vitalism
The (now-discredited) view that living tissue is governed by special laws of nature distinct from those governing non-living matter.
As defined in 158 | David Wallace on the Arrow of Time
Other definitions
A philosophical and biological view that life is a creative, non-mechanistic force; life is not reducible to physics and chemistry but represents an irreducible élan or vital impulse.
A History of Philosophy | 68 Historical Roots of Existentialism: Kierkegaard
Where it comes up · 7
- A History of Philosophy | 39 Leibinz's "Monads"2 claims
- 113 - Consciousness And The Self1 claim
- 264 - Consciousness And Self Rebroadcast1 claim
- Sara Walker #31 claim
- 158 | David Wallace on the Arrow of Time1 claim
- Does Consciousness Extend Beyond Brains? The 2023 Holberg Debate, feat. Seth, Luhrmann, Sheldrake.1 claim
- A History of Philosophy | 15 Epicurean Philosophy1 claim
Most important claims · 8 of 8Search all claims for “vitalism” →
- Even granting that philosophical zombies are nomologically and conceptually impossible, the hard problem retains force for Harris because explanations of consciousness do not seem to promise the same intuitive closure as other scientific explanations: everything about life except conscious experience can be defined in extrinsic functional relations among parts, but adding 'there is something it is like to be this process' appears to be a brute correlation rather than an illuminating explanation.113 - Consciousness And The Self
- Unlike Aristotle's vitalism or Plato's dualism, Epicureanism views the soul not as a life-force or eternal immaterial entity but as a perishable configuration of atoms identical in nature to the body and equally subject to dissolution.A History of Philosophy | 15 Epicurean Philosophy
- The analogy between explaining life and explaining consciousness is false because everything about life except conscious experience can be defined in terms of extrinsic functional relationships among material parts, whereas consciousness adds the inexplicable fact that for some processes there is something it is like to be them, leaving a brute-fact residue that other scientific explanations do not.264 - Consciousness And Self Rebroadcast
- Life itself is not fully solved scientifically—vitalism seemed impossible until biological mechanisms were understood, but biology still hasn't fully explained what makes something alive versus non-alive.Does Consciousness Extend Beyond Brains? The 2023 Holberg Debate, feat. Seth, Luhrmann, Sheldrake.
- Modern genetics significantly changes the picture of animalism and traducianism; biological vitalism was quite popular in some circles in the 1940s, particularly in France, but 50 years makes quite a difference—vitalism became a rarity by the mid 20th century.A History of Philosophy | 39 Leibinz's "Monads"
- Vitalism is the philosophical view that life is something distinct from simply physical and chemical processes, and it continued to flourish really until the mid-20th century.A History of Philosophy | 39 Leibinz's "Monads"
- The reversibility paradox only bites if you hold a reductionist picture; early scientists could reasonably believe living tissue obeyed different laws than non-living matter, so the discovery that the world is genuinely unified and reductionist is a substantive achievement of 20th century science, not an a priori truth available to 19th century thinkers.158 | David Wallace on the Arrow of Time
- Materialists and vitalists disagree fundamentally about whether life can be fully described by matter; Walker argues vitalists were not simply wrong, because our concept of 'matter' is itself a historical invention, and if we learn to measure and rigorously describe currently unmeasured patterns, we may find matter has more properties than we thought, one of which could be life, making life a material property that still retains the mystery vitalists noticed.Sara Walker #3