
What this covers
This is a Bibliotheca webinar in which Michael Sugrue discusses George Orwell's 1984 with host Christy Goebel. It begins with the novel itself: Ingsoc as a distortion of English socialism, Newspeak as a vocabulary shrunk until dissent cannot be thought, and Winston Smith's work rewriting records at the Ministry of Truth whenever Oceania switches enemies. Sugrue reads Big Brother as a secular theocracy and O'Brien as an Inner Party intellectual who knows the ideology is fraudulent and uses doublethink to hold 2+2=4 and 2+2=5 as the Party requires. He treats the four-fingers torture scene as the turning point, since its aim is to make a person distrust his own perception. He also places Orwell as a committed English socialist who distrusted communism, and he names Zamyatin, Huxley and Bradbury as related dystopian writers.
The discussion then moves to history and the present. Trofim Lysenko's compulsory biology under Stalin illustrates what happens when politics overrides reality, and Sugrue uses Weimar Germany's changing story of defeat in the First World War to show why control of the past matters. China's social credit system serves as a contemporary parallel. Sugrue also complicates Orwell's prophecy: technology enables surveillance, but phone cameras and leaks can also contradict official accounts.
The later portion turns contested and political. Sugrue defends a John Stuart Mill-style free speech standard grounded in fallibility, argues that library access should lean toward more information, and criticizes political-correctness restrictions while still favoring plainly calling out abuse. He questions mandatory bias training as an effort to control the inner person. He also criticizes extreme libertarianism for treating liberty as the only good, and argues that mainstream media is ideologically positioned and shaped by neoliberalism, whose gains went mostly to the top tenth of Americans. Goebel notes that sales of the book have spiked twice in four years, across political lines.
Orwell's 1984 remains prophetic in warning against totalitarian control of language, thought, and reality through technology and surveillance, though technology itself can be liberating; the key distinction between free and totalitarian societies is that democracies must err on the side of freedom while totalitarians seek absolute control of the psyche.
- Control of language restricts thought; newspeak eliminates the possibility of dissent by making disagreement literally unthinkable
- Reality exerts selection pressure against make-believe—totalitarian regimes must constantly reinforce falsehoods like Lysenko's biology or face collapse
- Free societies should allow maximum speech while distinguishing between words (which fire blanks) and physical violence; totalitarian societies seek control of inner person, not just behavior
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Newspeak is the only allowable dialect of English within the Party and intentionally restricts vocabulary and verbal complexity to restrict thought itself and eliminate the possibility of disagreement with the Party by making dissenting thoughts literally unthinkable.
“newspeak is the only dialect of english that is allowable within the party and it cuts back on words and on verbal complexity in the hope of restricting thought and limiting the possibility of what can be thought so language as uh politically weaponized in the case of newspeak means that even the possibility of disagreement with the party is eliminated”
Orwell distrusted communism and feared its totalitarian tendencies, but he was a committed English socialist in the sense that he was not opposed to a large welfare state—this intellectual positioning made him an important 20th century writer.
“orwell has always been a great avatar of speaking the truth and speaking the truth plainly uh he was an interesting individual in that he uh distrusted communism and feared its totalitarian tendencies but he was a committed english socialist in the sense that uh he was not opposed to a large welfare state so uh he was uh an important writer of the 20th century because of the intellectual content of his work”
Control of the past is crucial to controlling the present and future; the historical narrative is an extremely important linchpin for a culture—in Weimar Germany (1920s), the narrative shifted from American intervention to blaming Jews for losing World War I, which catalyzed radical movements.
“one of the most powerful ideas in the book is that control of the past is crucial to controlling the present and the future in other words the historical narrative is uh an extremely important kind of linchpin for a culture if you notice for example in weimar germany this is 1920s germany the narrative of german history uh explaining why they had lost the first world war went from the american intervention to the sinister behavior of jews all right they were sold out and when this dishonest representation of their history um became current it sparked and catalyzed a great many radical movements”
The individual has no chance against a totalitarian collective; Winston Smith loses because the individual must eventually confront the Party, which is eternal and collective, while individuals die and are singular.
