YouTube58m· Oct 2018· cataloged

Yuval Noah Harari | 21 Lessons for the 21st Century | Talks at Google


What this covers

Yuval Noah Harari, macro-historian, Professor, best-selling author of "Sapiens" and "Homo Deus," and one of the world's most innovative and exciting thinkers, discusses his newest work, "21 Lessons for the 21st Century."

Described as a “truly mind-expanding” journey through today’s most pressing issues, "21 Lessons for the 21st Century" reminds us to maintain our collective focus in the midst of dizzying and disorienting change.

Moderated by Wilson White.

Get the book: https://goo.gl/CVDJzG

Visit Yuval Noah Harari's YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/user/YuvalNoahHarari

Source description (no synthesized summary yet).


The claims · ranked40 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.80

The historically unprecedented threat is that corporations like Google and governments will soon have privileged access to what is happening inside human bodies and brains—understanding individuals better than individuals understand themselves—through the convergence of AI and biotech, particularly biometric sensors and neural monitoring.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“there is no longer the privileged access now belongs to corporations like Google they can have access to things happening ultimately inside my body and brain which I don't know about there is somebody out there not just one all kinds of corporations and governments that made me not today maybe in five years ten years twenty years they will have privileged access to what's happening inside me more privileged than my access they could understand what is happening in my brain better than I understand it”

0.74

Technology is not inherently good or bad—it is dual-use, meaning the same technology can be designed to either reduce suffering (diagnostic medicine, safety) or increase suffering (surveillance, control), depending on choices made in design, deployment, and governance.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“it should also be emphasized that technology is never the FIR monistic you can build either paradise or hell with these technologies they are not just they don't have just one one type of usage”

0.74

Science knows only two kinds of processes in nature: deterministic processes and random processes, and their combination results in probabilistic processes, but neither randomness nor probability constitute freedom.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“science knows of only two kinds of processes in nature it knows about deterministic processes and it knows about random processes and their combination results in probabilistic processes but randomness and probability they are not freedom”

