trolley problem
A thought experiment in which one must decide whether to divert a runaway trolley to kill one person instead of five, used to probe intuitions about consequentialist ethics.
As defined in Erik Hoel on Effective Altruism, Utilitarianism, and the Repugnant Conclusion
Other definitions
A philosophical thought experiment asking whether one should actively divert or push to kill one person to save five, used to probe moral intuitions about action versus inaction.
Ben Cohen on the Hot HandPhilosophical thought experiment about moral decision-making: should you actively divert a trolley to kill one person to save five? Highlights distinction between action and inaction
A billion years of evolution in a single afternoon — George Church
Where it comes up · 13
- Erik Hoel on Effective Altruism, Utilitarianism, and the Repugnant Conclusion3 claims
- 176 | Joshua Greene on Morality, Psychology, and Trolley Problems3 claims
- Yuval Noah Harari | 21 Lessons for the 21st Century | Talks at Google2 claims
- 56 - Abusing Dolores2 claims
- Byrne Hobart - FTX, Drugs, Twitter, Taiwan, & Monasticism1 claim
- Ben Cohen on the Hot Hand1 claim
- 48 - What Is Moral Progress1 claim
- 57 - An Evening With Richard Dawkins And Sam Harris 11 claim
and 5 more
Most important claims · 10 of 19Search all claims for “trolley problem” →
- The trolley problem can be complexified into the case of a surgeon who murders an innocent person to harvest organs and save five dying patients; the math is identical (one life for five), yet most people find it deeply repugnant, which shows the problem is not one of complexity but of the trolley problem's excessive simplicity.Erik Hoel on Effective Altruism, Utilitarianism, and the Repugnant Conclusion
- Many behavioral-economics paradoxes that purport to show irrationality depend heavily on how the question is framed and stripped of context; figures like Taleb and Gigerenzer argue that once you account for real-world context, decisions that looked irrational are actually rational, as illustrated by a child's sensible worry, in the Trolley Problem, that the man being pushed might push back.Ben Cohen on the Hot Hand
- When systematizing moral preferences into a coherent theory, there is a danger of over-simplifying—as with naive utilitarianism that would endorse secretly killing one healthy person to harvest organs for twenty—and the right response is usually not to accept the repugnant conclusion but to recognize the systematization was too crude; moral systems should be logical but may legitimately remain fuzzy, balancing aggregate welfare against individual rights as the trolley problem illustrates.100 | Solo | Life and Its Meaning
- Body count is often an insufficient measure of the full consequences of an action; the intuition that consequentialism is a poor moral theory usually results from consequentialists failing to count more ethereal but real consequences — such as the fear, paranoia, and erosion of trust that would follow a doctor killing one healthy patient to save five.48 - What Is Moral Progress
- People resist genetic counseling partly through 'trolley problem' reasoning: inaction feels like not their fault, but actually all reproductive decisions are decisions; doing nothing is a choice with consequencesA billion years of evolution in a single afternoon — George Church
- Starting from simple thought experiments like the trolley problem and expanding them upward into prescriptions for how to spend billions of dollars introduces hidden problems of scale, concept, and complexity, so we should be suspicious of that move.Erik Hoel on Effective Altruism, Utilitarianism, and the Repugnant Conclusion
- To construct moral rules well requires two components: first, reflecting on our inner moral impulses—accepting that our intuitions are often incoherent and using tools like trolley-problem thought experiments to systematize them—and second, communicating with other people to learn their impulses and reason toward a mutually agreeable system, with no guarantee of success.53 | Solo -- On Morality and Rationality
- Like uncontroversial political issues that never reach national debate because they are easily resolved, the easy-to-solve trolley problems in the world have already been solved, leaving us only with situations that superficially resemble trolley problems but actually are not.Erik Hoel on Effective Altruism, Utilitarianism, and the Repugnant Conclusion
- As we build machines more powerful than us within their domains, the moral relativist view that there are no better or worse answers to ethical questions collapses, because someone must code explicit values into systems like self-driving cars—and failing to build in values is itself a value choice—forcing programmers to confront trolley-problem-like tradeoffs in practice.57 - An Evening With Richard Dawkins And Sam Harris 1
- Having to program self-driving car algorithms is amazingly clarifying of moral priorities because it forces people who claim moral questions have no answers to take a position—any car that is totally unbiased about whose life it saves is itself 'a Buddhist car' representing a default moral choice, and the moment you design away from pure equality you must make moral decisions (killing one is better than killing five), so you cannot take refuge in moral relativism when morality is in the engineers' hands.56 - Abusing Dolores