What this covers

This is a roughly half-hour lecture-style summary by Jeffrey Kaplan of Peter Singer's 1972 paper "Famine, Affluence and Morality." Kaplan states that the views are Singer's, not his own, and he disabled comments because of threatening and abusive replies. The summary walks through the paper as a numbered argument. It first sets up the technical distinction between the supererogatory, meaning praiseworthy but not required, and the obligatory, meaning required on pain of moral failure. Singer's claim is that most people file giving to famine relief under the first heading and feel no guilt about spending on luxuries, when it belongs under the second.

The argument is then taken one premise at a time. The first is a general principle about preventing very bad things when nothing of moral significance is lost. The second, that hunger, disease, and death are very bad, is treated as nearly uncontroversial. The third depends on how Singer defines luxuries such as new clothes, cars, and restaurant meals. The fourth is an empirical claim that organizations like Oxfam and UNICEF really do use donations effectively.

Most of the contentious material concerns the gap between the drowning child and distant famine. Singer identifies two candidate differences, proximity and the presence of other potential donors. He dismisses proximity because modern communication and efficient aid organizations let us know of distant suffering and act on it. Other donors matter only if they actually help. He also rejects the worry that private giving will cause governments to cut their own aid.

Kaplan also covers the objection that the demand is too much. Singer's reply is that this is a standard complaint against utilitarian views, which he endorses, and that how demanding a conclusion is does not show it false. Singer favors the stronger version, which asks people to give until they approach the level of those they help. Kaplan notes that the argument applies to nearly anyone in a capitalist society, and that philosophers' clever counterarguments have not been decisive.

Sharpest takeaway

Peter Singer argues that affluent people have a moral obligation to donate most of their discretionary income to famine relief organizations because preventing easily preventable deaths is morally mandatory, not supererogatory, and proximity and the presence of other potential donors are morally irrelevant.

  • If we can prevent something very bad without sacrificing anything of moral significance, we must do so—a principle that generalizes from the intuitive drowning child example to famine relief
  • Proximity and the presence of other potential donors are not morally relevant differences between the drowning child case and global famine relief, because modern communication and efficient aid organizations have eliminated the practical barriers that once made proximity matter
  • The conclusion follows that spending money on luxuries (new clothes, coffee, cars) while people die of preventable famines is morally equivalent to letting a child drown to avoid muddy clothes

The claims · ranked19 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.66

The distinction between the supererogatory (morally praiseworthy but not required actions) and the obligatory (morally required actions) is a technical philosophical distinction that is central to understanding Singer's argument.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Peter Singer - ordinary people are evil [KVl5kMXz1vA]

“Okay. If we're going to understand this argument, then we need one distinction to start out. This is a technical distinction, but there's really only one technical term. Here you go. We're talking about the distinction between the supererogatory and the obligatory.”

0.66

Singer responds to the objection that his moral requirement is 'too demanding' by noting that this is a standard objection to utilitarianism, which he endorses, and that the demanding nature of morality is not an argument against the truth of his conclusion.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Peter Singer - ordinary people are evil [KVl5kMXz1vA]

“To that, Singer says a couple things. One thing he says is, look, that is a standard, you know, objection to utilitarianism. And Singer is himself a utilitarian or at least he's a consequentialist. I can't remember. Anyway, he's close to a utilitarian and he could be for the purposes of this paper. So, well, it's a standard objection against utilitarianism that it's too demanding, but Singer just thinks that this is a very weak objection. Maybe morality is very demanding. The argument seems to work. The fact that you don't like the conclusion, which is really what the too demanding objection comes to, the fact that you don't like the conclusion is not an argument that the conclusion is false.”

0.66

Peter Singer's 1972 paper 'Famine, Affluence and Morality' argues that people's general moral outlook is deeply and profoundly wrong regarding their obligations to prevent distant suffering.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Peter Singer - ordinary people are evil [KVl5kMXz1vA]

“Today we're talking about an absolutely revolutionary paper published by a philosopher named Peter Singer in 1972. The name of the paper is famine, affluence and morality.”