0.74

Fake news is not new—humans have been spreading misinformation throughout history, often in much worse forms than today—and the real challenge is not detecting which stories are true or false, but understanding what reality actually is beneath competing narratives.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“we're gonna open it up for questions from the audience in a few minutes here but I want to try to get an easy win so in in 21 lessons you you tackle really big challenges and questions that we're wrestling with today of those those questions which do you think is the easiest to solve and what should we be doing to go about solving it ooh what is the easiest to solve trying to get quick wins on the board here yeah for so the rest the fake news question not because it's the easiest to solve but also maybe because it's one of the most relevant to what you're doing here in in Google and I would say that the current incarnation of the fake news problem has a lot to do with the model of the news and information market that we have constructed a model which basically says exciting news for free in exchange for your attention and this is a very problematic model because it it turns human attention into the most scarce resource and you get more and more competition for human attention with more and more exciting news that again in in some of the smartest people in the world have learned how to excite our brain how to make us click on the next news story and truth gets completely pushed aside it's not part of the equation the equation is excitement attention excitement attention and on the collective level I think the solution to this problem would be to change the model of the news market to high quality news that cost you a lot of money but don't abuse your attention it's very strange that we are in a situation when people are willing to pay a lot of money for high quality food and high quality cars but not for high quality news and this is a lot to do with the architecture of of the information market and I think there is there are many things that you here in Google can do in order to help society change that the model of the news market I'd want to continue explore that and whether that would be create like economic divide or exacerbate the current divide but I'm gonna open it up now for audience questions we have a microphone here on the side start with you hi thank you so much for writing your books they're completely wonderful and I've had a joy reading them so one of the things that you kind of explore here is we are facing a couple of global problems and historically we have never created global global organizations which is responsible for solving global problems who had any ability to enforce them and even when we have created them they have come after great tragedies so how can we sort of make that happen and make somebody responsible and have the ability to have those organizations enforce those solutions yeah I mean it's it's not going to be easy and but I think the most important thing is to change the public conversation and focus it on the global problems if people focus on local problems they don't see the need for effective global cooperation so the first step is to tell people again and again and again look the three biggest problems that everybody on the planet is now facing our nuclear war climate change and technological disruption and even if we are able to prevent nuclear war and climate change it's still AI and biotech are going to completely disrupt the job market and even the human body and we need to figure out how to regulate this and how to prevent the dystopian consequences and make sure that the more utopian consequences materialized and for that we need global cooperation to be obvious to everybody you cannot prevent climate change on a national level and you cannot regulate AI on a national level whatever regulation the u.s. adopts if the Chinese are not adopting it it won't do much help so you need cooperation here and and then it goes into practical political issues I mean you have an elections coming up midterm elections in the US so if you go to a town meeting with an inspiring congressman or congresswoman so we just ask them what are you going if I elect you what will you do about the danger of climate change about the danger of nuclear war and about getting global regulations for a iron for biotech what's your plan and if they say oh I haven't thought about it then maybe don't vote for that person question hi you go thanks for coming here today so in one of your talks you suggested that to avoid getting our hearts hacked we need to stay ahead by knowing ourselves better and it seems to me that the process of knowing yourself needs a lot of intelligence and in some ways it's a skill that needs to be developed I mean the intellect that we have as human seems fairly new when compared to other properties that we got evolutionarily so how do you suggest that we can learn to think and use our intelligence better and also do that at a scale because if only some people know themselves but millions are on your billions around you don't then then you can only go so far well I don't think that knowing yourself is necessarily about all about intelligence certainly not in the narrow sense of intelligence if you include emotional intelligence and so forth and yes but in in the more narrow sense of like IQ I think this is not some of the many very intelligent people in the world who don't know themselves at all which is an extremely dangerous combination now some people explore themselves through therapy some use meditation some use out some use sports they like go on a long hike go for a month to the Appalachian Trail and and get to know themselves on the way there are many ways to do it which are not necessarily about intellect it's not like reading articles about brain science and that's gonna help in some ways and in this sense I think it's a very kind of democratizing ability or force to get to know yourself after afros in you you're always with yourself it's not like you need some special Abra Tory and to get some very rare machines from I don't know that cost millions of dollars you just need yourself sure but what about the art of thinking like what about the art of the art of thinking I mean people are very intelligent but they don't really use their intelligence to understand themselves right yeah and there is no easy way to do it if it was easy to get to know yourself better everybody would do it long ago and we would be living in a very very different world we have we have folks joining us from all around the world as well so I have a question from from the question Bank compassion is the critical underpinning of any successful society yet I believe that technology is reducing our capacity capacity for empathy it feels that we no longer value compassion perhaps even seeing compassion as weak what are in your view effective ways to motivate members of society to develop their compassion I don't think the technology is inherently undermining compassion it can go both ways certainly communication technology can make you aware of the plight of people on the other side of the world and without that you may be extremely compassionate about your immediate like family members and neighbors and won't care at all about people on the other side of the world so I don't think there is an inherent contradiction or collision between technology and compassion but it is true that the way we design technology can make us less compassionate and even the way that we design ourselves for most of history so you had economic and political systems trying to shape people and in the past they live with education and with our culture and in the president future we are likely to do it more and more with biotech and with brain computer interfaces so our ability to manipulate ourselves is growing and therefore it extremely important to remember to take compassion into account otherwise the danger is the you know armies and corporations and government in many cases they want something like intelligence they want more intelligent workers and soldiers they want more decisive workers and soldiers don't take a whole day to decide I want you to decide this in half an hour and as our ability to manipulate humans and I mean manipulate our ear engineer that that the body in the brain as it grows we might engineer more decisive and intelligent humans at the price of compassion which many corporations and armies and governments find either irrelevant or even problematic because it causes people to be hesitant and to take more time about the decisions and so on and so forth so we need to remember that the enormous importance of compassion and again it goes back also to the question about getting to know yourself which i think is the key to developing compassion not just because when you understand your own that this makes me miserable then you understand all the same thing may make other people also miserable it's even much deeper than that when you really get to know yourself you realize that when you ignore others and when you mistreat others very often it harms you even before it harms them it's a very unpleasant experience to be angry so your anger may have harm other people or maybe not maybe you're boiling with anger about somebody and you don't do anything about it because she's your boss but you don't harm her but your your anger harms you so the more you you understand yourself the greater incentive you have to do something about my anger about my hatred about my fear and most people discover that as they develop more compassion towards others they also experience far more peace within themselves another live