attachment parenting
A parenting philosophy emphasizing close physical and emotional proximity (e.g., co-sleeping) as the natural way to raise children
As defined in Emily Oster on Cribsheet
Where it comes up · 2
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “attachment parenting” →
- Natural childbirth, breastfeeding advocacy (lactivism), and attachment parenting were all started by people explicitly trying to force women back into the home—breastfeeding advocacy began in a late-1950s traditionalist Catholic mothers' group reasoning that breastfeeding would keep women home, and attachment parenting as articulated by Bill Sears was framed as God-given with the husband as head and the wife solely occupied caring for him and the children.Amy Tuteur on Birth, Natural Parenting, and Push Back
- The premise of attachment parenting—that there was one universal prehistoric culture in which everyone parented the same way—is false; there are countless ways to raise children across cultures, none inherently better, and the key truth from observing many cultures is simply that children need to be loved and to know they are loved, with everything else being commentary.Amy Tuteur on Birth, Natural Parenting, and Push Back
- The attachment-parenting appeal to how things were 'always done' in ancestral cave-dwelling life is of limited relevance because modern society and the skills children need differ greatly from those conditions, and it's unclear what specific outcome the argument is even meant to evaluate.Emily Oster on Cribsheet
- The absence of a 'natural fathering' movement—nobody argues children need fathers to hunt big animals with spears, and no indigenous cultures involved fathers in childbirth (women were banished to birthing huts)—reveals that natural mothering ideology selectively emulates prehistory only where it constrains women, exposing it as gendered control rather than principled appeal to nature.Amy Tuteur on Birth, Natural Parenting, and Push Back