the refusal to revise beliefs through dialogue—which is why totalitarian regimes (whether religiously grounded or secular) share this dangerous characteristic of enforcing unchallengeable axioms by force.
“there's only one language game where in fundamentalism and of dogmatism dogmatism is not a pejorative concept the dogma is a good word in specifically within Catholicism and the notion that you must believe things on faith that is in the absence of compelling evidence that would otherwise cause a rational person to believe it that you know religious context is considered a feature not a bug elsewhere we recognize it to be a bug”
Harris proposes a concrete test case: the Quran unambiguously states that theft should be punished by hand-amputation, and there is no way to interpret this as metaphorical without engaging in the kind of tortured reinterpretation that proves texts can be made to mean anything.
“some of the claims in the book are not at all hard to parse in fact so many of them can only be honestly interpreted one way so to take again an example that will be not inflammatory to you but makes the point it just says that the remedy for theft in the Quran is to cut the hands off a thief auuu that is the unambiguous injunction it's not an allegory it's not it's so so the you have to be you have to indulge some kind of tortured interpretive scheme to avoid the the shocking fact that the creator of the universe thinks you should live this way for all time”
Stories and narratives function as a priori intuitive structures that guide behavior and interpretation—they are not merely tools for communicating pre-existing ideas but part of the foundational cognitive equipment that allows humans to navigate reality and extract meaning from facts.
“I think there's a third category of a prior intuitions that are in fact stories or their personalities or stories so let me give you an example”
Religious frameworks like the taboos against masturbation, sexual license, and out-of-wedlock procreation functioned as adaptive heuristics in ancestral environments by increasing reproduction rates and incentivizing pair-bonding, but those same heuristics are now maladaptive in a world of 7.5 billion people and are therefore not reliable guides for behavior without understanding the underlying variables.
“if we can agree that this makes sense actually is a Fitness enhancing adaptation that this story would result in people behaving in a way that might result in the marrying early might result in them reproducing earlier than they would otherwise right then we can understand it as mechanistic and we can understand what you said that you know maybe God would care about whether or not people masturbate because God is a metaphor for some set of stories that gets you to behave in an adaptive fashion”
Harris claims that his argument in The Moral Landscape uses two concrete stories (the 'hell' scenario of maximum suffering vs. the 'heaven' scenario of flourishing) to establish an axiom of morality, which Peterson interprets as relying on narrative/story rather than pure fact.
“I'm gonna do a quick rereading of the moral landscape so because see you talk about GE Moore's argument of infinite regress if you claim that something's good and you equate it with something you can also ask infinitely why the thing you're equating it with is good now it seems to me that the way that you step out of that argument correct me if I'm wrong here is you tell this you tell us you tell a story I'm not trying to be smart about that you tell two stories you tell a story about someone who has an absolutely terrible life there in a in a jungle”
Harris argues that even if religious heuristics were functional in ancestral environments, having a worldview guided by continuous honest engagement with reality is objectively better than being anchored to unchanging ideas born from people with none of our present tools.
“we should be able to agree that having a worldview guided by a continuous honest engagement with reality and so far as we can apprehend it is better than having a worldview solidified or anchored to unchanging ideas that were born of people who had none of our present tools none of our present insights into anything”
The developmental history of ethics and morality has been largely overlooked by rationalist accounts that credit the Enlightenment with sudden moral progress; in reality, moral development grew gradually from religious and cultural traditions over centuries, and Enlightenment rationalism was built on foundations that preceded it.
“I don't know if I'm a fool of the Enlightenment I think you enlightenment types and I put Pinker in the same cabin radically overestimate the degree to that was that was a cause of sui it's like everyone was barbaric and superstitious until 1750 and some miracle occurred and now we're all in what we all became enlightened like there was a lengthy develop clearly all haven't I mean with this hence hens - are complaining about the problem and most of the world most of the world hasn't had the enlightenment through on some look I know fold the Enlightenment but I think that it had a lengthy developmental history that is radically under played by the people who who grounded purely in rationality”
Harris is a moral realist who believes there are objectively right and wrong answers to moral questions, discoverable through reason and empirical investigation, even if we don't yet know what we're missing about human value.