“i think the idea is that the individual has no chance against this kind of collective individuals like winston smith live and die big brother doesn't and that means that when the individual squares off against this the individual is always going to lose”
Lysenko in Stalinist Russia exemplifies politically compulsory nonsense: as an uneducated agronomist, he claimed he could revive Lamarckian genetics, believing that acquired traits could be inherited; Stalin endorsed this fraudulent biology and killed anyone who opposed it, causing famines that killed millions and set back the Soviet economy enormously.
“this double-mindedness this double thing um can be turned on and off he can literally say that two and two is four or five depending on what the party requires uh this is quite similar to what to the uh horrific case of lysenko and stalinist russia lysenko was a an uneducated agronomist who decided that he could revive lamarchian genetics what that meant is that he could make uh plants and animals have qualities by uh acting upon their predecessors so if you cut the tail off a mouse and that and its children as children as children eventually 10 minutes into 10 generations into it uh the mice just give up and stop having tails now it turns out none of this is true and it was completely catastrophic when it was applied to uh agriculture so it caused a number of famines which killed millions of people it was on the other hand endorsed by stalin who was willing to kill anyone who spoke or wrote against lysenko is to make believe biology and what it did was set back the soviet economy enormously”
Extreme libertarians take a good thing (liberty) and transform it into the good thing (the only thing that matters), which is wrong because there are in fact many good things that compete for attention and resources and are incommensurable—they cannot be successfully quantified or ranked.
“the problem with libertarians isn't hard to describe anybody with any sense thinking about politics is going to agree that liberty is a good thing in other words all other things being equal leaving people alone to live the way they want is a good desirable end the problem with libertarians is that they take a good thing and they transform it into the good thing and that means that they've created a kind of new golden calf that everybody has to get down and worship now the problem is is that when they move from liberty being a good thing to being the good thing um they're just wrong um there are in fact lots of good things and they compete for our attention and resources and they're incommensurable”
Winston Smith's job at the Ministry of Truth is to rewrite historical records—when Oceania changes allegiance from Eurasia to East Asia, all prior news articles and newspapers must be rewritten and originals destroyed, allowing the Party to control the past and thereby control the future and present.
“his job is at the ministry of truth which is to say the ministry of propaganda which is say the ministry of lies and so since every few months uh oceania changes sides from siding with eurasia uh to to siding with uh uh east asia well that means that all this prior antecedent uh news articles and newspapers have to be rewritten the originals thrown away and the fraudulent copies or the fraudulent alternatives put in their place that way by controlling the past the party controls the future”
Winston Smith's torture by O'Brien reaches its critical turning point when O'Brien holds up four fingers, Winston says four, but through mechanized pain so extreme that Winston cannot perceive reality, he momentarily says 'yes, five'—demonstrating that the Party's goal is to make citizens unable to trust their own perception of objective facts like 2+2=4.
“this happens in the case of winston smith when his inner party torture o'brien tells him that two and two is five he holds up four fingers he says how many winston says four he doesn't know what he's supposed to say to avoid the pain because uh the torture is mechanized as well and uh the pain is made so extreme that he's unable to see reality and then at least for a minute or for a moment he says yes four five five he sees five um he can't be sure that two and two is four and that is the critical turning point”
O'Brien's statement 'if you want to imagine the future imagine a boot standing on a human face' represents Orwell's terrifying vision that humanity will be crushed by unstoppable totalitarian power because dishonest and anti-rational politics cannot be defeated.
“the gruesome image given to us through by o'brien if you want to imagine the future imagine a boot standing on a human face because humanity is going to be stepped upon and crushed by the unstoppable force of dishonest and anti-rational politics”
China exemplifies 1984-like totalitarianism: the chairman is a quasi-deity stand-in for the emperor in an authoritarian top-down tradition; the regime uses internet technology very effectively to control people through a social credit system that can deny dissenters jobs, transportation, and housing.
