institutions of justice
The film's term for the foundational legal-economic institutions—clear land title, access to courts, contract enforcement, freedom to exchange, and easy business registration—that enable wealth creation.
As defined in Michael Matheson Miller on Poverty, Inc
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 8 of 8Search all claims for “institutions of justice” →
- Even setting aside oligarchs, who have no economic incentive to build institutions of justice they don't need, the upper middle class in poor countries also lacks incentive: cheap servants like a driver and maid (which Schumpeter said is worth a household of appliances) make their lives comfortable, so they have a disincentive to create an inclusive economy that would raise wages and remove that benefit.Michael Matheson Miller on Poverty, Inc
- Prosperity depends on 'institutions of justice'—clear title to land, access to justice in the courts, enforcement of contracts, the ability to freely exchange, and the ability to register a business without undue burden—that are taken for granted in the West but are weak or absent across much of the developing world; without them, free or erratic aid cannot be absorbed and people cannot build wealth.Michael Matheson Miller on Poverty, Inc
- The poverty industry creates incentives for developing-country governments precisely not to build institutions of justice, because aid means governments don't need a vibrant tax base or a dynamic economy to stay in power; thus 70 years of emergency-model and sentimental aid have produced exactly the incentives needed for governments to avoid building inclusive institutions.Michael Matheson Miller on Poverty, Inc
- Political and economic institutions are not disconnected from culture but emerge out of it; a weakness of Why Nations Fail is its limited view of culture, because the institutions of justice rest on an ancient, non-linearly developed cultural and moral framework, and modern economics errs in splitting moral philosophy from economics as Adam Smith did not.Michael Matheson Miller on Poverty, Inc
- Poor people are not poor because they lack stuff; even raising $84 billion from generous donors would not eradicate extreme poverty because poverty stems from the absence of institutions of justice; likewise infrastructure, education, and health care are results of wealth before they become its cause, since life expectancy does not rise dramatically until a certain level of development is reached.Michael Matheson Miller on Poverty, Inc
- Hernando de Soto's experiment, in which student lawyers followed all rules to register a small sewing shop outside Lima using only public transport, took 289 days of 8-hour days, demonstrating that the legal and regulatory system is structurally unfriendly to poor people who cannot afford to circumvent it.Michael Matheson Miller on Poverty, Inc
- In many places 50-60% of land has no clear title, and where ownership is unknown there is no incentive to start a business because it can be taken away, with widows and orphans especially vulnerable—so the poorest are in the most dangerous position.Michael Matheson Miller on Poverty, Inc
- Access to justice in the courts is a key institution; a study cited indicates that in India it takes on average 20 years to get a court case heard and costs a great deal, so the poor are effectively excluded from legal recourse.Michael Matheson Miller on Poverty, Inc