0.61

People currently view giving money to famine relief organizations as supererogatory—something praiseworthy but not morally required—and do not feel shame or guilt about spending money on luxuries instead of donating to famine relief.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Peter Singer - ordinary people are evil [KVl5kMXz1vA]

“Because giving money is regarded as an act of charity, it is not thought that there is anything wrong with not giving. The charitable person may be praised, but the person who is not charitable is not condemned. People do not feel in any way ashamed or guilty about spending money on new clothes or a new car instead of giving it to famine relief.”

0.61

Singer thinks the stronger version of his argument (you must give away so much as to reduce yourself nearly to the level of those you are saving) is the correct one and his argument basically works for this stronger principle.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Peter Singer - ordinary people are evil [KVl5kMXz1vA]

“And Singer actually thinks this argument basically works for the stronger principle. You have to give up a lot.”

0.61

The argument presented by Singer seems to be a good argument, and it has seemed that way to everyone who has read his 1972 paper, which is why the argument is so difficult to refute.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Peter Singer - ordinary people are evil [KVl5kMXz1vA]

“That's a new thing. like you probably don't think that you and your family are evil, but the argument seems to show that it's a very radical conclusion and the problem is it's very hard to see what's wrong with the argument. The argument seems like a good one and it has seemed that way to everyone who read this paper since 1972.”

0.60

An action is obligatory if it is morally required—the agent must do it, they had a commitment to do it, and if they fail to do it, they have failed a moral obligation.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Peter Singer - ordinary people are evil [KVl5kMXz1vA]

“Something is obligatory if you have to do it. Right? So, if someone is assigned in the group to bring coffee and breakfast to every early morning meeting and you signed up, you promised, you committed to bringing coffee and breakfast on that day. Well, then bringing coffee and breakfast is obligatory.”

0.60

An action is supererogatory if it is morally good and praiseworthy but not obligatory—the agent did not have to do it, and if they do not do it, they have not failed a moral obligation.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Peter Singer - ordinary people are evil [KVl5kMXz1vA]

“That act, that action is super derogatory. It's extra. It's super. You didn't have to do it, but it was a really nice thing to do. It was an extra thing that you did and it was a good thing to do. It was not obligatory.”

0.56

Singer's central claim in 'Famine, Affluence and Morality' is that charitable giving to famine relief organizations is obligatory, not supererogatory—meaning affluent people must give money to relief agencies like Oxfam and UNICEF instead of spending it on luxuries.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Peter Singer - ordinary people are evil [KVl5kMXz1vA]

“Singer says, 'No, here's an argument that proves Singer thinks that giving to charity, giving extra money to famine relief, if you're affluent, if you have extra money, is something that you must do. You must do it in the same way that you must not murder or you must catch someone if they're if they're falling and you can just reach out your arms and catch them and save them. You must do it. That's the thesis.”

0.55

Premise Four is empirically true because relief organizations like Oxfam actually do effectively use donated money to prevent hunger, disease, suffering, disability, and death.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Peter Singer - ordinary people are evil [KVl5kMXz1vA]

“Is it true? By donating money to relief agencies like Oxfam, we could prevent hunger, disease, and other sources of suffering, disability, and death. Yes. Premise four is true. This is true. These organizations do do this. You can give them the money and then they will prevent these things. This premise 4 is just an empirical claim. It's just a claim about whether these organizations actually do the thing that they say they're going to do. And the answer is yes, they do do it.”

0.52

Singer argues that proximity is no longer morally relevant because modern communication technology allows people to know about distant suffering while it occurs, and efficient organizations now exist that can effectively transfer money across the world to save distant people's lives.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Peter Singer - ordinary people are evil [KVl5kMXz1vA]

“It used to be that proximity made a significant moral difference because it used to be that a great distance prevented people from knowing about about very bad things. It used to be that if there was some very bad thing happening on the other side of the world several hundred years ago, you could never know about that very bad thing or you couldn't find out about it for months or years. But now now proximity is irrelevant to your knowledge of very bad things because there's very efficient forms of communication. You can know about a famine going on in another country while it's going on with enough time to do something about it.”

