
A History of Philosophy | 68 Historical Roots of Existentialism: Kierkegaard
What this covers
This is a university lecture in a history-of-philosophy series, delivered by an instructor who treats existentialism less as a system than as a focus of interest: self-conscious human existence in a broken world. The first half works through Søren Kierkegaard, beginning with his satirical essay "The Present Age," which blames Enlightenment objectivity for draining the passion that revolution would require. It then follows his three modes of life. The aesthetic stage turns inwardly hollow, with an echo of Ecclesiastes. The ethical stage is Kantian, duty-bound conformity without real anguish. The religious stage answers the hunger of Geist (Spirit)). The lecture reads the "teleological suspension of the ethical" as that hunger moving beyond the ethical, not as a lapse into immorality.
The theological middle section is the most technical. The instructor separates a Paradox, where both claims can be true in different respects, from a Hegelian contradiction. They also compare Lutheran and Reformed accounts of how divine and human attributes relate in the Incarnation, citing the Westminster Catechism for the Reformed side.
The second half turns to Friedrich Nietzsche as a possible antithesis to Kierkegaard, one the instructor doubts could be synthesized. It draws on Arthur Schopenhauer's will, H. Bradley's "My Station and Its Duties," and the black dress of Queen Victoria as a symbol of Victorian denial of the body. Topics include the death of God as a cultural diagnosis, master versus slave morality, the Übermensch, and Nietzsche's objection to Darwinian adjustment. The contested turns come at the end. Karl Barth is offered as a rebuttal, with the Incarnation as God's "yes" to nature. The instructor also notes that Nietzsche's sister, a pro-Nazi sympathizer, edited his work, which leaves doubt about what he actually wrote.
Kierkegaard establishes existentialism as a philosophy centered on subjective human existence confronted by the unknowable, requiring passionate individual response rather than objective rational proof, particularly in matters of faith and the incarnation.
- The objective path to Christian truth is incomplete because the incarnation cannot be deduced from empirical premises
- Subjective response through faith and passion to the paradox of the eternal appearing in time is the existential answer
- Three life-stages (aesthetic, ethical, religious) show how spirit demands transcendence of purely sensate and duty-bound existence
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
The aesthetic point of view in Nietzsche differs fundamentally from Kierkegaard's aesthetic stage: Nietzsche's aesthetic point of view is romanticized and represents creative individuality, which Nietzsche tries to adapt from Romanticism for his own philosophical purposes.
“notice how different this is than the aesthetic stage is pictured by Kierkegaard the aesthetic point of view remember is romanticized it's on the point of view of creative individuality creative individuality and he tries to adapt Romanticism to his own point of view”
Kierkegaard's essay 'The Present Age' is a satirical critique of the Enlightenment's emphasis on objective rationality, arguing that the loss of subjective passion makes revolution impossible because people lack the existential commitment and spontaneity to act decisively against the status quo.
“The Present Age the tidal peace is his indictment of the Enlightenment where the emphasis is on the objective past the objective path in which no body would ever dream of a revolution anything like that footnote that was published in 1848 now if you know your European history 1848 was the day of revolutions German Italian so forth but after all it's his satirical critique of the Enlightenment that's the significant thing there's no passion”
The Christian confronted by the unknowable—what cannot be demonstrated by historical evidence though it can be attested by testimony—must express this unknown through paradox, where thesis and antithesis (e.g., eternal God appearing in time) cannot be synthesized into a single conceptual unity.
“we are confronted by the unknown by the unknown and the translations always capitalized it the unknown and you you get the feeling that that phrase the unknown he is echoing Paul speech of Athens”
The teleological suspension of the ethical is not a reversion to immorality but rather a transcendence of the ethical stage driven by the inner teleology (purpose/hunger) of the human spirit itself, which seeks satisfaction beyond mere conformity to social institutions—a hunger and thirst that only religious faith can fulfill.
“there arises what he calls a teleological suspension of the ethical now catch that phrase and let it run best catch the phrase he's not talking about reverting to some immoral kind of existence it's a teleological suspension of the ethical you see an in the Hegelian tradition there is this sense of cosmic teleology the kicker God is not talking cosmic teleology Kierkegaard's talking of the inner teleology of the human spirit”
In Nietzsche's philosophy, the underlying reality is will (creative force) rather than intellect, which he calls by the French term 'ressentiment'—a subconscious opposition and negation arising from the depths, such that guilt or moral conscience becomes understood as subconscious aggression against oneself.