question thank you after reading your books it occurs to me that you've most likely educated yourself both broadly and deeply to be the foundation for your ideas for those of us that are interested in cultivating our mind similarly wonder if you could share a little bit about your reading habits and how you use what to consume what am i reading habits um I read very eclectically like no book is bad from from entering the the book list but then I tend to be extremely impatient about the books I actually read I would begin like 10 books and drop 9 of them after 10 pages it's not always the wisest policy but it's my policy that if a book didn't really teach me something new had some interesting insight in the first 10 pages the chances it will it could be that in on page 100 there'll be some mind-blowing idea that I am now missing but there's so many I keep thinking there are so many books out wonderful books out there that I will never read so why waste waste time on a less optimal optimal book so I would try like a book on biology and then economics and then psychology and then fiction and whatever and just go through them quite quickly until I find something that really grabs me another live question I mr. Ari thanks for being here fascinating talk is as always I do a little bit of meditation myself and I've heard that you do a lot of meditation on the order of hours a day is that right I try to do 2 hours every day and I try to go every year to a long reach treat of 45 or 60 days so I was wondering how do you feel that has influenced your life and and the ideas that you have a tremendous influence I think both on my inner peace of mind but also on my work as a scientist maybe the two most important influences is that first it enable me to to have more clarity and more focus and certainly when you write about such big subjects like trying to summarize the whole of history in 400 pages so having a very very focused mind is very important because the great difficulty is that you everything kind of currently strikes you you start writing about the Roman Empire and you said well I have to explain this and this and this and this and and you end up with 4,000 pages so you have to be very what is really important and what can be left outside and the other thing is that at least of limitation that I I practice which is Vipassana meditation it's all about really knowing the difference between the fictions and story is generated by our mind and the reality what is really happening right now and when when when I meditate the things that happens is that constantly the mind is like a factory that constantly generates stories about myself about other people about the world that and they are very attractive and like I get identified with them and the meditation is constantly don't it's just a story leave it just try to stay with what is really happening right now and this is the central practice in in meditation it's also a guiding principle when I study history or when I study what's happening in the world hey thank you let's take another question from the from the dory with inequality rising across most nation in the last few decades what is your perspective on how we can use technological growth to solve this problem and create a more equitable world do we need a different economic paradigm to achieve this yes we probably need a different economic paradigm because we are entering kind of uncharted waters especially because of the automation revolution and the growing likelihood that more and more people will might be completely pushed out of the job market not just because there won't be enough jobs but simply because the the pace of change in the job market will accelerate so even if there are enough jobs people don't have the psychological balance and stamina to constantly retrain rescale reinvent themselves and so I think that the biggest problem in that job market is really going to be this psychological problem and then what do you do when more and more people are left out and there are explorations of new models like universal basic income and so forth which of worth exploring I don't have the answers I would just say that anybody who thinks in terms like universal basic income should take the word Universal very very seriously and not settle for national basic income because the the greatest inequality we're facing will probably be inequality between countries and not within countries some countries are likely to become extremely wealthy due to the automation revolution and California is certainly one of these places other countries might lose everything because their entire economy depends on things like manual labor which will lose its importance and they just don't have the resources and the educational system to kind of turn themselves into high-tech hubs so the really crucial question is not how do we what what do we do about I don't know Americans in Indiana who lose their jobs the really important questions is what do we do about people in Guatemala or Bangladesh who lose their jobs this should be I think the focus of this question of inequality okay look take another live question hello mr. Ari all right thank you for doing this QA so at Google we have a responsibility to build products and services which not only achieve results for our shareholders but also that actually benefit our end users so in order to spend less time hacking humans and spend more time reducing suffering we need to understand what's of a future we want to build so what I want to ask you is what are your personal methodologies for making predictions about the future and what suggestions would you give to Googlers who want to have a more vers understanding of the future well as I said in the very beginning I don't think we can predict the future but I think we can influence it what I try to do as a historian and I even when I talk about the future I define myself as a historian because I think that history is not the study of the past history is the study of change how human society is and in political systems and economies change and what I try to do is to map different possibilities rather than make predictions this is what will happen in 2050 and we need to keep a very broad perspective one of the biggest dangers is when we have a very narrow perspective like we develop a new technology and we think oh this technology will have this outcome and we are convinced of this prediction and we don't take into account that the same technology might have very different outcomes and then we don't prepare and we don't and as I said at the beginning it's especially important to take into account the worst possible outcomes in order to be aware of them so I would say whenever you're thinking about the future the future impact of added technology I'm developing create a map of different possibilities if you see just one possibility you're not looking wide enough if you see two or three it's probably also not wide enough you need a map of like four or five different possibilities minimum let's take another live question hey I'm sir hurry so my question is I'll start very broad and then I'll know it down for the focus I'm really interested in what do you think are the components that make these fictional stories so powerful in how they guide human nature and my and then if I narrow it down is I'm specifically interested in this self-destruction behavior of humans how can these fictional stories led by a few people convinced the mass to literally kill or die for that fictional story it's it again goes back to to hacking the brain and hacking the human animal it's been done throughout history previously just by trial and error without the deep knowledge of of brain science and evolution we have today but to give an example like if you want to convince people to persecute and exterminate some other group of people what you need to do is really latch onto the discussed mechanisms in the human brain evolution has shaped Homo sapiens who is very powerful discussed mechanisms in the brain to protect us against diseases against all kinds of sources of potential disease and if you look at the history of bias and prejudice and genocide one recurring theme is that it repeatedly kind of latches on to these discussed mechanisms and so you would find things like women are impure or these other people they smell bad and they bring diseases and very very often discussed is at the center so you'll often find comparison between certain types of humans and rats or cockroaches or all kinds of other disgusting things so if you want to instigate genocide you start by hacking the discussed mechanisms in the human brain and this is very very deep and if it's done from an early age it's extremely difficult after words people can they know intellectually that it's wrong to say that these people are disgusting that are these people they smell bad and then David but the anointing tool actually but when you you place them like in a brain scanner they can't help it if they were raised I mean so we can still do something about it we can still kind of defeat this but it's very difficult because it's it really goes to the core of the brain so I'll end on a final question because we're at time when Larry and Sergey when they founded Google they did show with this this deep belief in technology's ability to improve people's lives everywhere so if you had a magic wand and you could give Google and the next big project for us to work on and in 30 seconds or less what would what would you grant us is our assignment an AI system that gets to know me in order to protect me and not in order to sell me products or make me click on advertisements and so forth all right mission accepted thank you [Music] you”

