
Bryan Caplan on Hayek, Richter, and Socialism 06/28/2010
What this covers
Bryan Caplan and Russ Roberts discuss two historical warnings against socialism: Eugene Richter's 1891 dystopian novel Pictures of the Socialistic Future and F. A. Hayek's 1944 The Road to Serfdom. Both books diagnose the failure of state socialism, but Caplan argues they differ in their explanation of why. Rather than accepting the common view that power corrupts well-intentioned people, Caplan presents Richter's account of socialism's leaders as "born bad"—zealous ideologues whose commitment to totalitarian coercion was never incidental to their project but central to it. The pair trace how both authors identified Germany's intellectual and political traditions as the model for understanding socialism's dangers, and how the subsequent division of Germany into East and West provided what Caplan calls a "natural experiment" that should have settled the debate definitively.
The conversation ranges across how state socialism collapses without competition and incentives, requiring coercion to retain talent and labor. It examines the genealogy of modern Western Social Democrats as descendants of those who abandoned true socialism once they grasped its lethal requirements, while East German communists kept faith with complete state management. Caplan and Roberts also discuss implications for contemporary governance: how regulatory frameworks designed as fixed costs harm small firms and entrench large ones, how the rule of law depends on predictability rather than literal generality, and how government bailouts beginning in the 1980s created irreversible precedents that reshaped market expectations. The episode touches on the conceptual overlap Hayek drew between communism and fascism, the psychology of different kinds of ruthlessness, and the difficulty politicians face defending markets that work imperfectly but better than alternatives.
Caplan and Roberts argue that the catastrophes of 20th-century socialism were not the corruption of good people by power but the predictable result of zealous true-believers pursuing inherently coercive goals, and that Richter and Hayek correctly diagnosed both the incentive failures and the human dynamics of state socialism.
- Richter's 'born bad' theory holds socialism's leaders were always near-sociopathic zealots, not corrupted altruists
- State socialism eliminates competition and incentives, causing productivity collapse and requiring coercion to retain talent
- Modern Social Democrats are descendants of the 'sellouts' who abandoned true socialism once they saw it required mass killing
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Imposing a fixed regulatory cost (where every business must pay the same compliance expense regardless of size) is the worst thing you can do if you want many small firms, because it increases firm size and reduces the number of firms that can survive — exemplified by FDA regulation requiring pharmaceutical manufacturers to be very large.
“if you want to have a large number of small firms the worst thing that you can do is to impose a fixed regulatory cost where every... business you need to pay a hundred thousand dollars worth of expenses no matter how big or how small you are because then basically... increasing the size and reducing the number of firms”
Richter offers a 'born bad' theory of socialism's failure that differs from both Lord Acton's 'power corrupts good people' theory and Hayek's 'why the worst get on top' theory: socialists were never nice people but were always deluded totalitarian zealots whose sincere idealism was itself an ideal of doing terrible things to people.
“Richter presents a third very different story called the born bad story the story that the socialists were never nice people”
Both Richter and Hayek deliberately focused on Germany as the model of socialism's danger; Hayek (writing in 1944 with the USSR as Britain's ally) chose Germany because it was the enemy whose goals Britain was paradoxically adopting, and because he argued the intellectual roots of Nazism were German ideas being readily adopted by Americans and the English.
“Hayek also deliberately avoids talking about the Soviet Union the book was written in 1944 in the middle of World War two when the Soviet Union was our ally... he deliberately chose Germany as his model because for two reasons”
When regulation makes a business unprofitable, it is generally consumers who pay the price rather than the businesses themselves, because unprofitable firms exit and others sell the product at a price that remains profitable.
“generally these consumers who wind up paying the price rather than business themselves... the way that we often think about the effective regulation is... we're getting tough with this business really we're getting tough with the people who buy the product”
The true ideological descendants of the 19th-century German Social Democratic Party are the East German communists who kept faith with complete state management of the economy, while modern Western Social Democrats are descendants of 'sellouts' who, upon realizing socialism required killing many people, abandoned much of it because killing is bad even if Marx sanctioned it.
