factual
Reductionism is a substantive 20th-century discovery
The reversibility paradox only bites if you hold a reductionist picture; early scientists could reasonably believe living tissue obeyed different laws than non-living matter, so the discovery that the world is genuinely unified and reductionist is a substantive achievement of 20th century science, not an a priori truth available to 19th century thinkers.
factualpending
Speaker
David WallaceEvidence Quote
“even in the early 20th century people were still taking extremely seriously the idea that living tissue was not described by the same laws of physics that describe non-living matter... So I think the discovery that the world actually is really pretty unified, and that in the good sense it's pretty reductionist is a really substantive, important discovery of 20th century science. We don't want to just read it back as some automatic a priori fact about science”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:26:31 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...