C-section
Caesarean section; surgical delivery of a baby through incisions in the abdomen and uterus, sometimes performed as an emergency procedure.
As defined in Emily Oster on Pregnancy, Causation, and Expecting Better
Where it comes up · 3
- Amy Tuteur on Birth, Natural Parenting, and Push Back4 claims
- Emily Oster on Pregnancy, Causation, and Expecting Better3 claims
- What Modern Medicine Gets Wrong (with Marty Makary)1 claim
Most important claims · 8 of 8Search all claims for “C-section” →
- We cannot measure a baby's oxygen content directly because the baby is inaccessible; the only available test is listening to the fetal heart rate, which has a high false-positive rate (showing distress when the baby is fine) but a low false-negative rate (a normal reading reliably means the baby is fine), so when the test suggests trouble in the ambiguous middle range, the decision to intervene becomes a value judgment driven by parents' unwillingness to risk their baby, pushing C-section rates up.Amy Tuteur on Birth, Natural Parenting, and Push Back
- Before the 1930s C-sections were extremely dangerous and considered a bad thing, so many women had vaginal births and their babies died; once anesthesia, then spinal and epidural anesthesia, made C-sections safe, there was no longer a medical reason to avoid them, so the C-section rate rose as doctors sought to save every baby—and childbirth's current relative safety is the achievement of obstetrics, not its natural state.Amy Tuteur on Birth, Natural Parenting, and Push Back
- Because a baby in utero has a sterile gut and the microbiome is initially seeded by bacteria from the birth canal then augmented by colostrum and skin contact, babies born by C-section miss this seeding and may instead be colonized by hospital bacteria, meaning the dogma that there is no difference between vaginal and C-section delivery is false—even though, like antibiotics, C-sections save lives when needed but are massively overused.What Modern Medicine Gets Wrong (with Marty Makary)
- Vaginal birth after C-section carries an increased risk of uterine rupture and death of baby or mother; when these events occurred, women who had signed consent forms sued claiming they didn't truly understand the risk, won, and insurance payouts led insurers and the American College of Obstetrician-Gynecologists to impose restrictions (like the ability to perform a C-section within 30 minutes) that many rural and community hospitals couldn't meet, so they stopped offering VBAC attempts.Amy Tuteur on Birth, Natural Parenting, and Push Back
- Women obstetricians have epidurals in droves and C-sections at a much higher rate than average because their professional experience tells them these interventions are not harmful but merely choices, and epidurals were portrayed as bad partly because midwives cannot administer them and so demonized them.Amy Tuteur on Birth, Natural Parenting, and Push Back
- Erin Johnson's MIT research shows that doctors giving birth in California are far less likely to have emergency C-sections, which suggests that in other cases doctors may be overreacting and performing unnecessary C-sections, while doctor-patients are better able to push back.Emily Oster on Pregnancy, Causation, and Expecting Better
- Randomized evidence shows that simply giving a woman a doula—a labor support person in the room—reduces C-sections and epidurals, making doulas a cheap way for hospitals to lower their C-section rates and providing an independent advocate during the emotionally compromised state of labor.Emily Oster on Pregnancy, Causation, and Expecting Better
- In labor and delivery the power dynamic between patient and provider is so skewed—especially when told a C-section is needed for the baby's safety—that almost no patient can effectively push back or question whether the provider is overreacting, making informed self-advocacy nearly impossible in the moment.Emily Oster on Pregnancy, Causation, and Expecting Better