social entrepreneurship
Business activity aimed at social benefit; Thiel critiques it for drifting from 'good for society' to 'good as seen by society.'
As defined in Peter Thiel
Where it comes up · 3
- Michael Matheson Miller on Poverty, Inc3 claims
- Peter Thiel1 claim
- George Srour on Education, African Schools, and Building Tomorrow 12/22/20081 claim
Most important claims · 5 of 5Search all claims for “social entrepreneurship” →
- Successful social entrepreneurship requires staying modest in scope—being grand but not grandiose—rather than trying to transform an entire educational system quickly, because grand transformational efforts are easy to do badly and most charities fail by measuring the wrong things (dollars raised, dollars spent, staff size, kids in school) and thereby forgetting their mission.George Srour on Education, African Schools, and Building Tomorrow 12/22/2008
- Social entrepreneurship and aid typically measure outputs (blankets delivered, shoes given, cost, return on investment) but fail to measure the actual social impact, such as whether the giveaway put local producers out of business; in a competitive market putting a rival out of business by serving customers better is fine, but giving free goods with benevolent intent destroys companies without growing the economy.Michael Matheson Miller on Poverty, Inc
- Instead of building orphanages, the Clays started a jobs-creating business making necklaces; they now employ about 220 people and Shelly Clay estimates they care for about 720 children using only the sale of goods and services rather than donations, because the real problem is not that there are orphans but that parents lack the means to care for them—as one father said, 'I don't need that. I just need a job.'Michael Matheson Miller on Poverty, Inc
- TOMS Shoes' goal of becoming a sustainable for-profit so it can provide children shoes 'for the rest of their lives' implicitly desires those children to remain dependent so the company can keep providing; the deeper harm is anthropological, not merely economic, because no one wants to be a beggar for life and permanent giving perpetuates joblessness and the inability to build markets.Michael Matheson Miller on Poverty, Inc
- The word 'social' is ambiguous: it can mean good for society, or good as seen by society; in practice the second meaning always dominates the first, so social entrepreneurship degenerates into 'me too,' lemming-like clones that lose their raison d'être, unlike mission-oriented businesses with a counterfactual sense of importance.Peter Thiel