“underlying these sorts of reactions against enlightenment nietzsche is first of all a voluntarist the ultimate nature of things is more of the nature of will than of intellect and you'll find that everything is an expression of that he uses the term rasaan Timor French word he uses the term result amor there's no English translation of it really and so it appears just that way rasaan de Mar is a subconscious kind of opposition to something out of the subconscious negating an antithesis that theis it the antithesis negating the thesis”
Nietzsche proclaims 'God is dead' not merely as a philosophical fact but as a cultural phenomenon: God-language has become dead language with no meaning to people, and belief in God is irrelevant because Christianity has made God-belief irrelevant by saying 'no' to nature, the physical world, bodies, and emotions.
“God is dead now he uses that phrase oh I think Hegel may have been the first to use it I'm told it appears in Matthew Arnold Dostoevsky of course says if god is dead then anything is possible but Nietzsche yes talks of the death of God this is not just a philosophical fact for him it's a cultural phenomenon that is to say God language is a dead language doesn't have any meaning to people belief in God is irrelevant”
Lutheran theology holds that divine attributes and human attributes do not interpenetrate in the Incarnation, making the unity of divine and human natures difficult to conceptualize, whereas Reformed theology posits interpenetration of attributes allowing for easier conceptualization of that unity.
“Lutheran theology tends to say that the divine attributes and the human attributes don't interpenetrate so you can't define the unity of the two persons in terms of the interpenetration of the attributes reformed theology talks of the interpenetration of the attributes so you begin to conceptualize the unity”
Nietzsche's concept of the Übermensch (Superman or, to avoid modern associations, Overman) refers not to a biological super-race but to those strong-willed individuals who affirm life despite the death of God and despite Christianity's negation of life.
“he speaks therefore of ubermensch which of course translated would come out a Superman but because of associations with that in this day and age the substitute the word race and you get the idea that the strong-willed comprise a super race affirming life despite the death of God life despite Christianity's no to life affirming life”
What distinguishes a paradox from a Hegelian contradiction is that a contradiction is mutually exclusive (thesis and antithesis cannot both be true), while a paradox is a contrary where both thesis and antithesis can be true in different respects, allowing for synthesis.
“I have difficulty in seeing why those two should be antithetical although thesis antithesis synthesis is not necessarily thesis and antithesis not necessarily contradictory in logic yet the difference between a contradictory and a contrary... contradictory x's are across the diagonals that is to say a and O cannot both be true at the same time and in the same respect... on the other hand this way it's contraries some are some enough some are some aren't so if you take a paradox to be a contrary the thesis and the antithesis are contrary to each other they're not necessarily contradictory”
Nietzsche criticizes Darwinian natural selection because it treats evolution as gradual adjustment to environment, which would produce only well-adjusted conformists ('doodlers') lacking creative vitality and the force of will to resist conformity, whereas Nietzsche values creative life that defies adjustment.
“he also is critical of the Darwinian theory of natural selection because that sort of evolution thing serves life as a gradual adjustment to the environment and consequently would promise to make nothing but well-adjusted doodlers well-adjusted doodlers doodling because they don't have the creative vitality and the force of will not to adjust but all the calm whatever the opposition is to their lives rather”
Friedrich Nietzsche represents an antithesis to Kierkegaard that would be difficult or impossible to synthesize, as Kierkegaard is a religious existentialist while Nietzsche is radically irreligious, though how much of Nietzsche's rhetoric should be taken literally is unclear.
“with Friedrich Nietzsche we we have I think an antithesis that is a contradictory with regards to care that it would be hard to synthesize these to kick the guard as I as it's obvious is the religious existentialist need ship is as irreligious as one could imagine though it's it's not always clear as to how much of his rhetoric is to be taken literally”
Nietzsche's master morality versus slave morality represents an ethical relativism where what is morally good is not what benefits the maximum number of people but what benefits and furthers the creative power of the strong-willed.
“what Nietzsche gives you is a dialectic between master morality and servant morality because there are two different moralities he's an ethical relativist in the sense that the morality is the morality of be it the strong-willed or the weak-willed so what is morally right morally good is not what is good for the maximum number of people but what benefits the strong wilt and furthers their creative power”
Nietzsche's critique of Victorian morality focuses on the way it suppresses physicality, sexuality, and natural emotion, epitomized by Queen Victoria's clothing (dressed entirely in black from head to toe), representing the cultural denial of bodily existence that Nietzsche opposes.