“the purest the true believers they're the ones who became the true monsters and the people that we now think of a Social Democrats they're the descendants of the sellouts”
The case against socialism was effectively settled by the natural experiment of East versus West Germany, which provided overwhelming evidence no regression could overturn — yet the debate may not be over because generations who lived through it die off and new generations who only read about it adopt different attitudes.
“they had a remarkable social experiment there and the evidence was overwhelming you couldn't there's no regression you could run... not only was it not delivering the goods it was an appalling non-economic experiment”
Hayek's 'rule of law' is best understood not literally (general non-arbitrary rules could include absurd ones like mandatory orange jumpsuits) but as a code word combining generality, reasonableness, and especially predictability — the conditions that let individuals plan, since Hayek opposed government 'planning' (top-down state planning) while championing the framework that enables individual planning.
“what he meant to say was that look the rule of law is this code word for not only do we have regular laws but the laws have to be reasonable ones that don't persecute people”
Government interventions that set a precedent permanently change how people think and are very hard to take back — illustrated by Iran confiscating fled people's property circa 1980 and offering it back 20 years later, with few returning, because trust, once broken, does not reset.
“around 1980 the government of Iran under the ayatollah sort of confiscating property of people who'd fled the country then 20 years later they went and... saying you can have it back sorry and you can imagine how many people immediately got on the first plane back to Iran”
The single most important contribution of The Road to Serfdom is its recognition that communism and fascism are fundamentally the same — both rest on top-down centralized planning and share common intellectual roots in Germany.
“the single most important part of that book is the recognition that communism and and fascism are the same... they're both about top-down centralized planning of comedy Elektra roots and have common intellectual roots which pointing that in Germany”
A person living a personally modest, ascetic life (like Stalin sleeping on a cot) is not evidence of being a good person, because someone can be both hard on himself and a violent zealot who enjoys destroying other people's lives.
“Stalin for example by all accounts that I have read lived an extremely modest life... and yet he murdered millions of people and so you might look at him say well you see she's so hard on himself he must be a nice guy and not necessarily”
Under state socialism, removing financial incentives causes productivity and wealth to fall dramatically because no one will do the hard or unpleasant jobs or try harder than anyone else.
“they quickly find of course that because of the incentive problems productivity and wealth actually go down rather dramatically”
Western nations avoided the totalitarian road not primarily through ideology but because common sense intervened: when forced to choose between going further toward socialism or doing something truly awful, people pulled back; the visible failure of East Germany versus West Germany was decisive evidence.
“a lot of it is that while the official ideology was one where it seemed like socialism away to that way to the go common sense got in the way... when it seemed like you had to choose between like you know going further toward socialism or doing something truly awful... I guess we don't really need to go to go as far as it seems”
The rescue of creditors (not just bailouts), beginning around 1984 and including the 1995 Mexican loan guarantee that actually rescued Mexico's lenders and was deemed a 'success' because the guarantee was never invoked, sent a signal that large financial institutions could keep lending to risky enterprises without bearing the consequences of default — culminating in the 2008 crisis and the misallocation of scarce capital.
“the relentless bailout of creditors other than Lehman Brothers certainly the rescue of Bear Stearns creditors AIG s in particular”
A useful dividing line between sociopaths and ordinary murderers is whether they can readily do horrible things to people personally known to them: Stalin enjoyed imprisoning the wives of his own colleagues, whereas Hitler had to work himself up for hours to harm people he personally knew while readily murdering millions of strangers.
“one very common dividing line that people make between sociopaths and simple murderers is that the sociopath doesn't mind doing horrible things to people that are very personally well known to him”
Eugene Richter's 1893 novel 'Pictures of the Socialistic Future' was remarkably prescient, predicting 70 years before the Berlin Wall that German socialists would take power, ban emigration, and shoot people fleeing the country.