“crucially for me is the claim that I'm a realist I'm a moral realist and what realism means is that it's there that there are right and wrong answers to questions of this kind and and and you can not know what you're missing in fact we almost certainly don't know what we're missing on questions of human value”
Good people can be motivated to commit atrocities by sincere religious conviction if they believe the doctrines to be true—such as ISIS recruits who were secular before converting and who then justified slavery and sexual violence by literalist Islamic interpretation, demonstrating that religious belief itself, not just tribal psychology, can drive evil.
“so you have the person who joins Isis who wasn't even Muslim before they converted you know 16 months ago and they go all the way down the rabbit hole to the the most doctrinaire most committed most uncompromising view of just how you have to live in this world if you're going to be Muslim and they join Isis based on the idea that salvation only goes one way and the dying and defense that the one true faith is the best thing that can happen to you”
Multiple religious traditions (Hinduism, Buddhism, Christianity) can be irreconcilable in their doctrinal claims yet simultaneously functional as useful heuristics for their adherents, suggesting there must be a deeper level of reality that explains why incompatible systems both work—rather than one being true and others false.
“Hinduism is a completely different set of stories right now and many of them the logic the emotional logic the psychological import many of them have the opposite valence from any Christian story you would tell the like for instance the whole notion of good and evil yeah right which has such primacy I mean you talk about religion being deeper than ethics because ethics just deals with right and wrong and religion deals with good and evil right at bedrock okay good and evil do not have the same meaning in the East Buddhism and Hinduism do something very different with living”
Religious texts contain passages that are unambiguously unacceptable by modern moral standards (such as instructions to stone women for non-virginity, condoning slavery, and laws of warfare), and these passages cannot be reinterpreted away through sophisticated theological reading—they represent genuine moral progress that has moved beyond the texts, not within them.
“there are things written into these religious texts that are unambiguously unacceptable viewed through a modern lens and not because the texts are so complicated that we have misunderstood something but there are things that are just written in there that we now understand to be wrong”
Prayer can be understood as a psychological process where one honestly acknowledges wrongdoing and commits to accepting whatever answer emerges to the question 'how do I put this right?'—this is answerable without supernatural explanation but demonstrates how religious language can describe real psychological processes of moral transformation.
“so here's here's an exercise you can try so here what you do is is as you sit on the edge of your bed and you say okay what I did was wrong and you have to really believe this right so you've thought about it's killing you it's killing you so now you're penitent and you're confessing let's say and you're confessing to yourself as much as to anyone and you say I really want to know what I did wrong and I really want to know what I could do to put it right and I'm willing to accept any answer that will manifest itself to me you try that see what happens well that's a prayer that will be answered”
Psychological well-being comprises not only the absence of suffering but the quality of human relationships, individual mental states, and societal conditions—so a complete consequentialist account must include the psychological implications of a person's intentions and character, not only external outcomes.
“the way those those views tend to be taught they tend to take as in the tally of consequences you leave out the psychological implications of being the sort of person who would who would have sought those consequences or behaved that way right so I would grant you and this I'm explicit about this whenever I talk about this that part of the picture of any consequentialist discussion of well-being are is everything about the human mind and social relationships and societies born of all the individuals living together everything there that leads to different states of consciousness”
Any moral claim ultimately rests on foundational moral intuitions that cannot be derived from or justified by reference to still more basic facts—just as mathematical intuitions (like 2+2=4) rest on axioms that cannot themselves be derived from a more fundamental system, moral claims necessarily bottom out in irreducible intuitions that we must accept or abandon the coherence of morality entirely.
“every claim every claim we make about anything at a certain point if you trace all the tools were using down to you know Turtles all the way down to something that we can't explain and justify right this is true of physics it's true of mathematics I just said it was true of arithmetic I mean there's that we have intuitions of truth that can't be cashed out by recourse to the system itself”
Interpretive frameworks and a priori intuitions necessarily mediate between facts and values—we cannot derive values directly from facts without presupposing an interpretive structure, and this problem parallels the philosophical issue that you cannot move from 'is' to 'ought' without smuggling in normative assumptions.
