causal

Voluntary Socialism Avoids Totalitarian Coercion

Large-scale socialism tends to become totalitarian because solving incentive problems by force (e.g., a Russian kolkhoz killing those who try to exit) is an effective but ugly way to prevent exit; the kibbutz is notable for solving these incentive problems voluntarily, but the byproducts—lack of privacy and suppressed individual freedom—are costs many people find unacceptable, which is why kibbutzim never exceeded 7% of the population and exist only in Israel.

causalpending

Speaker

Ran Abramitzky

Evidence Quote

“it's not surprising that often places that try to be like Socialists are often totalitarian and they put big restrictions on the ability of people to move... What's nice about the kibbutzim is that they try to do it without such measures.”

Source

Ran Abramitzky on the Mystery of the Kibbutz— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:07:25 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...