“not only did Richter write a story where the Socialists took over Germany and started shooting people fleeing the country but it was actually a amazingly prescient story about what would happen under socialism in Germany written 70 years before the rise of the wall”
Hereditary absolute monarchies could eventually produce rulers willing to voluntarily sign away power because, unlike modern dictatorships where one must fight and kill to reach the top, hereditary succession can by luck deliver someone who is not power-hungry.
“in a modern dictatorship where you have to fight to get to the top kill the people the top are always very power-hungry whereas Anna reddit erryone you actually do eventually have a chance of just getting lucky and you have someone who doesn't really want to be in charge”
Germany's Social Democrats greatly expanded the role of the state in the 1920s (well on its way to socialism), and the Nazis, rather than reversing this, extended it further; the main difference from Soviet communism was agriculture, where both the Social Democrats and Nazis declined to confiscate peasant land because Lenin's and Stalin's attempts had caused massive productivity declines.
“there was a very large expansion of the role of government in Germany in the 20s under under the Social Democratic Party of Germany and then when the Nazis took over they took that very large and very very very large government... and they added more socialism”
Hayek did not actually claim that any step toward socialism inevitably leads to a totalitarian state; he warned of a moderately slippery slope where, if no deliberate effort is made to stop further socialism, one may eventually fall off the edge.
“he tries to avoid making hyperbolic claims about how like you know some small amount of socialism is going to send a straight to herion ISM but... he is concerned about maybe not a super slippery slope but a moderately slippery slope”
The more pressing danger today is not formal nationalization but de facto state control through 'implicit ownership' — where government may return firms (like GM) to private property in name, yet they become so entangled with and dependent on government support that they effectively act as state industries, with government as an active rather than silent partner.
“what I'd rather see is the is the implicit ownership of government's where you know government may say general and General Motors the auto industry the private property again but in practice they may have become so entangled and so dependent upon the government... that they pretty much wind up acting like a state industry”
Compliance specialization over the last twenty years (e.g., Sarbanes-Oxley consultants) has made it easier for large companies to avoid competition because they can absorb compliance as a fixed overhead cost their size accommodates, whereas smaller companies cannot.
“you have a lot of consultants who will do your sarbanes-oxley... appliance work for you but it's really done I think you know over the last twenty years has made it easier for large companies to avoid competition because they can outsource a lot of these costs and see it just as overhead a fixed cost that their size can absorb whereas smaller companies can't do that”
The TARP bailouts set an irreversible precedent: unlike rule-bound FDIC, they were unprecedented, discretionary rescues for an unregulated context, so that for at least a generation markets will now expect bailouts whenever a crisis hits, regardless of government promises not to repeat them.
“tarp in the bed and the bailouts I think that's something that's really hard to take back... it was just you know what if something goes bad will they who knows well now now we do know now we have a pretty good idea there's something like this happens it will happen again”
Businesses need not absolute certainty but reasonable foreseeability of the political and regulatory environment; what harms investment and innovation is a substantial increase in the probability of unprecedented, arbitrary government decisions — exemplified by BP being pressured into an arbitrary $20 billion fund, which is inconsistent with the rule of law.
“it's not that businesses need certainty about the rules but you know Rea reason of allah mount a certainty... the concern in recent years is not so much that we've gone from zero chance of government doing these things to... some positive probability but then we've gone from a lower probability to some some higher probability”
Politicians find it rhetorically difficult to defend market outcomes that are imperfect but better than the alternative, so they prefer to deflect attention to distracting issues — for example, arguing against climate action by pointing to China's failure to do its fair share rather than admitting a policy costs much and accomplishes little.
“one of the most effective ways to argue against doing something about global warming is to say other countries aren't doing as much... it seems more rhetorically effective in politics to say China isn't doing its fair share than to say this won't do that this is gonna cost a whole lot of money and won't do very much”
FDR's New Deal embedded 'legislative time bombs' — programs whose initial impact was trivial but which grew enormous decades later, such as Social Security and Fannie Mae (1938), the latter contributing to a crisis costing the American people over $300 billion seventy years later.
