Takings Clause
The constitutional provision requiring just compensation when government takes private property, serving as a safeguard against citizen values overriding property rights.
As defined in et_577
Where it comes up · 2
Most important claims · 5 of 5Search all claims for “Takings Clause” →
- There are several ways to finance government activity—borrow (taxes tomorrow), tax today, confiscate real resources, or solicit voluntary donations—and the only thing that differs across them is which group of people bears the cost and when; none of them eliminates the burden, because in every case real resources are consumed and someone pays.Don Boudreaux on Public Debt
- Justice Holmes's formulation in Pennsylvania Coal v. Mahon that regulation is a taking 'when it goes too far' is vapid, and combined with the Supreme Court's takings jurisprudence this produces a dreadful intellectual mess in which nobody knows when land regulations go too far, generating enormous value destruction through landmark preservation and Endangered Species Act habitat rules.Richard Epstein on the Rule of Law 06/1/2009
- Just compensation requirements neutralize down-zoning threats: if a government must pay a landowner the value lost when a parcel is reduced from $100,000 to $10,000, the threat becomes idle because the government can force the reduction only by paying the full loss, so the takings clause protects against arbitrary power.Richard Epstein on the Rule of Law 06/1/2009
- In the Lucas litigation, South Carolina changed its rules in the middle of the case, imposing impossible procedural restrictions on bringing takings claims and substantive requirements that made valuing the owner's entitlement impossible, thereby evading the full-compensation rule.Richard Epstein on the Rule of Law 06/1/2009
- In Lucas v. South Carolina Coastal Council, Justice Scalia held that a land-use restriction that wipes out the entire economic value of land is a taking requiring compensation, but refused to specify how much value must be lost before a regulation counts as a wipeout; Epstein proposes that compensation plus residual use value should always sum to the land's full prior value (for example, a house permitted only at 10x10 feet should be compensated for the value lost above the residual value).Richard Epstein on the Rule of Law 06/1/2009