value pluralism
The view that there are many legitimate, sometimes conflicting human values that cannot be reduced to a single standard
As defined in AMA | October 2023
Where it comes up · 7
- Kieran Setiya on Midlife3 claims
- Philip E. Tetlock2 claims
- Jonathan Haidt1 claim
- 354 - Is Moral Progress A Fantasy1 claim
- 295 - Philosophy And The Good Life1 claim
- 248 | Yejin Choi on AI and Common Sense1 claim
- AMA | October 20231 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 10Search all claims for “value pluralism” →
- The pursuit of parsimony—treating the simplest one-principle explanation as automatically better—is a bad, almost religious quest that is a disaster for the social sciences, because people are far more complicated than matter; Haidt advocates 'antiparsimony' and is normatively a value pluralist (drawing on Isaiah Berlin), holding that extremism in defense of any single virtue becomes a vice.Jonathan Haidt
- The sense of missing out on the many valuable lives one could have lived (existential FOMO) reflects value pluralism—the fact that there are many incommensurable kinds of valuable things that don't compensate for each other—and the only way to escape missing out would be a world that was evaluatively homogeneous or a self that was monomaniacal, neither of which anyone wants; so it is a glorious thing that the world contains more good than any life can hold.295 - Philosophy And The Good Life
- Integrative complexity reflects value pluralism: the more frequently a political thinker confronts cognitive dissonance between conflicting values, the more pressured they are toward complex synthetic thinking, whereas lopsided values permit simpler dissonance reduction like denial or bolstering one value while downplaying another.Philip E. Tetlock
- People who grow up with a second culture appear to have some forecasting advantage because accountability to conflicting audiences and value pluralism gives them a richer internal dialogue and stronger perspective-taking skills, which are important parts of superforecasting.Philip E. Tetlock
- Talking about aligning AI values with human values may involve a category mistake because it is not clear that current AI systems have values in any meaningful sense; furthermore, since humans hold pluralistic and conflicting values, the very goal of 'aligning to human values' is underspecified and requires deciding whose values and how to reconcile them.AMA | October 2023
- Liberalism was a coincidence of historical accidents—a local way of life emerging from particular types of Christianity in a few countries, now fading away—and one can hold that it was a genuinely good form of life while also recognizing that there have been other, non-barbarous ways of life permitting a different constellation of goods, virtues, and excellences.354 - Is Moral Progress A Fantasy
- AI alignment is vital but problematic because there is no single objective value to align to—humans hold diverse values across cultures and personal choice (value pluralism) and are dynamic beings whose values are inconsistent and change—so AI must be aligned to diverse values rather than one, currently it is aligned to California tech-world left-leaning Western values, and how to technically align to plural values remains an open question.248 | Yejin Choi on AI and Common Sense
- Once you recognize that values are plural and not measurable on a single scale, Effective Altruism's mantra of 'do the most good' becomes very hard to apply: comparing saving 1,000 versus 2,000 from malaria is straightforward, but comparing malaria relief against arts education for children has no single metric and the idea of one is an illusion.Kieran Setiya on Midlife
- Most of life's significant decisions are not trade-offs with a common currency where you weigh more-against-less; they are choices where you simply give something up and never get the foregone option at all, and recognizing that this very feature—uncompensated loss across plural goods—is what makes life rich provides genuine comfort against 'grass would have been greener' regret.Kieran Setiya on Midlife
- Nostalgia and regret for roads not taken—'existential FOMO'—are an inevitable function of value pluralism: because there are diverse, incommensurable goods, choosing one means an uncompensated loss of the others; the only way to avoid missing out would be a homogeneous single-currency life that is dystopian and impoverished, so missing out is the disappointing-but-overall-not-regrettable price of a rich evaluative landscape.Kieran Setiya on Midlife