0.72

In history, organizing humans at large scale has always required shared fictional stories or narratives (whether religious, economic, or political) that enough humans believed in to coordinate behavior, rather than purely objective reality.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“so far in history in order to organize humans on a large scale you always had to have some story some fiction which humans invented but which enough humans believed in order to agree on how to behave”

0.72

The difference between a fictional entity like a corporation and a real entity is whether it can suffer: Google cannot suffer even if its stock drops or it is broken up by a court, but humans and animals can suffer, making suffering the ultimate test of reality versus fiction.

definitionhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“If you want to know whether something is a real entity or a fictional entity you should just ask can this entity actually suffer... Google cannot suffer even if the stock goes down even if a judge comes and says this is a monopoly you have to break it up... it doesn't suffer humans can suffer like the managers the owners of the stocks the employees they can suffer”

0.69

The three biggest problems facing all humans on the planet right now are nuclear war, climate change, and technological disruption (AI and biotech), and these problems cannot be solved at the national level—they require effective global cooperation.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“the three biggest problems that everybody on the planet is now facing our nuclear war climate change and technological disruption and even if we are able to prevent nuclear war and climate change it's still AI and biotech are going to completely disrupt the job market and even the human body and we need to figure out how to regulate this and how to prevent the dystopian consequences and make sure that the more utopian consequences materialized and for that we need global cooperation to be obvious to everybody you cannot prevent climate change on a national level and you cannot regulate AI on a national level whatever regulation the u.s. adopts if the Chinese are not adopting it it won't do much help so you need cooperation here”

0.68

Corporations and governments may engineer humans to be more intelligent and decisive while removing compassion, because they view compassion as irrelevant to their goals or even problematic because it makes decision-making slower and more hesitant.

causalhigh valuefringenovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“armies and corporations and government in many cases they want something like intelligence they want more intelligent workers and soldiers they want more decisive workers and soldiers don't take a whole day to decide I want you to decide this in half an hour and as our ability to manipulate humans and I mean manipulate our ear engineer that that the body in the brain as it grows we might engineer more decisive and intelligent humans at the price of compassion which many corporations and armies and governments find either irrelevant or even problematic because it causes people to be hesitant and to take more time about the decisions”