“I can't see and you actually state this in your book I can't see how you can interpret the world of facts without an a priori interpretive structure and and this is an old philosophical claim it's not unique to me it's it's the claim of conte for example that you can't get directly from the fact to the value because there's an interpretive framework that mediates between you and the facts”
Peterson argues that the Christian Bible contains an internal tension between dogmatic and prophetic traditions, and the prophetic tradition itself implicitly condemns the dogmatic, cruel rules—suggesting an evolutionary internal mechanism for moral correction.
“there's a real tension and this is I think the tension that would be of interest to you is there's a tension between the dogmatic and the prophetic traditions and I think to the degree that you're interested in religious phenomenology you find yourself on the side of the prophetic tradition and the prophetic tradition has implicitly in it what would you call an an implicit damnation of those dogmatic crew those cruelly dogmatic rules”
Sophisticated theological readings of religious texts that move away from literal interpretation become unconstrained by the text itself, allowing interpreters to project any psychological insight they want onto the material—this is why fundamentalism has an asymmetric advantage in that it simply reads the words as written without importing external frameworks.
“this is this is a problem with sophisticated theology because the the sophisticated theology is in in most cases inspired by a more and more modern recognition that well we can't read it literally because it either makes no sense or it makes barbaric sense right so we have to get away from the literal and the more you get away from the literal the more you are unconstrained by the text and you can just broadcast on it anything you want to put there”
Islamic tradition contains unambiguous doctrinal statements that are harder to reinterpret than Christian ones (due to the doctrine of Quranic perfection and immutability), and polling data shows zero percent of UK Muslims surveyed accept homosexuality as morally acceptable, suggesting Islamic doctrine is slower to update than Christianity was under Enlightenment pressure.
“the doors leading out of this kind of fundamentalism don't open from the inside they get bashed open from the outside and it's it's it's humanism and it's secularism and it's scientific rationality that has exerted such pressure such winnowing pressure on Christianity you know now for multiple centuries that that's why we're not encountering the Christians of the 14th century on a daily basis but we and we are essentially encountering Muslims of the 14th century not only in the Middle East but in our own societies in in terms of their intuitions about how we should all live right I mean the fact that zero percent of UK Muslims think homosexuality is acceptable right zero percent”
Peterson responds that the heuristic of sexual restraint may serve important functions by channeling sexual energy toward pair-bonding and responsibility, even if modern secular people can understand sexuality without these story-frameworks.
“if you're masturbating all the time you're not satisfying you are you're monogamous relationship with your wife or husband we don't need to go there let's just you're not procreating and we must agree that a certain amount of masturbation was prevented by that story which made people fear the consequence of them engaging it which would result in I'm pretty sure less yes masturbation which means that in seeking a release which we are physiologically programmed to seek one might end up looking in a more urgent fashion for a mate right so so it's are we going to enforce monogamy as a No so look I'm trying to take you somewhere I think I think there is a way that we can rescue some important part of what both of you are saying”
Religious texts are complex developmental narratives whose elements must be interpreted in light of the whole work, not isolated sentence-by-sentence; a single passage only becomes intelligible when read in narrative context, just as a movie's opening scenes must be reinterpreted in light of its ending.
“it isn't reasonable to take a single sentence out of a coherent narrative and say that stands on its own or it's rarely reasonable because you have to interpret the word in the sentence and the sentence in the paragraph and the paragraph in the chapter and the chapter in the context of the entire book”
Harris argues that Eastern religions (Buddhism, Hinduism) have fundamentally different conceptions of good and evil than Western religions—viewing evil as ignorance rather than malevolence—which suggests that 'good' and 'evil' are not universal moral intuitions but culturally contingent frameworks.
