voluntary Socialism
A socialist community whose members join and may leave by choice, without state coercion, distinguishing it from compulsory communist regimes.
As defined in Ran Abramitzky on the Mystery of the Kibbutz
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 3 of 3Search all claims for “voluntary Socialism” →
- Large-scale socialism tends to become totalitarian because solving incentive problems by force (e.g., a Russian kolkhoz killing those who try to exit) is an effective but ugly way to prevent exit; the kibbutz is notable for solving these incentive problems voluntarily, but the byproducts—lack of privacy and suppressed individual freedom—are costs many people find unacceptable, which is why kibbutzim never exceeded 7% of the population and exist only in Israel.Ran Abramitzky on the Mystery of the Kibbutz
- Because membership was voluntary with free exit, the kibbutz uniquely reveals how many people actually choose egalitarian living when they can—unlike former Communist countries where people could not vote against socialism or exit at will—and the answer that at most 7% of the Jewish population chose it suggests a real limit to the appeal of the egalitarian model even when successful.Ran Abramitzky on the Mystery of the Kibbutz
- The founders of the kibbutz were idealistic socialists and Zionists who explicitly wanted to create a 'new human being'—the opposite of homo economicus—who cares more about the collective than himself, and they wanted membership to be voluntary rather than coerced.Ran Abramitzky on the Mystery of the Kibbutz