civil disobedience
The deliberate, public breaking of a law believed unjust, done as an appeal to conscience and (for King) openly, lovingly, and with willingness to accept the legal penalty.
As defined in Lessons from Lincoln, Then and Now (with Diana Schaub)
Where it comes up · 3
- Lessons from Lincoln, Then and Now (with Diana Schaub)4 claims
- Chris Hedges: Corporate Totalitarianism: The End Game2 claims
- Great Minds - Aquinas' Summa Theologica: The Thomist Synthesis and its Political and Social Content1 claim
Most important claims · 7 of 7Search all claims for “civil disobedience” →
- America's two greatest moral lights, Lincoln and Martin Luther King, Jr., fundamentally disagree on obedience to law: Lincoln held that even unjust laws in a fundamentally decent democratic order must be religiously obeyed until changed, whereas King held that an unjust law is not a law and engaged in deliberate civil disobedience.Lessons from Lincoln, Then and Now (with Diana Schaub)
- King justified law-breaking not as violence and not as evasion of consequences, but as a bounded appeal to conscience that must be done openly, lovingly, and with willingness to accept the penalty including jail—these boundaries being what made the disobedience 'civil' for King.Lessons from Lincoln, Then and Now (with Diana Schaub)
- Lincoln would respond that crossing the line into lawbreaking undermines law itself in the long run and unleashes something one cannot control, and this can actually be seen during the Civil Rights struggle: King's willingness to break the law led others to break the law in ways far less bounded than King's own carefully constrained civil disobedience.Lessons from Lincoln, Then and Now (with Diana Schaub)
- Much of the Civil Rights struggle succeeded without any lawbreaking at all—the Montgomery bus boycott used economic choice, the NAACP fought in courts, the Freedom Rides tested already-struck-down segregation in interstate commerce, and the Rosa Parks case was a staged test of a law's constitutionality—and through judicial review the American system offers a 'constitutionalized' form of civil disobedience where 'breaking' an unconstitutional law that the court then voids means no law was actually broken.Lessons from Lincoln, Then and Now (with Diana Schaub)
- No time remains for conventional strategies; climate change creates a timeline where mass civil disobedience becomes a moral imperative—we must stop being constrained by the 'tyranny of the practical' and act according to moral principle.Chris Hedges: Corporate Totalitarianism: The End Game
- America's only response to impending totalitarianism is sustained mass civil disobedience; this requires spiritual dimension (understanding that some things have intrinsic value beyond monetary worth) and must target the system itself, as Standing Rock demonstrated before 700 arrests, attack dogs, water cannons with pepper spray in freezing temperatures, infiltration, and drone surveillance.Chris Hedges: Corporate Totalitarianism: The End Game
- Natural law theory, derived from Cicero through Aquinas, becomes the foundation for civil disobedience: when positive law (human-made law) conflicts with natural law or God's revealed law, citizens can justifiably refuse obedience by appealing to a universal moral standard accessible to reason that supersedes positive law.Great Minds - Aquinas' Summa Theologica: The Thomist Synthesis and its Political and Social Content