“Hinduism is a completely different set of stories right now and many of them the logic the emotional logic the psychological import many of them have the opposite valence from any Christian story you would tell the like for instance the whole notion of good and evil yeah right which has such primacy I mean you talk about religion being deeper than ethics because ethics just deals with right and wrong and religion deals with good and evil right at bedrock okay good and evil do not have the same meaning in the East Buddhism and Hinduism do something very different with living I'm willing to accept your definitions of good and evil for truth is just not even evil is just ignorance on some level”
Moral intuitions themselves have a hierarchy of universality—some are deeply context-independent and appear across all human cultures (like the rejection of extreme suffering), while others are specific to particular traditions or environments, similar to how scientific truths vary in depth and universality.
“so there may be there may be some moral universals sure I think okay Jordan no but possible that there are some moral intuitions that are highly specific to particular traditions and wouldn't translate over to others yeah oh it's a highly probable because there would be environment specific adaptations like the environment specific tool use of chimpanzees right or maybe it's not even the environment maybe it's the self-consistency of the belief pattern in question so I'm sure I would put that in the broader environment”
Peterson responds to the Buddhism/Hinduism challenge by arguing that despite surface differences in framing, the underlying human nature and moral structures are universal—like how languages differ superficially but share deep grammatical universals.
“think about it like languages like many and then this is kind of an answer to the problem that you you laid out which is a real problem I'm not trying to deny the problem if you look at there's a lot of languages lots of languages look at how different they are it's like yeah have some levels of analysis they're fundamentally different and at other levels of analysis they're fundamentally the same which is how we know that their languages”
The notion that God exists is best understood not as a supernatural claim but as a metaphorical representation of transcendent principles that operate across evolutionary time scales: the capacity for truthful speech that structures hierarchies, the redemptive principle that emerges from honest confrontation with reality, and the selective forces that reward competence and moral judgment over tyranny.
“I say I act as if he exists so a much more precise claim okay so then what look but in this case what fits it so you act as though God exists”
Peterson claims that some a priori intuitions might take the form of stories, personalities, or myths rather than abstract principles—and that this is a genuine third category of fundamental truth beyond both mathematical intuitions and empirical facts.
“so let me give you an example so I'm gonna do a quick rereading of the moral landscape so because see you talk about GE Moore's argument of infinite regress...and so I think there might be mathematical intuitions a priori so let's say Kant identified time and space is a prior intuitions but I think there's a third category of a prior intuitions that are in fact stories or their personalities or stories”
Both Sam Harris and Jordan Peterson share the core commitment to avoiding two catastrophes: moral relativism/nihilism and arbitrary dogmatic moral absolutism (whether religious fundamentalism or secular totalitarianism), and both believe free discourse is the mechanism that corrects dogmatic excess.
“we want to ground a structure of ethics in something solid and and and there's two there's two things you want to avoid two catastrophes let's say one is the catastrophe that you identified with religious fundamentalism and the other is the catastrophe that's associated with moral relativism”
Harris identifies a slippery problem: if Peterson allows that sophisticated theological reinterpretation reveals 'deeper' meanings in religious texts, it takes roughly 20 minutes to extract even basic admissions (like that the Bible contains indefensible moral content) when direct statements should suffice.
“the fact that it takes you 20 minutes to admit that there's that a lot of the Bible is filled with barbaric nonsense catalytic it took me 20 minutes to admit well we'll go to the tape on this these things matter these things matter”
Peterson claims that God is 'that which eternally dies and is reborn in the pursuit of higher being and truth,' capturing the mythological notion of sacrifice and renewal as fundamental to cosmic order.
“God is that which eternally dies and is reborn in the pursuit of higher being and truth that's a fundamental element of here mythology”
The worst possible misery for everyone—suffering maximized across all conscious beings indefinitely—is bad, and this claim is foundational to any coherent use of the words 'bad' or 'good'; anyone who claims this scenario is not bad is using the words 'bad' and 'good' in an incomprehensible way that makes further moral discourse impossible.
