trade-offs
Constraints in which gaining one capacity costs another, used to explain why evolution may not develop extra cognition.
As defined in 260 | Ricard Solé on the Space of Cognitions
Where it comes up · 4
- What Happened to the Republican Party?: A Conversation with Bret Stephens (Episode #329)3 claims
- How We Tamed Ourselves and Invented Good and Evil (with Hanno Sauer)1 claim
- A.J. Jacobs on Solving Life's Puzzles1 claim
- 260 | Ricard Solé on the Space of Cognitions1 claim
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “trade-offs” →
- The economist's framing holds that there are no solutions, only trade-offs—every choice, like every chess move, offers benefits weighed against costs rather than a clean resolution.A.J. Jacobs on Solving Life's Puzzles
- We could save tens of thousands of lives annually by enforcing a 30 mph national speed limit, but we don't, because we recognize that the public interest involves trade-offs between competing goods: public health is one, but so are mobility, time, and freedom; this principle should have applied to COVID policy but didn't.What Happened to the Republican Party?: A Conversation with Bret Stephens (Episode #329)
- Public health officials and experts during the COVID pandemic failed to acknowledge the trade-offs between competing public goods (disease prevention vs. childhood development, education, mental health) and instead treated public health in isolation as the sole consideration, then compounded this error by refusing to acknowledge their failures afterward.What Happened to the Republican Party?: A Conversation with Bret Stephens (Episode #329)
- Synthetic biology lets complexity theorists ask new questions by, for example, attempting to genetically modify bacteria so they behave like ants—communicating to find shortest paths—and the failure or success of such engineering reveals whether evolution simply couldn't reach a solution or whether trade-offs make extra cognition not worth developing.260 | Ricard Solé on the Space of Cognitions
- The concept of trade-offs is crucial for sound public decision-making because most major policy problems involve choosing among least-bad options, not finding a single right solution; focusing on the negative half of a trade-off can make any choice seem scarcely tolerable.What Happened to the Republican Party?: A Conversation with Bret Stephens (Episode #329)
- We should engage in explicit cost-benefit analysis of how punitive to be, because human psychology is not naturally cost-benefit psychology—the public tends to see only benefits or only costs of an action and ignore one side of the equation—yet some mix of incentives and sanctions, ideally more incentives and fewer, gentler sanctions, remains necessary because collective action problems always threaten cooperation.How We Tamed Ourselves and Invented Good and Evil (with Hanno Sauer)