uti possidetis juris
The international law doctrine used to determine the borders of a newly created country: the new state inherits the borders of the largest pre-existing administrative unit.
As defined in Is Israel Occupying the West Bank? (with Eugene Kontorovich)
Where it comes up · 2
- Is Israel Occupying the West Bank? (with Eugene Kontorovich)3 claims
- A Military Analysis of Israel's War in Gaza (with Andrew Fox)1 claim
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “uti possidetis juris” →
- The core principle is that you cannot occupy territory to which you have a legal claim; applying uti possidetis juris, Israel's borders at independence in 1948 were those of Mandatory Palestine (between the river and the sea, including Judea and Samaria), so the West Bank falls within Israel's legal claim and cannot be occupied territory.Is Israel Occupying the West Bank? (with Eugene Kontorovich)
- Uti possidetis juris is the established international law doctrine for determining the borders of a new country: the borders become those of the largest pre-existing administrative unit, ignoring history, demography, topography, and fairness because those factors are indeterminate; the rule's virtue is that it is a single, simple-to-administer factor.Is Israel Occupying the West Bank? (with Eugene Kontorovich)
- The international community refuses to recognize Crimea as Russia's not because of self-determination (a majority were ethnically Russian) or colonial distance, but because Crimea was part of the Ukrainian Soviet Socialist Republic after Khrushchev transferred it in the 1950s; it therefore became part of Ukraine on independence, and the ethnic argument Russia made (mirroring the Palestinian argument) was rejected.Is Israel Occupying the West Bank? (with Eugene Kontorovich)
- The colonialism framework of international law—written in the post-WWII era as European powers handed colonies back to indigenous populations—does not fit Israel, because rather than Jewish colonizers displacing native Arabs from land where no Jews had lived, you have two peoples both claiming indigeneity and long historical ties; even pro-Israel counterarguments like uti possidetis juris are themselves colonial frameworks, so applying colonial international law cannot solve the intractable problem.A Military Analysis of Israel's War in Gaza (with Andrew Fox)