“my argument is that the worst possible misery for everyone is bad that's hell okay that's so so hell is is the religious version of that but I'm just you can forget about religion or whether there's a God or anything else that we live in a universe that admits of the possibility of experience I'm asking you to imagine a universe where every conscious mind every mind that can have an experience is tuned to the worst possible experience for that mind for as long as possible so there's no silver lining there's no there no lessons learned everything that can suffer suffers as much as it possibly can for as long as it can now that includes human beings includes animals and includes the future AI that we might build that can suffer it includes beings that we will never know about right so my argument is that's bad if anything is bad that's bad okay we don't disagree that the hell is bad”
Harris challenges Peterson's redefinition by noting that most believers do not have in mind the God Peterson is describing—they imagine a personal, supernaturally-conscious deity who hears prayers and cares about specific moral rules—and Peterson's definitions may mislead people into thinking ancient religion is compatible with modern knowledge.
“I'm not hearing in that list of attributes a God who could care if anyone masturbated I was not hearing a God who depends on what else is stopping you from doing...I'm not hearing a god a personal God who can possibly hear anyone's prayer is much less answer them right and I'm just I'm wondering what percentage of religious people who would say oh yeah I believe in God and it's the most important thing in my life what percentage of those religious people do you think have in mind a God of the sort you just described”
Revelation can be read psychologically as expressing the archetypal truth that heroic renewal occurs at moments of darkest crisis, and that redemption is found in truthful speech—a claim that needn't invoke the literal apocalyptic content but captures something psychologically real.
“what it anything and this is we should talk about well let me let me just address it all I only take a minute to do it and I'll try to be succinct so there's an idea that's expressed in that book is that it's something like things are always falling apart in a fundamental manner it's part it's built into the strut there's an apocalyptic element to human life we fail in small ways and we fail in catastrophic ways and everything that we have we lose and we die so there's and and societies come to an end there's an apocalyptic element built into the structure of human reality and part of part of what's revealed in that strange book at the end which is like a hallucinogenic nightmare in some sense is that the hero is born at the darkest point”
Harris's conception of morality centers on reducing unnecessary suffering and promoting wellbeing, which he describes as an 'elastic suitcase term' that subsumes all positive states of consciousness.
“the word I use for this is well-being yeah and I know from having I don't think we spoke about this on my podcast but from haven't seen you in other interviews I I think you think that phrase doesn't capture everything one could reasonably want but I think it doesn't matter just I've you know it's an elastic suitcase term for a reason”
The university systems, journalism, and traditional sense-making institutions are breaking down at the same moment that a network of people are trying to make sense in alternative ways, creating both risk of failure and potential for upgraded understanding of difficult issues.
“we are existing in a moment where all of the systems that have helped us make sense are breaking down the university systems are breaking down journalism is breaking down and at that same moment we have a network of people who are trying to make sense in an alternative way”
The concept of 'being' (capital B) in Western metaphysics, which Peterson associates with the ultimate value, is distinct from 'well-being' and encompasses positive human experiences beyond mere absence of suffering, including meaning, transcendence, and flourishing.
“the phrase I use though the word I use for this is well-being yeah and I know from having I don't think we spoke about this on my podcast but from haven't seen you in other interviews I I think you think that phrase doesn't capture everything one could reasonably want but I think it doesn't matter just I've you know it's an elastic suitcase term for a reason and it's it's actually in reading your book I realize there's a point of contact here because you use the word being capital B being with as though it were imbued with significant gravitas and and so for me well and I agree with you that's an appropriate use of being and for me well-being is simply just the positive side of being you know there's the negative side the suffering we want to mitigate but I think I think however good consciousness can be in this universe that the well-being for me subsumes all of those possibilities”
Sam Harris and Jordan Peterson have had difficult conversations in past podcasts where approximately 10% of what Peterson says strikes Harris as unwise or poorly-intentioned, prompting Harris to question whether he is the problem in their interactions.
“I had so much admiration for him in those conversations it's 90% of what he said in those conversations struck me as really wise and useful and well-intentioned and 10% didn't and I noticed that it was clear to me that that you've seen these successful conversations with other people who I respect I began to wonder that you know I might be the problem”