utilitarian
Pertaining to the ethical view that the right action maximizes overall well-being (pleasure minus pain) summed across all affected beings.
As defined in Paul Bloom
Where it comes up · 17
- Sam Bankman-Fried3 claims
- 188 - A Conversation With Paul Bloom3 claims
- 285 | Nate Silver on Prediction, Risk, and Rationality2 claims
- What if the truth offends? Publish it anyway | Peter Singer2 claims
- Bridging Science, Medicine, and Returns1 claim
- Larissa MacFarquhar1 claim
- Paul Bloom1 claim
- Byrne Hobart - FTX, Drugs, Twitter, Taiwan, & Monasticism1 claim
and 9 more
Most important claims · 10 of 23Search all claims for “utilitarian” →
- Decoupling has a downside resembling 'engineer's disease': because it's easy to build a bad, oversimplified model that describes the past but isn't robust to the future, the same decoupling tendency that yields nuance can also lead Riverians to ignore real-world subtleties—as with Sam Bankman-Fried quantifying everything in crazy, imprecise ways.285 | Nate Silver on Prediction, Risk, and Rationality
- The liberty movement's schism rests on a real methodological difference: economists use consequentialist or utilitarian arguments, while political philosophers like the followers of Ayn Rand favor the moral case, and these two approaches genuinely have different policy implications.Michael Munger on the Perfect vs. the Good
- Utilitarian expected-value reasoning works cleanly only with finite numbers; once you admit the possibility of infinite utility, you must compare hierarchies of infinity, linearity breaks down, and addition stops behaving normally—a genuinely relevant unknown that no one has a good account of and that leaves serious thinkers more confused rather than satisfied.Sam Bankman-Fried
- In the early 19th century, Jeremy Bentham, the founder of the Utilitarian School, wrote essays strongly attacking the idea that it should be a crime for anyone to have sex with someone of their own sex, arguing as a utilitarian that this experience is enjoyable for consenting adults and does no harm to anyone else.What if the truth offends? Publish it anyway | Peter Singer
- Bankman-Fried's effective altruism commits the same sin as an authoritarian central planner: believing one knows how to fix the world, asserting that one's planning is superior to the market's trial and error.Arnold Kling on Twitter, FTX, and ChatGPT
- Many who are shocked by Singer's arguments about ending the lives of severely suffering, non-viable infants are simultaneously comfortable with abortion under any circumstance, which is incoherent: the moral difference between late abortion and Singer's cases is one of degree, not kind, so a pro-choice person who is outraged at Singer is deeply confused, whereas a consistent opponent who treats any abortion as murder at least has the veneer of consistency.188 - A Conversation With Paul Bloom
- As a committed utilitarian, Singer is forced to do the moral math on hard cases—such as a lifeboat choice between a human child with cognitive ability below the smartest orangutan and the orangutan—where the morally relevant question becomes which being is more capable of a good life, potentially ranking the orangutan above the child; this is the kind of uncomfortable but serious conclusion that follows from consistent application of the framework.188 - A Conversation With Paul Bloom
- Effective altruism, a utilitarian doctrine, has few objections in principle but in practice fails to be as effective as it should be because it is very difficult to resist the surer short-term goods (like deworming medicine or bed nets) over the riskier, longer-term, and ultimately more important investments in political change and institutions.Larissa MacFarquhar
- From a pure Benthamite standpoint, life extension research is not the most pressing problem because the replacement cost of human life is low—we have flourished without it and can grow utility more cheaply by creating new lives than by saving existing ones—though feedback mechanisms and international coordination effects complicate any simple birth-subsidy conclusion.Sam Bankman-Fried
- Even granting that focusing on growth would make future generations much better off, today's horribly poor people still exist, and depending on one's moral calculus — e.g., that we are only as good as the least among us — it remains defensible and worthwhile to spend substantial effort alleviating present poverty rather than sacrificing the current generation for future ones.Chris Blattman on Chickens, Cash, and Development Economics