A.J. Jacobs on Solving Life's Puzzles
What this covers
A.J. Jacobs and Russ Roberts explore the relationship between puzzles and how we live, using crosswords, jigsaws, Rubik's Cubes, and unsolved mysteries as a framework for understanding human decision-making and conflict. Jacobs, author of The Puzzler, argues that the structure of puzzle-solving mirrors life itself—not because life has clean solutions, but because the value of both lies in the struggle rather than any final answer. Roberts, the host of EconTalk, brings an economist's perspective that frames choices as trade-offs rather than resolutions, and together they examine what puzzles teach us about curiosity, patience, and the limits of optimization.
The conversation ranges across how people think under pressure and distraction, why some problems can be solved and others cannot, and what happens when we treat disagreement as a puzzle to crack rather than a war to win. Jacobs distinguishes between puzzles and mysteries—the former hard but solvable, the latter often unsolvable—and argues that maturity means being fluid enough to pursue solutions where they exist while accepting uncertainty where they do not. He traces how language works as translation, how our brains fail at large numbers, and how online algorithms have changed problem-solving from discovery to recipe-following. The pair also wrestle with whether anger ever helps, how division of labor outperforms individual effort, and whether the future belongs to humans or machines—landing instead on a centaur model where both work together. Throughout, they return to Jacobs's central idea: that [embracing the forward arrow](concept:Embrace the Forward Arrow), the struggle itself, is where meaning lives.
Jacobs argues that puzzles are a metaphor for life: the value lies not in reaching the solution but in embracing the struggle and curiosity along the way, and that treating disagreements and problems as puzzles to solve rather than wars to win is a saner, more productive way to live.
- The 'question mark, forward arrow, exclamation point' framework holds that one must enjoy the struggle because the solution may never come
- Treating conflict as a puzzle ('get curious, not furious') is more productive than anger-based engagement
- Some problems are mysteries with no solution, and maturity means living with that uncertainty
Sequential optimization ignores how elements interact, making true solutions impossible in high-dimensional systems.
- Testing 200 types of oregano sequentially while holding everything else constant ignores the economics of interaction effects: because ingredients combine in vast numbers of combinations, sequential one-variable-at-a-time optimization cannot find the true optimum, and the universe lacks enough time to try all combinations of pizza ingredients.
“he's probably a little weak on what we would call an economics interaction effect. So, trying 200 types of oregano, seriatum--in a row--and finding which one's the best with the other stuff held constant give you one answer. Versus--there's a lot of combinations. The universe probably doesn't have enough life left in it or ever to try all the combinations”
- The Rubik's Cube combinations represent a precisely answerable question with an actual exact number, whereas the number of grains of sand on Earth or stars in the universe are fundamentally unanswerable—only crude back-of-the-envelope estimates around 10 to the 22nd—because their definitions are inherently fuzzy.
“this is not an answerable question, either of them. The Rubik's Cube is an answerable question, I think... we have no idea precisely how many grains of sand there are on the earth and we have no idea precisely how many stars there are in the heavens. It's an estimate”
Communication and cognition require acknowledging that meaning varies between people and mental state shapes performance.
- Almost all language is a form of translation, because words like 'freedom' or 'virtue' carry different meanings for different people, so communication requires recognizing that what one person 'stuffs' into a word is not the same as another person's meaning.
“sensitizing myself to the fact that almost all language is a form of translation. And, 'trunk' is just the most obvious example, but when you start talking about freedom or virtue, you start to realize, 'Hmm, it's not just trunk'”
- Playing online chess does not necessarily make one smarter or better at looking ahead, but it provides a window into one's current mental state—losing repeatedly with unforced errors reveals distraction or poor focus, while a streak of wins reflects a moment of focus and clarity, demonstrating that even slight distraction sharply degrades cognitive performance.
“playing chess online... instead of teaching me something about how to make decisions or look ahead, it teaches me about my current mental state... I'll lose seven, eight in a row... And, then I'll get in a moment of focus and clarity and I can win seven or eight in a row.”
Policy and choice succeed by respecting human nature and accepting trade-offs rather than imposing systematic control.
- Adam Smith in The Theory of Moral Sentiments describes the 'man of system' as one who would move the pieces of society around as if they were pieces on a chess board, ignoring that the human pieces have a principle of motion of their own—a powerful metaphor for the danger of public policy that goes against what is natural to people.
“Adam Smith in The Theory of Moral Sentiments describes the 'man of system' as one who would move the pieces of society around as if they were pieces on a chess board without a motion of their own... a very, very powerful way to think about public policy that goes against what is natural to us.”
- The economist's framing holds that there are no solutions, only trade-offs—every choice, like every chess move, offers benefits weighed against costs rather than a clean resolution.
“the economist in me like to say: No solutions, only trade-offs.”
Anger abandons conscious reasoning while passion as deep caring enhances judgment and well-being.
- Anger is never a beneficial emotion except when one is in physical danger, where it can save your life; outside that, anger means abandoning the conscious mind to let visceral responses take over, which is a mistake—passion, by contrast, meaning caring deeply or being deeply curious, is good.
“anger is never a good emotion, unless you're in physical danger... what anger means is I am cutting loose. I'm going to ignore my conscious mind and let my visceral responses take over... Passion, different thing. Passion is good”