0.51

Premise One of Singer's argument is: If it is in our power to prevent something very bad from happening without thereby sacrificing anything of moral significance, then we must morally prevent that very bad thing from happening.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Peter Singer - ordinary people are evil [KVl5kMXz1vA]

“One, if it is in our power to prevent something very bad from happening without thereby sacrificing anything of moral significance, then we must morally do it. That is, prevent that very bad thing from happening. Okay, that's premise one.”

0.51

Singer argues that the presence of other people who could help is morally relevant only if those other people actually do help; if they do not help, the obligation falls on you regardless of whether others could help.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Peter Singer - ordinary people are evil [KVl5kMXz1vA]

“He says, 'L the presence of others who could help is sort of relevant because their presence typically leads to they're actually helping those other people actually helping prevent the very bad thing. So if there were other people who saw the child drowning in the shallow pond, well then very likely one of those other people would save the child and then you wouldn't have to save the child.”

0.45

Singer considers and rejects the objection that if private individuals donate heavily to famine relief, governments will reduce their own aid, resulting in insufficient total relief.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — Peter Singer - ordinary people are evil [KVl5kMXz1vA]

“He considers another argument. This is on page 239. Another argument that goes like this. If private individuals start donating money to famine relief, then governments will stop. And if governments stop donating money because the private individuals have got it taken care of, well then very bad things will result um there won't be enough money because the governments are the real source of the money or whatever. Sing response to this part of his response is to just say don't worry about it.”

0.43

Singer's argument can be applied to any person living in a broadly capitalistic society in the 21st century, regardless of their specific life circumstances, beliefs, or values, because Singer needs only basic assumptions about their social and historical context to conclude their entire life needs reworking to be morally acceptable.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Peter Singer - ordinary people are evil [KVl5kMXz1vA]

“I can basically make some assumptions about my audience. You know, general assumptions. You live in a broadly capitalistic society, let's assume, you know, there are government regulations and that sort of thing. And you live sometime in the beginningish of the 21st century. That's basically enough. If that's true of you, then Singer thinks that your whole life needs to be reworked if you're going to live in a morally acceptable way.”

0.43

Once Singer's definition of luxuries is understood, Premise Three is clearly true because giving up luxuries like new clothes, new cars, or restaurant meals when old clothes and homemade food suffice is not a morally significant sacrifice.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Peter Singer - ordinary people are evil [KVl5kMXz1vA]

“So once we understand what Singer means by luxuries, he's right. These things are not of moral significance. They're not a big deal. If you go without them, you're not really worse off.”

0.43

There are two potentially morally relevant differences between the drowning child example and the example of giving up luxuries to save people from famine: proximity (physical nearness) and the presence of others who could help.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Peter Singer - ordinary people are evil [KVl5kMXz1vA]

“There's two ways in which there might be a relevant difference. These are the two relevant differences that Singer considers and responds to. Here they are. Okay, here's the first potentially relevant difference. Proximity.”

0.34

Premise Two is very plausible and uncontroversial because it simply identifies hunger, disease, suffering, disability, and death as very bad things that virtually everyone agrees are bad.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Peter Singer - ordinary people are evil [KVl5kMXz1vA]

“Premise two, by the way, seems totally plausible. Hunger is very bad. Real hunger, where someone doesn't have enough food to eat. And disease and other things that cause people to suffer or become disabled or die. All of that is bad. Yep. Okay, good job. Premise two, very plausible.”

0.29

Philosophers have attempted clever and careful arguments to show that Singer's argument does not work, though these responses have not been decisive.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Peter Singer - ordinary people are evil [KVl5kMXz1vA]

“There are responses to it and there are philosophers who try very hard and have very clever, careful things to say to try to show that this argument doesn't actually work. But at least until we get to read some of those arguments, you should try to see if there's anything wrong with this argument yourself.”