0.68

AI researchers and technology developers naturally tend to focus on positive scenarios of technology because they are developing and investing in these technologies, while social critics focus on dangerous scenarios for obvious reasons; both perspectives are necessary.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“it should also be emphasized that technology is never the FIR monistic you can build either paradise or hell with these technologies they are not just they don't have just one one type of usage and as a story in' and as a social critic and maybe philosopher i tend to focus more on the dangerous scenarios simply because for obvious reasons the end for news and the corporation's and the scientists and engineers are developing these technologies they naturally tend to focus on the positive scenarios on all the good it can do”

0.68

Spirituality is fundamentally about asking big questions about life, meaning, and purpose ('What is humanity? What is good? Who am I?'), while religion is about providing answers to these questions and insisting that people believe those answers.

definitionhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“spirituality is about questions religion is about answers spirituality is when you have some big question about life like what is humanity what is the good Who am I these kinds of question life what should I do in life and and this is kind of and you go on a quest looking deeply into these questions and you're willing to go after these questions wherever they take you you can just go go yeah maybe in the future but so far in at least some of these questions when you I think when you type like what is the meaning of life you get 42 like that there is a number one result search so you go on a spiritual quest and religion is the exact opposite religion is somebody comes and telling you this is the answer you must believe it if you don't believe this answer then you will burn in hell after you die or you will burn you here even before you die”

0.68

Because external entities understanding humans better than humans understand themselves will be able to manipulate and hack individual decision-making, the only protection is self-knowledge—understanding one's own biases, reactions, and vulnerabilities well enough to recognize and resist manipulation.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“To avoid getting our hearts hacked we need to stay ahead by knowing ourselves better... the more you understand yourself the greater incentive you have to do something about my anger about my hatred about my fear”

0.68

Knowing yourself is not primarily about intelligence in the narrow sense (IQ), but rather about emotional intelligence, self-awareness, and understanding the mechanisms (therapy, meditation, sports, nature immersion) through which one can develop this self-knowledge.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“I don't think that knowing yourself is necessarily about all about intelligence certainly not in the narrow sense of intelligence if you include emotional intelligence and so forth and yes but in in the more narrow sense of like IQ I think this is not some of the many very intelligent people in the world who don't know themselves at all which is an extremely dangerous combination now some people explore themselves through therapy some use meditation some use out some use sports they like go on a long hike go for a month to the Appalachian Trail and and get to know themselves on the way there are many ways to do it which are not necessarily about intellect”

0.68

Genocide is often instigated by latching onto disgust mechanisms in the human brain—framing target groups as unclean, disease-carrying, or animal-like (comparing humans to rats or cockroaches)—and this psychological mechanism is extremely deep and difficult to reverse even after intellectual understanding.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“if you want to convince people to persecute and exterminate some other group of people what you need to do is really latch onto the discussed mechanisms in the human brain evolution has shaped Homo sapiens who is very powerful discussed mechanisms in the brain to protect us against diseases against all kinds of sources of potential disease and if you look at the history of bias and prejudice and genocide one recurring theme is that it repeatedly kind of latches on to these discussed mechanisms and so you would find things like women are impure or these other people they smell bad and they bring diseases and very very often discussed is at the center so you'll often find comparison between certain types of humans and rats or cockroaches or all kinds of other disgusting things”

0.65

Technology can already infer physiological and psychological information about individuals just by analyzing their faces—such as blood pressure from facial analysis, mood from eye and mouth movements, and even sexual orientation—without placing sensors on people or asking for consent.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“we are developing the ability for example to know the blood pressure of individuals just by looking at them you don't need to put a sensor on a person just by looking at the face you can tell what is the blood pressure of that individual and by analyzing tiny movements in the eyes in the mouth you can tell all kinds of things from the current mood of the person are you angry are you bored to things like sexual orientation”

0.61

Liberal democracy is in crisis because it is built on the philosophical foundation of free will—the idea that individual choice represents the highest authority in economics ('the customer is always right') and politics ('the voter knows best')—but neuroscience and evolutionary biology have thoroughly disproven free will as a scientific reality.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“the entire liberal democratic system is built on philosophical ideas we've inherited from the 18th century especially the idea of free will which underlies the basic mottos of the liberal worldview like the voter knows best the customer is always right beauty is in the eye of the beholder follow your heart do what feels good all these liberal motors which are the foundation of our political and economic system they assume that the ultimate authority is the three choices of individuals”