“he also also with many legislative time bombs where the original the initial impact of Social Security was trivial... and yet sixty years later it has an enormous effect so a dead Fannie Mae is at which established in 1938”
The Nazis achieved socialist control without formal nationalization through de facto ownership of people, captured by Hitler's reported line: 'we don't need to take your cow because as long as we own you' — control over those running the firms was sufficient.
“the line that you get from Hitler is pretty much look we don't need to take your cow because as long as we own you right so... as long as we actually have complete control over the people running it so that's good enough”
Much of the original Nazi program was protecting failed, outmoded business models from competition (planks against department stores and chain stores), making the Nazis effectively the original anti-Walmart movement.
“a lot of the Nazi program was basically protecting failed outmoded business models from competition... there were planks against department stores chain stores you could say the Nazis were sort of the original anti-walmart movement”
There is no benign dictator in history; essentially every leader who has held something close to absolute power has been corrupted beyond words.
“I don't think there's a benign dictator in history can you think of one... all the leaders that I can think of who have had something close to what Lord Acton would call absolute power we're corrupted beyond beyond words”
Repeated bailouts have damaged the financial system's core function of allocating scarce capital to its highest-valued use, and even a Fed insider (Gary Stern, co-author of 'Too Big to Fail') admitted he would have rescued the firms because it was a political problem, implying we need new mechanisms — though it is unclear whether such mechanisms or the political institutions to enforce them can be designed.
“the tragedy is we have in many ways destroyed the financial system that it is are really as a source of our productivity... it's supposed to be how it capital gets allocated to its highest valued use capital scarce and we're not allocating to its highest valued use”
American social welfare spending will inevitably grow for demographic reasons, and recent legislative changes are amplifying rather than dampening these demographic effects, so government will get bigger unless a major effort is made to stop it.
“for the social overspending the trendline is way up just for demographic reasons and then on top of that new programs have been adopted... government is definitely gonna get bigger... right now actually... the changes legislation are amplifying rather than dampening the these demographic effects”
Soviet 'industrialization' is better described as 'militarization' because so much of it was geared toward building a modern army rather than producing what consumers wanted; the central planning question was secondary to producing guns.
“when we talk about Soviet dust realization so much of it was geared towards the military that I think a really a better term is actually militarization... It's more about building up a modern a modern army than it is about building up a modern economy where you find what people want”
It is easier than ever to start one's own business for technological reasons (the internet enabling self-employment), but harder than 25-40 years ago to start a business that has employees, mainly due to litigation risk and compliance burdens rather than formal regulation.
“it's easier to start your own business much easier mainly for technological reasons... but we're offsetting it somewhat if you want to have employees and be a going concern”
A captured Polish brother judged the Germans worse than the Soviets in their respective labor camps precisely because the Germans believed in their ideology and rigidly followed the rules, whereas ordinary Russians pitied the prisoners and were willing to bend the rules — suggesting that under a terrible regime, arbitrariness can be necessary to stay alive.
“so which was worse you know the Russians the German says the Germans were definitely worse why because they believed it and they followed the rules”
Hayek in The Road to Serfdom was not an anarchist and was willing to support government involvement in anti-pollution where there are public externalities, and even to stomach government policy aimed at increasing competition where it could do so better than alternatives.
“he's not an anarchist... he certainly in the Road to Serfdom is willing to seek out rent involvement in anti-pollution places where there's public externalities... and he's even willing to see to stomach government in policy and regulation to increase competition if it could do so”
Bismarck pursued conservative socialist policies such as social security and accident insurance out of pure pragmatism, and it took other civilized countries decades to catch up to what he had implemented.
“it's well known I think by most folks that Bismarck pushed so-called liberal or socialistic policies such as social security conservative socialism... accident insurance was actually probably the bigger deal at the time”
Under socialism the state confiscates or destroys savings because accumulated savings constitute capital, the root of capitalism, which is the root of exploitation.
“the state confiscates or makes worthless all savings accounts because if people accumulate savings then there's the possibility of exploitation because after all when you have savings you have capital and that's the root of capitalism which is the root of exploitation”