dogmatism
The posture of holding beliefs that one has decided in advance cannot be revised and being unwilling, even offended, to reconsider them regardless of argument or evidence.
As defined in Sam Harris on Meditation, Mindfulness, and Morality
Other definitions
Rigid adherence to a set of principles or beliefs without questioning or considering alternative perspectives; the insistence that one worldview is absolutely true without leaving room for mystery or complexity
How “The Matter With Things” Can Transform the World | book by Iain McGilchrist
Where it comes up · 10
- Sam Harris & Jordan Peterson in Vancouver 2018 (with Bret Weinstein moderating) — Night One5 claims
- Sam Harris & Jordan Peterson in Vancouver 2018 (with Bret Weinstein moderating) — Second Night3 claims
- Dr. Darren Staloff, Augustine's City of God2 claims
- Tyler Cowen in Discussion With Dwarkesh Patel2 claims
- Jordan Peterson & Sam Harris Try to Find Something They Agree On | EP 4081 claim
- Sam Harris on Meditation, Mindfulness, and Morality1 claim
- 60 - An Evening With Richard Dawkins And Sam Harris 21 claim
- Sam Harris vs Jordan Peterson | God, Atheism, The Bible, Jesus - Part 1 - Presented by Pangburn1 claim
and 2 more
Most important claims · 10 of 18Search all claims for “dogmatism” →
- Dogmatism is intrinsically divisive and is the enemy of reason because it is the very posture of holding beliefs that one has decided in advance cannot be revised and being unwilling and offended to reconsider them; this fundamentalist sensibility, which religion uniquely treats as a virtue, shatters our shared epistemology and must be overcome wherever it exists, including in politics.Sam Harris on Meditation, Mindfulness, and Morality
- David Hume, though an agnostic who rejects God, nonetheless employs the same epistemic humility and critique of dogmatism that characterizes Augustinian philosophy, suggesting that the 'cash value' of the Augustinian stance is independent of its theological scaffolding.Dr. Darren Staloff, Augustine's City of God
- The core problem with religious dogma is not religion per se but dogmatism—the belief in things without compelling evidence and the refusal to revise beliefs through dialogue—which is why totalitarian regimes (whether religiously grounded or secular) share this dangerous characteristic of enforcing unchallengeable axioms by force.Sam Harris vs Jordan Peterson | God, Atheism, The Bible, Jesus - Part 1 - Presented by Pangburn
- Religious fundamentalism is not the core danger; rather, dogmatism—the practice of believing things strongly on bad evidence and enforcing these beliefs through force—is the defining characteristic of totalitarian systems, whether religious or secular, because dogmatism prevents the revision of false ideas through discourse.Sam Harris & Jordan Peterson in Vancouver 2018 (with Bret Weinstein moderating) — Night One
- Stalin's culture (Georgian, Leninist dogmatism, wine/dance-heavy society) created context for fist-pounding authoritarianism; combined with 'bad genetic luck' (his particular personality/psychology), this led to his catastrophic outcomes—culture matters but so does individual idiosyncrasy.Tyler Cowen in Discussion With Dwarkesh Patel
- Stalin was described in 'Stalin's Library' as well-read and intelligent, annotating many books, yet never even hinting doubt about Marxism in any annotations—showing that extreme ideological dogmatism can coexist with intelligence and erudition.Tyler Cowen in Discussion With Dwarkesh Patel
- The crimes of the 20th century attributed to atheism (Soviet gulags, Nazi death camps) were actually perpetrated by regimes that resembled religions in all respects except explicit commitment to otherworldliness—they featured dogmatism, personality cults, and irrationality.AD Harris/Murray/Peterson Discussion: London
- Religious belief systems can channel primate aggression in unhappy ways, leading to tribal violence amplified by religious dogmatism, but this is not unique to religion; nationalism, racism, and all forms of dogmatism produce similar effects.Sam Harris & Jordan Peterson in Vancouver 2018 (with Bret Weinstein moderating) — Night One
- Religious fundamentalism and dogmatism—the insistence that core beliefs cannot be revised regardless of evidence—is the primary source of sectarian violence and prevents genuine moral progress, whereas secular approaches to ethics allow for evidence-based revision.Jordan Peterson & Sam Harris Try to Find Something They Agree On | EP 408
- Harris argues that dogmatism—the insistence that certain truths have been decided for all time and no future evidence or argument is admissible—is a fundamental obstacle to honest conversation and moral progress in any domain.Sam Harris & Jordan Peterson in Vancouver 2018 (with Bret Weinstein moderating) — Second Night