0.56

Religious belief often commits a 'magic trick' of swapping one card for another: beginning with acknowledgment of genuine mysteries (Big Bang, consciousness) that religion claims God explains, then swapping to concrete claims about how God wants women to dress or how sexuality should be conducted, with no rational connection between the mystery and the law.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“and it's like you know it's like a magic trick that when you you come and talk about God so how do you know that God exists and so forth people would say well the Big Bang and human consciousness and in science can't explain this and science can't explain that and then and this is true and then like a magician swapping one card for another they will take out the mystery garden place the the petit glow giver and you end up with something strange like because we don't understand the Big Bang women must dress with long sleeves and Men shouldn't have sex together and what's the connection I mean how did you get from here to there”

0.56

Google, as a corporation, can survive the physical destruction of its buildings, death of its workers and managers, loss of all money in its bank—as long as the Supreme Court (the most powerful legal shaman) does not invalidate the legal fiction that constitutes it.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“if you somehow it's some natural calamity destroy is like there is an earthquake and the Googleplex collapses Google still exists even if many of the workers and managers are killed it just hires new ones and it still has money in the bank and even if there is no money in the bank they can they can get alone and build new buildings and hire new people and everything is okay but then if you have one of these the most powerful shaman like the Supreme Court of the United States come and said I don't like your story I think you need to be broken into two different fictions then that's the end”

0.56

The future is not predetermined or predictable, but it is influenceable, and the best approach is to map multiple possible futures (at least 4-5 possibilities) rather than making point predictions, to prepare for and avoid negative scenarios.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“I don't think we can predict the future but I think we can influence it what I try to do as a historian and I even when I talk about the future I define myself as a historian because I think that history is not the study of the past history is the study of change how human society is and in political systems and economies change and what I try to do is to map different possibilities rather than make predictions this is what will happen in 2050”

0.55

The fake news problem is fundamentally rooted in the current business model of the news and information market, which provides exciting content for free in exchange for user attention, turning human attention into the scarcest resource and prioritizing engagement over truth.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“the current incarnation of the fake news problem has a lot to do with the model of the news and information market that we have constructed a model which basically says exciting news for free in exchange for your attention and this is a very problematic model because it it turns human attention into the most scarce resource and you get more and more competition for human attention with more and more exciting news that again in in some of the smartest people in the world have learned how to excite our brain how to make us click on the next news story and truth gets completely pushed aside it's not part of the equation the equation is excitement attention excitement attention”

0.55

The practical basis for believing in free will was that humans were so complicated and individuals had such privileged access to their own inner mental states that no external entity could understand a person better than they understood themselves, making belief in free will pragmatically necessary and sustainable.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“that but that hasn't changed today right like that there is no longer the privileged access now belongs to corporations like Google they can have access to things happening ultimately inside my body and brain which I don't know about there is somebody out there not just one all kinds of corporations and governments that made me not today maybe in five years ten years twenty years they will have privileged access to what's happening inside me more privileged than my access they could understand what is happening in my brain better than I understand it”

0.55

The most important things to teach young people are mental flexibility and the ability to reinvent themselves repeatedly throughout their lives, because nobody knows what the world will look like in 2050 except that it will be very different from today, and traditional deep-foundation identities are no longer viable.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“the one thing that they will need for sure is the ability to reinvent themselves repeatedly throughout their lives today the first time in history that we don't really know what particular skills to teach young people because we just don't know in what kind of world they will be living but we do know they will have to reinvent themselves”

0.52

The combination of AI and biotech is revolutionary because it allows understanding of human psychology and behavior, which is necessary for technologies like self-driving cars; without understanding human biology and behavior, AI cannot function effectively in real-world applications.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“to put a self-driving car on the road you need biology not just computers you need to understand humans for example if somebody is approaching the road the car needs to tell is this an 8 year old an 18 year old or an 8 year old and needs to understand the different behaviors of a human child a human teenager and a human adult and this is biology and similarly to have really effective like self-driving taxis you need the car to understand a lot of things about human psychology the psychology of the passengers coming in and what they want and so forth”

0.52

People are willing to pay significant money for high-quality food and cars but not for high-quality news, and this is due to the architecture of the information market rather than inherent consumer preference.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“it's very strange that we are in a situation when people are willing to pay a lot of money for high quality food and high quality cars but not for high quality news and this is a lot to do with the architecture of of the information market”

