Court Packing
Proposals to increase the number of Supreme Court justices to secure a favorable majority; Roosevelt's 1937 plan violated a customary norm rather than written law.
As defined in Richard Epstein on the Rule of Law 06/1/2009
Other definitions
Expanding the number of justices on a court to shift its ideological balance, cited as one way court authority can be eroded.
Claude, War, and the State of the Republic (with Dean Ball)
Where it comes up · 3
- Richard Epstein on the Rule of Law 06/1/20093 claims
- Claude, War, and the State of the Republic (with Dean Ball)1 claim
- 223 - A Conversation With Andrew Sullivan1 claim
Most important claims · 5 of 5Search all claims for “Court Packing” →
- The Supreme Court's shift in 1937 was driven by anticipated retirements and the prospect that Roosevelt would appoint new justices, and by the overwhelming 1936 Roosevelt victory; Justices Hughes and Roberts changed their jurisprudence, which Epstein reads as a response to electoral mandate rather than abject capitulation.Richard Epstein on the Rule of Law 06/1/2009
- Roosevelt's 1937 court-packing plan did not violate any written law: the Constitution does not fix the size of the Supreme Court (nine was a convention, not a requirement), but adding justices violated a sub-constitutional customary norm that gave too much power to one administration.Richard Epstein on the Rule of Law 06/1/2009
- With the Legislative Branch effectively neutered and executive power vastly expanded, the courts are the only functioning branch and the last lasting check on the executive; Roberts predicts the courts will rule for Anthropic because they see themselves as a bulwark against unconstrained executive discretion, but this check is in real tension because ultimately the executive enforces court decisions.Claude, War, and the State of the Republic (with Dean Ball)
- The mainstream and social media's instinctive suppression of the Hunter Biden laptop story—however cynically partisan its origin—reveals a rot in journalism, because the core journalistic instinct should be to surface information and let the public decide, not to control news on behalf of a preferred political outcome or social-justice agenda.223 - A Conversation With Andrew Sullivan
- The Constitution's judicial article does not fix the size of the Supreme Court, and adding justices to a court of nineteen would make it impractical for all justices to sit together, which is one reason the nine-member convention is useful.Richard Epstein on the Rule of Law 06/1/2009