brain in a vat
A philosophical thought experiment imagining a disembodied brain fed experiences; used here as a metaphor for living purely mentally while neglecting the body.
As defined in Tom Cruise's Body of Work (with Aled Maclean-Jones)
Where it comes up · 7
- Tom Cruise's Body of Work (with Aled Maclean-Jones)1 claim
- Intersubjectivity, Social Objectivity, and the Free & Equal Other | Existential Basics ep.61 claim
- 198 - A Conversation With Paul Bloom1 claim
- 115 - Sam Harris Lawrence Krauss And Matt Dillahunty 11 claim
- 105 - Richard Dawkins Sam Harris And Matt Dillahunty1 claim
- 262 | Eric Schwitzgebel on the Weirdness of the World1 claim
- Sam Harris & Yuval Harari - Suffering Makes Us Real1 claim
Most important claims · 7 of 7Search all claims for “brain in a vat” →
- If experience is fundamentally subjective in nature, it is paradoxical that individual people can report experiencing a similar reality, since each person could be a brain in a vat with no certainty that others see the same world as they do.Intersubjectivity, Social Objectivity, and the Free & Equal Other | Existential Basics ep.6
- Consciousness is the one fact that cannot be an illusion: even in a simulation, dream, or brain-in-a-vat scenario, something seems to be happening, and that seeming is consciousness; everything else (body, free will, self) could be illusory, but the existence of experience itself cannot be doubted.115 - Sam Harris Lawrence Krauss And Matt Dillahunty 1
- The deeper danger of screens is not merely attention or concentration but alienation: when deeply absorbed in scrolling, one quickly forgets one's own body exists, and a person can live largely as a 'brain in a vat' fueling the mind with content while neglecting embodied existence.Tom Cruise's Body of Work (with Aled Maclean-Jones)
- Consciousness is the one thing in the universe that cannot be an illusion because even under conditions of radical skepticism (brain in a vat, hard drive in alien supercomputer, or any deceived state about external reality), the fact that something seems to be happening is itself an undeniable demonstration of consciousness.Sam Harris & Yuval Harari - Suffering Makes Us Real
- Skeptical scenarios should be divided into ungrounded skepticism (hypotheticals like being a brain in a vat or an inception scenario, for which there is no positive reason beyond mere logical possibility) and grounded skepticism (starting from ordinary background assumptions and finding a positive reason for doubt)—and dream skepticism is grounded, because we dream every night and some mainstream theories of dreaming hold that we sometimes have stable, mundane experiences indistinguishable from waking life.262 | Eric Schwitzgebel on the Weirdness of the World
- The fact that there is something it is like to be you in this moment—that experience seems any way at all—is the one thing you cannot be wrong about, undeniable even if you are dreaming, a brain in a vat, or in the matrix, and this is distinct from the hard problem of why consciousness exists; but the self, unlike consciousness, can be shown to be illusory.198 - A Conversation With Paul Bloom
- Consciousness—the felt sense that something is going on, the experiential quality of any state—is the one thing in the universe that cannot be an illusion, because it is always the first fact before any other fact can be discussed; whether you are a brain in a vat or in a simulation, the lights being on is the precondition for everything else.105 - Richard Dawkins Sam Harris And Matt Dillahunty