miracle
In Hume's definition, a violation of natural law; an event that departs from the regular course of nature or the observed uniform operations of natural forces
As defined in A History of Philosophy | 47 Hume: Do We Know What's Real?
Where it comes up · 2
- A History of Philosophy | 47 Hume: Do We Know What's Real?6 claims
- The Bible and Western Culture - Hume, Swift, and the Collapse of Deism6 claims
Most important claims · 10 of 12Search all claims for “miracle” →
- Hume's 1748 'Essay on Miracles' became one of the stock ideas of contemporary life by establishing skepticism about miracles, showing that the laws of nature are accumulations of regularities in human experience and that miracles as violations of those laws start with the burden of proof against them.The Bible and Western Culture - Hume, Swift, and the Collapse of Deism
- If one accepts miracles indiscriminately from all religious traditions, one must take every claim seriously (including a child claiming a monster in the closet), making life impossible; conversely, if one rejects miracles, Christian revelation (which depends on miracles) also fails—leaving no rational middle ground.The Bible and Western Culture - Hume, Swift, and the Collapse of Deism
- Richard Whateley's 1819 satirical essay 'Historical Doubts Concerning Napoleon Bonaparte' applies Hume's criteria of historical credibility against belief in Napoleon's exploits and by analogy questions the sufficiency of Hume's canons of evidence for belief in historical miraclesA History of Philosophy | 47 Hume: Do We Know What's Real?
- If natural law is understood as the operation of causal necessities—a rigid, mathematically determined causal mechanism throughout creation—then a miracle would be logically impossible; but if natural law is understood as uniformity of experience, then a miracle is not logically impossible but merely unbelievableA History of Philosophy | 47 Hume: Do We Know What's Real?
- Hume's argument against miracles concerns believability rather than logical possibility: no evidence can be sufficiently steady and forceful to produce belief in a miracle because miracles, by definition, do not come with the uniformity needed to induce habitual beliefA History of Philosophy | 47 Hume: Do We Know What's Real?
- Hume challenges Christians by asking: if they believe Christian miracles based on historical reports, why don't they believe Hindu or Buddhist miracles reported with equal historical documentation, since the evidence quality is equivalent—forcing a choice between consistent skepticism about all miracles or special pleading for one's own religion.The Bible and Western Culture - Hume, Swift, and the Collapse of Deism
- A miracle is a violation of natural law, and natural law should be understood as either the operation of causal necessities or simply the experience of uniform regularityA History of Philosophy | 47 Hume: Do We Know What's Real?
- By the middle of the 18th century, the Enlightenment was running out of steam and losing the optimistic expectation that it would solve all philosophical problems, as exemplified by caustic ironic works like 'Candide' that rejected the reconciliation of reason and revelation.The Bible and Western Culture - Hume, Swift, and the Collapse of Deism
- It would take a miracle to create belief in miracles—an ironic formulation suggesting that the conditions needed to generate belief in miracles (steady, forceful impression) are themselves miraculous and thus unattainableA History of Philosophy | 47 Hume: Do We Know What's Real?
- Hume notes that witnesses reporting miracles tend to offer contradictory evidence, so even their testimony about miracles does not have the steadiness and forcefulness needed to produce beliefA History of Philosophy | 47 Hume: Do We Know What's Real?