moral foundations theory
A framework holding that people draw on a set of underlying moral foundations, which different groups weight or define in dramatically different ways.
As defined in Arthur Brooks on Love Your Enemies
Where it comes up · 5
- Jonathan Haidt4 claims
- Jonathan Haidt on the Righteous Mind3 claims
- Helen Pluckrose and James Lindsay on the Enemies of Modernity2 claims
- Arthur Brooks on Love Your Enemies1 claim
- 110 - The Change Artist1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 11Search all claims for “moral foundations theory” →
- Per Horseshoe Theory (extended to three legs for libertarian, liberal, and conservative moralities), the political extremes bend away from individual liberty toward social authoritarianism characterized by 'authoritarian conventionalism'—the belief that one's own group's views should be conventional for everyone—so the true battle for modernity is against authoritarianism on all sides, not left versus right.Helen Pluckrose and James Lindsay on the Enemies of Modernity
- Moral foundations theory holds there are roughly six innate moral 'foundations'—care/harm, fairness/reciprocity, loyalty/betrayal, authority/subversion, sanctity/degradation, and liberty/oppression—that are products of evolution but that cultures build upon variably, reconciling the universality of human nature with the deep variability of cultures.Jonathan Haidt
- Moral foundations function like taste buds: they are innate receptors present from birth (not modules firing at the moment of judgment), and each culture builds a distinctive 'cuisine'—a morality—that must ultimately please the same universal set of moral taste buds, with different cultures emphasizing different ones.Jonathan Haidt
- Libertarian, liberal, and conservative moralities are three distinct moral predilections with clear definitions under Jonathan Haidt and Craig Joseph's moral foundations theory, providing an empirical basis for the three-part political taxonomy.Helen Pluckrose and James Lindsay on the Enemies of Modernity
- Morality originates from evolution—humans have innate capacities built in to navigate the social world—but nothing is hard-wired; culture then shapes which of these innate capacities develop more than others, making humans 'predisposed but not predestined.'Jonathan Haidt on the Righteous Mind
- Morality rests on six foundations functioning like taste buds: care/harm, fairness/cheating, and liberty/oppression are universal; while authority/subversion, loyalty/betrayal, and sanctity/degradation are also universal but are emphasized far more by conservatives and traditional societies and are thin on the secular Left.Jonathan Haidt on the Righteous Mind
- Yale developmental research (Bloom and Wynn) shows infants as young as 3-6 months, after watching puppet shows where one puppet helps another up a hill and another hinders it, reliably prefer the helping puppet—suggesting an innate capacity to distinguish kind from cruel agents.Jonathan Haidt on the Righteous Mind
- Politics must be analyzed at multiple emergent levels simultaneously (individual psychology, neural, sociological), and the Republican Party's higher-level social constructs have progressively drifted out of tune with the moral intuitions and psychology of its voters, explaining the unexpected failure of establishment candidates.Jonathan Haidt
- The best criticism of moral foundations theory is simply that it has left some things out, which is surely true; the theory was always presented as a first pass from extensive reading rather than a closed list of exactly five (later six) foundations, and the only critic claiming morality is just one thing (harm), Kurt Gray, offers no real argument beyond the appeal of parsimony for cramming everything into one principle.Jonathan Haidt
- Assuming all opponents share your exact goals commits a positive version of the ad hominem fallacy, but almost inevitably an ideological opponent shares more of your deep moral sentiments than you think; the failure is that people fight 'hammer and tongs' about means while never listening for common moral ends.Arthur Brooks on Love Your Enemies