private government
A non-state entity (like a homeowners' association) that performs governmental functions such as service provision, fee collection, and rule-making for a community.
As defined in Alex Tabarrok on Private Cities
Where it comes up · 3
- Elizabeth Anderson on Worker Rights and Private Government3 claims
- 139 | Elizabeth Anderson on Equality, Work, and Ideology3 claims
- Alex Tabarrok on Private Cities1 claim
Most important claims · 7 of 7Search all claims for “private government” →
- If a classical liberal rejects the nanny state's infantilizing control even when it might save lives, consistency demands rejecting the same paternalistic, freedom-restricting control when exercised by private government in the workplace rather than applying cost-benefit analysis there.Elizabeth Anderson on Worker Rights and Private Government
- Any complex organization needs an internal governance structure that, once scaled up, becomes a hierarchy; the default constitution of the American workplace is a top-down dictatorship where unelected executives own the means of production and govern workers, making bosses 'small-c communist dictators.'Elizabeth Anderson on Worker Rights and Private Government
- The objection is not hierarchy itself—which is unavoidable at scale for coordination—but 'private government,' meaning bosses exercise nearly unaccountable power that leaves workers vulnerable to abuse such as denied bathroom breaks and widespread sexual harassment.Elizabeth Anderson on Worker Rights and Private Government
- Most new housing in the United States is built within homeowners' associations—private governments serving 60-70 million people, collecting hundreds of billions in fees and controlling security, snow removal, road maintenance, and zoning—which function like Buchanan's economic 'clubs' and increasingly take over municipal functions.Alex Tabarrok on Private Cities
- Empowering workers within the firm through co-determination—giving workers a say in management—could make companies more socially responsible, because most employees have an ethical core and want meaningful work rather than work that merely makes money while spreading social toxicity; this worker-empowerment route is preferable to state regulation, which carries its own dangers.139 | Elizabeth Anderson on Equality, Work, and Ideology
- American free-market ideology is appealing because it descends from a founding ideal of universal self-employment—everyone working their own capital in perfectly competitive markets—under which a free society and a society of equals would coincide, since no one could amass enough capital to dominate others; this ideal explains why political discourse talks about markets but ignores the internal organization of firms.139 | Elizabeth Anderson on Equality, Work, and Ideology
- Modern firms function as private governments, exercising over employees a degree of control—including over off-duty conduct—that often exceeds what even the state is permitted, because under employment-at-will bosses can fire workers for any or no reason while supposed labor-law speech protections go largely unenforced.139 | Elizabeth Anderson on Equality, Work, and Ideology