0.52

High intelligence without self-knowledge is an extremely dangerous combination because highly intelligent people can harm themselves and others more effectively while remaining ignorant of their own motivations and emotional patterns.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“some of the many very intelligent people in the world who don't know themselves at all which is an extremely dangerous combination”

0.52

American democratic institutions and the US constitutional system are shared fictions (agreed-upon stories) rather than objective realities, but they are powerful fictions that serve important functions (providing healthcare, safety, rule of law) and are therefore real in their effects.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“the experiment is a story that we share it's things that we humans have invented and created in order to serve certain needs and desires that we have it is as a created story and not an objective reality but it is nevertheless the one of the most powerful forces in the world when I say that something is a fiction or a story I mean to imply it's band or that it's not important no some of the best things in the world and the most powerful forces in the world are these shared fictions nations and corporations and banks and and so forth they are all stories we created but they are the most powerful forces today in the world far more powerful than any human being or any animal and they can be a tremendous force for good the key is to remember that we created them to serve us and note that we are here in order to serve them”

0.52

A different economic paradigm will be necessary because automation is creating technological unemployment not just due to job shortage, but because the pace of job market change will exceed human psychological capacity to retrain and reinvent repeatedly.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“we probably need a different economic paradigm because we are entering kind of uncharted waters especially because of the automation revolution and the growing likelihood that more and more people will might be completely pushed out of the job market not just because there won't be enough jobs but simply because the the pace of change in the job market will accelerate so even if there are enough jobs people don't have the psychological balance and stamina to constantly retrain rescale reinvent themselves”

0.52

The greatest inequality resulting from automation will be inequality between countries (those that successfully transition to high-tech economies vs. those dependent on manual labor), not within countries, and this global inequality deserves more policy focus than within-country inequality.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“I would just say that anybody who thinks in terms like universal basic income should take the word Universal very very seriously and not settle for national basic income because the the greatest inequality we're facing will probably be inequality between countries and not within countries some countries are likely to become extremely wealthy due to the automation revolution and California is certainly one of these places other countries might lose everything because their entire economy depends on things like manual labor which will lose its importance and they just don't have the resources and the educational system to kind of turn themselves into high-tech hubs so the really crucial question is not how do we what what do we do about I don't know Americans in Indiana who lose their jobs the really important questions is what do we do about people in Guatemala or Bangladesh who lose their jobs this should be I think the focus of this question of inequality”

0.52

Understanding yourself deeply (self-knowledge) is the key to developing compassion because when you understand your own suffering, you understand that others suffer similarly, and when you understand yourself you realize that harming others harms you through anger, hatred, and fear that damages your own peace.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“when you really get to know yourself you realize that when you ignore others and when you mistreat others very often it harms you even before it harms them it's a very unpleasant experience to be angry so your anger may have harm other people or maybe not maybe you're boiling with anger about somebody and you don't do anything about it because she's your boss but you don't harm her but your your anger harms you so the more you you understand yourself the greater incentive you have to do something about my anger about my hatred about my fear and most people discover that as they develop more compassion towards others they also experience far more peace within themselves”

0.51

The problem occurs when people invert the proper relationship between human interests and institutions, believing that the nation is more real than them and that they should serve the institution rather than the institution serving them and other humans.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“the trouble really begins when people lose sight of the simple reality that we are real they are not and a lot of people throughout history and also today they kind of take it upside down they think the nation is more real than me I am here to serve it and not it is here to serve me and my fellow humans”

0.51

Universal Basic Income proposals should take the word 'universal' seriously and not settle for national basic income, because the crisis of inequality will be primarily global and national solutions will be insufficient and potentially harmful if they leave global inequality unaddressed.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“anybody who thinks in terms like universal basic income should take the word Universal very very seriously and not settle for national basic income because the the greatest inequality we're facing will probably be inequality between countries and not within countries”

0.50

Approximately 1.25 million people are killed each year in traffic accidents, more than 90 percent caused by human error, and replacing human drivers with self-driving cars could save approximately one million lives per year.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“at present about 1.25 million people are killed each year in traffic accidents more than 90 percent of these accidents are because of human errors if we can replace humans with surviving cars it's not that we'll have no car accidents that's impossible greatly but we'll probably save a million lives every year”