“he's critical you see of let's call it 19th century Victorian eyes religion the kept all of the seediness and the physicality of our existence especially sexuality under wraps and you know if you want the vision of under-wraps think of the way queen victoria dressed in black from head to toe”
The ethical stage, though an improvement over the aesthetic, involves Kantian duty-bound conformity to social institutions without deep moral anguish or a conscience filled with remorse—the kind of existence where one never says 'Woe is me, I'm undone.'
“this is simply a structured life in which one has some objective duties acting if you like out of a sense of duty get who he's referring to the Kantian existence acting out of a sense of duty but without any deep moral anguish of decision without a conscience that's filled with remorse the kandia never says woe is me I'm undone”
The aesthetic stage of human existence—the sensate stage focused on immediate pleasure and social life—becomes inwardly unsatisfied because self-consciousness awakens and the spirit demands a higher form of existence beyond mere sense-perception, creating a crisis of the spirit.
“the aesthetic is virtually an objective type of existence living in the world of the senses aesthetic in the European sense of sense perception not just the arts it includes the arts but it includes social life without moral conscience sensitivity haunting the inner life”
Karl Bart, the Protestant theologian, counters Nietzsche's claim that Christianity says 'no' to nature by arguing that in the incarnation—God becoming flesh in creation—Christ represents God's giant 'yes' to nature and the physical world.
“this is the background against which Carl Bart the Protestant theologian said that in Christ incarnate God sends a giant yes to nature get it in becoming incarnate in the physical creation in the human creation God says yes to that creation yes to make sure”
Romanticism, particularly as a late Romantic movement, represented a repudiation of nineteenth-century optimism and Enlightenment rationalism, influencing both Kierkegaard and Nietzsche in their respective critiques of modernity.
“there is very much influence but the romanticist movement late romantic very much the critic of nineteenth-century culture and of an Enlightenment and that's the way in which stuff presents him in his chapter”
In Germanic philosophy, 'spirit' (Geist) refers to the inner creativity, inner resources, and inner needs of the human being—used in a Hegelian sense to denote self-conscious existence that needs to come to its fulfillment.
“he uses the term spirit and for good as in the Germanic sense of spirit Geist generally this refers to the the inner creativity the inner resources the inner needs of the human being it's used in if you like in Hegel sense of spirit self conscious existence that needs to come to its fulfillment”
H. Bradley, the Hegelian idealist, wrote an essay on ethics titled 'My Station and Its Duties' which is not about a railroad station but about one's station in life, one's social class and conformity to environmental adjustment—which Nietzsche criticizes as hopeless conformism.
“if H Bradley the her gaily an idealist has an essay on ethics which gets to the heart of his ethical theory the essay is called my station and its duties he's not talking of a railroad station he's talking of his station in life his class in the socialist adjusting to environment”
Schopenhauer was a voluntaristic idealist who argued that the 'idea' is purely phenomenal (appearance) while the underlying reality is the 'will,' establishing the metaphysical framework that Nietzsche inherits and develops.
“Schopenhauer remember Schopenhauer's major work the world as will and idea well vitality idea the rational mental representation now Schopenhauer of course was arguing that the idea is purely phenomenal it's the well that is real he was a voluntary sztyc idealist”
The biblical and theological echo in Kierkegaard's critique of the aesthetic stage appears in the book of Ecclesiastes, which emphasizes the emptiness and vanity of sensual satisfaction.
“the aesthetic is virtually an objective type of existence living in the world of the senses which typical God thinks can get awful boring and he seems there to be echoing the book of ecclesiastes whatever my heart desired I kept back from it kept not from it and it was all vanity and vexation of spirit”
In the Reformed tradition, exemplified by the Westminster Catechism, God is described as a spirit infinite in wisdom, goodness, love and power, while humans are spirits finite in the same attributes, allowing for the conceptualization of unity through interpenetration of attributes.
“the Westminster catechism reformed catechism which speaks has got of God as a spirit infinite in wisdom goodness love and power attributes man as a spirit finite in wisdom goodness love and power oh you see the same attributes infinite in one finite in the other and so they could meet and you have been sexualized the unity”
Existential philosophy is not so much a position or system as a focus of interest—philosophizing about human existence and self-conscious existence in a broken world.
