totalitarianism
A 20th-century system of total societal control with a specific set of conditions, distinct from ordinary tyranny, characterized by mass mobilization and, per Arendt, loneliness.
As defined in Masha Gessen
Other definitions
A political system of total state control where the government regulates all aspects of life and allows no freedom of action, thought, or expression; the dystopian political structure in which A Clockwork Orange is set.
A Clockwork Orange: Bibliotheca Webinar
Where it comes up · 13
- 1984 by George Orwell: Bibliotheca Webinar4 claims
- Masha Gessen3 claims
- 131 - Dictators Immigration Metoo And Other Imponderables3 claims
- AD Harris/Murray/Peterson Discussion: London3 claims
- Mark Zuckerberg & Yuval Noah Harari in Conversation2 claims
- Stephen Kotkin2 claims
- Yuval Noah Harari - Are Humans Superior to Other Life forms?2 claims
- What Happened to the Republican Party?: A Conversation with Bret Stephens (Episode #329)1 claim
and 5 more
Most important claims · 10 of 25Search all claims for “totalitarianism” →
- Following Hannah Arendt, the defining condition of totalitarianism is loneliness; this often-overlooked humanistic insight explains much of Russia's grumpy, depressive culture as a function of powerlessness, and even social phenomena like excess mortality are explainable through mass depression.Masha Gessen
- Russia is not a continuous history of unfreedom or innate desire for a strong hand; it was an ordinary tyranny until the early 20th century, then underwent the longest totalitarian experiment in history—a specific 20th-century phenomenon—so current conditions are best understood as the aftermath of that experiment rather than perennial Russian character.Masha Gessen
- One disturbing feature of Hannah Arendt's model of totalitarianism is that while the system structurally demands an all-powerful, all-knowing, prophetic leader, the particular person filling that role may be interchangeable—raising the key question of whether singular figures like Hitler or Stalin were truly unique or replaceable within the system.Vejas Liulevicius
- Falling GDP per capita is good for Putin because Russian society has reconstituted itself as a totalitarian society, and poverty and scarcity maintain the sense of mobilization essential to totalitarian societies; conversely, the 2011-12 mass protests were partly a function of prosperity, since people only demand good governance when they are not preoccupied with survival.Masha Gessen
- Russia has no genuine public opinion because Putin has presided over the near-complete destruction of the public sphere; without a public sphere no meaningful opinion can form, and one hysterical 'country under siege' position dominates everything.131 - Dictators Immigration Metoo And Other Imponderables
- Centralized data processing enabled by AI may structurally advantage totalitarian systems over democracies because the more data you have in one place, the better your algorithms become, reversing the 20th-century advantage democracies had (distributed decision-making was more efficient with 1950s technology, making the Soviet centralized model fail).Mark Zuckerberg & Yuval Noah Harari in Conversation
- In a totalitarian society you can predict with about 86 percent accuracy that people will tell pollsters whatever was last on television, so survey answers are meaningless; accurately mirroring the signal from above is a survival skill, not an opinion.131 - Dictators Immigration Metoo And Other Imponderables
- An extraordinarily important idea embedded in religious frameworks is that even at the top of a hierarchy, one is not absolute but subordinate to something beyond oneself—a principle that prevents totalitarianism.AD Harris/Murray/Peterson Discussion: London
- China exemplifies 1984-like totalitarianism: the chairman is a quasi-deity stand-in for the emperor in an authoritarian top-down tradition; the regime uses internet technology very effectively to control people through a social credit system that can deny dissenters jobs, transportation, and housing.1984 by George Orwell: Bibliotheca Webinar
- Fears of dangerous technological developments and climate change have motivated calls for powerful surveillance states to prevent bad outcomes, but totalitarianism kills far more people than any natural disaster, making surveillance-based governance more dangerous than the threats it claims to preventA Psychologist and Historian Discuss the End of the World | Dr. Niall Ferguson | EP 404