supererogatory
Describing acts that go beyond what is required or expected of a person—above and beyond moral duty
As defined in Alexandra Hudson on the Soul of Civility
Where it comes up · 3
- Peter Singer - ordinary people are evil4 claims
- Michael Munger on John Locke, Prices, and Hurricane Sandy1 claim
- Alexandra Hudson on the Soul of Civility1 claim
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “supererogatory” →
- Drawing on the distinction between erogatory acts (paying or giving what is due) and supererogatory acts (heroic acts beyond duty), Locke argues that in a market setting one is obliged to engage in the voluntary transaction—to sell the horse or grain at the price one would charge anyone—analogous to throwing a life ring to a drowning person, but is not obliged to sell at a self-sacrificing price (which would be supererogatory).Michael Munger on John Locke, Prices, and Hurricane Sandy
- The distinction between the supererogatory (morally praiseworthy but not required actions) and the obligatory (morally required actions) is a technical philosophical distinction that is central to understanding Singer's argument.Peter Singer - ordinary people are evil
- People currently view giving money to famine relief organizations as supererogatory—something praiseworthy but not morally required—and do not feel shame or guilt about spending money on luxuries instead of donating to famine relief.Peter Singer - ordinary people are evil
- An action is supererogatory if it is morally good and praiseworthy but not obligatory—the agent did not have to do it, and if they do not do it, they have not failed a moral obligation.Peter Singer - ordinary people are evil
- Singer's central claim in 'Famine, Affluence and Morality' is that charitable giving to famine relief organizations is obligatory, not supererogatory—meaning affluent people must give money to relief agencies like Oxfam and UNICEF instead of spending it on luxuries.Peter Singer - ordinary people are evil
- Adam Smith's distinction between justice and beneficence maps the spectrum of civility: justice is the bare minimum a society needs to survive—what you owe others—while beneficence is active goodness, the supererogatory above-and-beyond acts that are not expected of you but are good for their own sake.Alexandra Hudson on the Soul of Civility