“existential philosophy which I described as not so much a position as system as a focus of interest philosophizing about human existence self conscious existence in a broken world”
Nietzsche's sister edited his work after his death and was a pro-Nazi sympathizer, leading some scholars to attribute certain passages in Nietzsche's work to editorial manipulation rather than Nietzsche's authentic thought, creating scholarly uncertainty about what Nietzsche himself believed.
“because according to one line of scholarship Nietzsche's work was edited after his death by his sister who was a pro do not see get the picture and there are some things in nature which people have interpreted as being really and the sort of voluntary story”
In the religious stage, Kierkegaard distinguishes between Religious A (continuation of the ethical with religious institutions substituted for secular ones, epitomized by 'churchmanship') and Religious B (vital spiritual life where self-consciousness before God becomes most real, sin becomes tangible, and faith and love emerge as passionate responses).
“the religious stage in that he distinguishes between two phases religious a and religious be religious a is really little more than continuation of the ethical invert they the institutions and structures in which you now invest yourself our religious institutions and structures what the British called churchmen ship but its religion B which really is the vital kind of spiritual life”
Nietzsche's Dionysian-Apollonian dialectic in 'The Birth of Tragedy' posits that Greek tragedy arose from the creative tension between Dionysian vitality (riotous creative outbursts of emotion and passion) and Apollonian rational order, through which the Greeks creatively affirmed life in the face of the horrible.
“in a work called the birth of tragedy the birth of tragedy we're going back to the Greeks he talks of two traditions in opposition to each other the Dionysian and the Apollonian now those terms obviously symbolise things that you are familiar with the Dionysian vitality the Apollonian for the Apollonian rational order the Dionysian the vitality of riotous creative outbursts of emotion passion”
Søren Kierkegaard draws a distinction between the objective path to becoming Christian (through natural theology or historical evidence) and the subjective path (through individual passionate response), arguing the objective path is inherently incomplete because the incarnation—a historically unique event—cannot be deduced from universal empirical laws of human nature and history.
“the objective path whether it be a path of natural theology or of historical evidences whatever always seems to be incomplete because there are always some unanswered questions that cause one to defer decision”
Nietzsche is a biological vitalist—he sees life as a creative force breaking out in multiple ways, rooted in biological drive—which represents the beginning of what is now called sociobiology, the claim that there is a biological basis for social behaviors, mores, and ethics determined by biology.
“he's a vitalist seeing this creative spirit of life breaking out in all sorts of ways there is a biologically based creativity there is a biological drive this is the beginning of what nowadays we call sociobiology you see this the fact that there's a claim that there is a biological basis for social behaviors for social mores for ethics and it's all determined by your biology”
Kierkegaard distinguishes between a genius (a creative spirit who stands out from the crowd but whose insights will eventually be superseded and forgotten) and an apostle (one sent by God, remembered for divine authority rather than creative originality, speaking with 'Thus saith the Lord'), representing a critique of 19th-century liberal theology's view of revelation as gradual God-consciousness emerging from the human spirit.
“the genius is the creative spirit who sees far ahead of others it stands out above the crowd the creative genius the Apostle is one sent by God who is remembered not for his genius which would soon be overtaken by the others and therefore almost forgotten but is remembered rather for the Authority on which he speaks says the Apostle thus saith the Lord there's a qualitative difference not just a difference of degree of authority but a qualitative difference between a genius and an apostle”
Kierkegaard was not a dramatic convert or unbeliever but rather a critic of the established state church in Denmark, which he saw as epitomizing the objectivity of religion through automatic membership by birth ('How to become Christian? Be born a Dane').
“kids who got actually was very much a critic of the established state Church in Denmark which for him epitomized the objectivity of religion a how to become a Christian be born a Dane you seen in the state church you're automatically a member of”
A sensate culture (a term used by sociologist Sorokin) attempts to find satisfaction in consumer goods and baubles from shopping centers, but such culture fails to satisfy genuine human needs or spirit.
“there was a sociologist some twenty or thirty years ago thing I think it was Sorokin who talked of the since eight cold yeah now you can imagine what a sense eight culture would be one that tries to be satisfied with all of the baubles that exist in shopping centers”
The three stages (aesthetic, ethical, religious) may not be metaphysically necessary stages but rather phenomenological descriptions of typical consciousness development, which would mean individuals might conceivably skip stages rather than move through all three in sequence.
“that's raising the question as to whether the dialectical movement is on metaphysical necessity or whether it's simply a generalized phenomenological description if it's descriptive then it might not be necessary may just be characteristic”