0.48

Whatever regulation the United States adopts for AI, if China does not adopt equivalent regulation, it will not effectively prevent AI risks because countries will compete on AI capability and regulation creates competitive disadvantage.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“you cannot regulate AI on a national level whatever regulation the u.s. adopts if the Chinese are not adopting it it won't do much help”

0.48

Harari practices Vipassana meditation 2 hours daily and participates in 45-60 day retreats annually, which provides clarity and focus for writing, and trains the mind to distinguish between fictional stories generated by the mind versus actual present-moment reality.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“I try to do 2 hours every day and I try to go every year to a long reach treat of 45 or 60 days”

0.48

Google and other technology companies can play a significant role in helping society change the business model of the news market away from free, attention-maximizing content toward paid, high-quality journalism.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“I think there is there are many things that you here in Google can do in order to help society change that the model of the news market”

0.48

Technology companies like Google should invest in developing AI systems that are designed to protect individual users and understand them for their own wellbeing, rather than being designed to hack them or manipulate them into clicking and purchasing.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“an AI system that gets to know me in order to protect me and not in order to sell me products or make me click on advertisements and so forth”

0.47

Engineers are now forced by practical necessity to tackle and resolve spiritual and philosophical questions (like the trolley problem in self-driving cars) that philosophers have debated for millennia without practical impact, because engineering requires specific algorithmic decisions with real-world consequences.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“now in most throughout history you always had a small minority of people who was very interested in the big spiritual and philosophical questions of life and most people just ignore them and went along with with their like you know fighting about who owns this land and then who that this goatherd to whom it belongs and so forth now we live in a very unique time in history when engineers must tackle spiritual questions if you are building a self-driving car by force you have to deal with questions like free will”

0.45

AI-enabled healthcare could diagnose diseases far earlier than human awareness allows—before symptoms appear—using 24-hour biometric monitoring and AI analysis, shifting the diagnosis threshold from symptomatic to pre-symptomatic, which would reduce cost and pain but replace human doctors with AI systems.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“the combination of being able to understand what's happening inside my body this also implies that you can provide people with the best health care in history you can for example diagnose diseases long before the person understands that there is something wrong at present the human mind or human awareness is still a very critical Junction in health care like if something happens inside my body and I don't know about it I won't go to the doctor so if something like I don't know cancer is now spreading in my liver and I still don't feel anything I won't go to the doctor I won't know about it only when I start feeling pain and nausea and all kinds of things they can't explain so after some time I go to the doctor it does all kinds of tests and finally they discover oh something is wrong and very often it's by that by that time it's very expensive and landfill not necessarily to light but expensive and painful to take care of it if I could have an AI doctor monitoring my body 24 hours a day with biometric sensors and so forth it could discover this long before I feel anything edit at a stage when it's still very cheap and easy and painless to cure it”

0.45

When philosophers debated trolley problems like Kant, Schopenhauer, and Mill, even when they reached agreement on the right course of action, that agreement had little impact on actual behavior because in a moment of crisis humans react from gut instinct rather than consciously applied philosophy, unlike with algorithmic decision-making which guarantees the programmed choice will be executed.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“previously with philosophical discussions...even if they reach an agreement that very little impact on actual behavior because even if you agree theoretically this is the right thing to do at the time of crisis you'd philosophy has little power you react from your gut not from your philosophical theories”

0.27

Harari reads eclectically but is extremely impatient with books, often starting 10 and dropping 9 after 10 pages, on the theory that if a book doesn't offer a new insight in the first 10 pages, it's unlikely to be worth the time given the vast number of unread books in the world.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“I read very eclectically like no book is bad from from entering the the book list but then I tend to be extremely impatient about the books I actually read I would begin like 10 books and drop 9 of them after 10 pages it's not always the wisest policy but it's my policy that if a book didn't really teach me something new had some interesting insight in the first 10 pages the chances it will it could be that in on page 100 there'll be some mind-blowing idea that I am now missing but there's so many I keep thinking there are so many books out wonderful books out there that I will never read so why waste waste time on a less optimal optimal book”

0.17

Reading should be eclectic across domains—biology, economics, psychology, fiction—because breadth of knowledge enables new connections and insights that specialized reading cannot provide.

normativespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“I would try like a book on biology and then economics and then psychology and then fiction and whatever and just go through them quite quickly until I find something that really grabs me”