Amy Tuteur on Birth, Natural Parenting, and Push Back
What this covers
Amy Tuteur, an obstetrician-gynecologist, and host Russ Roberts discuss Tuteur's argument that modern natural parenting movements—urging women to avoid C-sections and epidurals and to breastfeed—rest on flawed history, lack convincing health evidence, and inflict psychological harm through guilt and social pressure. The conversation unfolds across medicine, history, and sociology, examining how obstetric safety transformed childbirth from a leading cause of death into a manageable medical event, then traces how that achievement became obscured once mortality dropped low enough that people forgot the dangers it prevented—a form of survivorship/complacency from rare risk.
Tuteur contends that breastfeeding advocacy and attachment parenting trace their roots to mid-twentieth-century figures, including traditionalist religious groups and Grantly Dick Read, a eugenicist who explicitly sought to keep educated women at home. She presents sibling control study evidence—notably the 2014 Colen study—showing that once researchers account for selection bias by comparing breastfed and bottle-fed children within the same families, purported benefits to term babies vanish. The scope extends to obstetric technicalities: how fetal heart-rate monitoring's high false-positive rate drives defensive C-section decisions, why VBAC carries genuine but often unacknowledged risk, and how litigation reshaped hospital capacity. Tuteur argues that medical colonialism—invoking underserved women's real crises to promote amenities for the privileged—mischaracterizes where maternal danger actually lies today, and identifies a fundamental asymmetry: no parallel "natural fathering" movement exists, revealing that selective appeals to prehistory constrain women alone.
Tuteur argues that the 'natural parenting' movement—pressure to avoid C-sections and epidurals and to breastfeed—is rooted in historical efforts to control women, offers little or no proven benefit to children, and harms women by inducing guilt over medically safe choices.
- Modern obstetric interventions (C-sections, anesthesia) transformed childbirth from a leading cause of death into a relatively safe event.
- Large-scale and sibling-controlled studies show the measurable benefits of breastfeeding for term babies are trivial.
- Natural childbirth, breastfeeding, and attachment parenting movements were historically founded by figures seeking to keep women in the home.
Lamaze breathing does not control pain and amounts to encouraging women to suffer while praising them.
- Lamaze breathing does not actually control childbirth pain, evidenced by the fact that if pain could be controlled by breathing it would be taught to soldiers and others; the fact that it's taught only for childbirth suggests it doesn't work and amounts to encouraging women to torture themselves while praising them for it.
“if you could really control pain by breathing, they'd teach it to soldiers. Or other people. The fact that it's only taught for childbirth suggests that it probably doesn't work.”
Recent spike in measured US maternal mortality reflects definitional and reporting changes, not genuine increased danger.
- The recent spike in measured US maternal mortality likely reflects a change in how maternal death is measured and reported—including the practice of classifying a woman who dies up to six months after childbirth as maternal mortality based on a coroner's decision—rather than the US becoming a more dangerous place to give birth.
“one of the challenges of measuring maternal mortality is that a woman who dies 6 months after childbirth can be classified as an example of maternal mortality. Because of a coroner's decision and the way that was kept track as changed over time”