Constitutional Disobedience
Seidman's framework that we should follow constitutional provisions only when they are good on their merits, not because the Constitution commands them, and should otherwise feel free to ignore the document in designing policy.
As defined in Louis Michael Seidman on the Constitution
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 5 of 5Search all claims for “Constitutional Disobedience” →
- The Constitution itself was created in violation of existing law: the Framers were directed only to propose amendments to the Articles of Confederation, which required ratification by all 13 state legislatures, but they instead wrote a new document, provided for ratification by popularly elected conventions, and declared 9 states sufficient—so the founding document was itself unconstitutional.Louis Michael Seidman on the Constitution
- It was common ground including Lincoln that the Constitution prohibited interfering with slavery in states where it already existed, so the Emancipation Proclamation—though justified as a temporary war power—violated that understanding; slavery's abolition was accomplished by force of arms in violation of the Constitution, and the subsequent 13th Amendment was adopted through constitutionally questionable mechanisms.Louis Michael Seidman on the Constitution
- Telling people they must accept a policy simply because the Constitution says so, without giving present-day reasons, is deeply authoritarian; obligations should be justified by reasons that make sense now, not by the judgments of people who lived 250 years ago.Louis Michael Seidman on the Constitution
- The practice of admitting new states with one senator serving a short initial term to stagger elections violates Article I, which provides all senators serve six years (with only the original group divided by lot); this glitch has been ignored since Vermont in 1791 with no harm, illustrating that sensibly ignoring a bad constitutional provision causes no chaos.Louis Michael Seidman on the Constitution
- For provisions of the Constitution worthy of respect, we should follow them because they are worthy of respect on the merits, not because people thought they were worthy several hundred years ago; constitutional disobedience means abandoning obedience-as-such, not abandoning every provision.Louis Michael Seidman on the Constitution