“china is the great example uh the chairman of the chinese communist party is a quasi-deity you know he's the stand-in for what the emperor used to be and uh it's uh it's an authoritarian top-down tradition and it's managed to use the technology of the internet very very effectively in controlling people their system of social credit can deny people that make waves the ability to get a job the ability to use uh transportation the ability to uh to get an apartment so it's a pervasive and very dangerous tendency”
The Party's ideology, Ingsoc (English Socialism), represents a transformation of English socialism into an authoritarian system of supervision, surveillance, and systematic dishonesty with an active choice to abolish history and continuously rewrite evidence of the past.
“the party is what's left it whose ideology is ingsoc um is uh a transformation of english socialism it's transformed itself into uh an authoritarian system of supervision and surveillance and dishonesty uh there is an active attempt or active uh choice to abolish history and to continuously transform the evidence of the past to suit the prevailing uh desires of the political elite”
Orwell was prophetic in warning about the return of absolute authority mediated by technology, but he failed to see that technology can also be liberating—cell phone cameras contradict official accounts, and people can now leak information in ways previously impossible.
“i think his concerns about absolute the return of absolute authority uh mediated by technology i think that that's a a prophetic insight um on the other hand he failed to see the technology is in some ways liberating look at the changes that have happened now that everybody has a camera on their cell phone you can take photos and these often are at variance with the official accounts so in some ways it is actually liberated individuals i mean let's be fair to technology it hasn't all been one way um people can uh leak information now in a way they never could before”
Zamyatin's 'We' and Aldous Huxley's 'Brave New World' are earlier dystopian/utopian works that are also prescient, and Ray Bradbury's 'Fahrenheit 451' is another great book that addresses similar concerns about authoritarianism and control.
“well earlier of course there's zamyatin's wii and uh there's also earlier than that uh brave new world which is some ways almost as prescient i can't think of a book maybe maybe a fahrenheit 451 by ray bradbury okay that's a great book too”
Language restriction through political correctness should be distinguished from standing up to genuinely abusive racist language; the best way to stand up to offensive language is to call out the offense plainly ('don't be a jerk') rather than through linguistic restriction or cancellation.
“they do have to be stood up to is the best way of standing up to them constricting the language or saying don't be a jerk um you know i i think that that's in other words um there are some verbally abusive racist people um i don't know that there are all that many of them i agree that language is important and it matters um and i'm certainly willing to call people out about language but at the same time um blacklisting people on account of language which is what tantra canceled culture amounts to stuff they said 18 years ago or something i mean it um it can become counterproductive and crazy um fairly quickly”
Conflicts about what libraries can contain and what information they can access should be resolved toward maximization of information and access; ultimately the people (local communities) should judge what information is appropriate, not centralized authorities.
“conflicts about what libraries can can contain and the information they can access on the whole insofar as possible should be resolved to the mac to to the maximization of information and access you know there's a great line in john locke's second treatise on government in which he says ultimately the problems of society can't be left to any small number of people what he says is ultimately the people shall judge and that it seems to me local communities in a rough general sense should have uh a great deal of input into schooling and into libraries”
A defense of free speech in the tradition of 19th century liberals like John Stuart Mill—letting everybody say whatever they want and modifying only the minimum practically necessary (e.g., can't yell fire in a crowded theater)—comes closest to a neutral standard for determining acceptable speech.
“a defense of free speech the ways the way one of the 19th century liberals like uh say john stuart mill did yeah um i think that that comes as close as i'm familiar with to a neutral standard which is let everybody say whatever they want uh and then we'll modify it you know to the minimum amount practical so you know there's the old hackneyed phrase that you can't uh yell fire in a crowded theater fair enough”
John Stuart Mill's powerful point is that everyone who wants to restrict free speech by saying 'you can't say that, we can't think that' is assuming themselves to be infallible, which nobody can sustain.
“john stuart mill's powerful point is that everyone that wants to restrict freedom of speech saying you can't say that we can't think that is assuming themselves to be infallible right and nobody is nobody can sustain that”
Big Brother in 1984 is a kind of secular god and the regime represents a secular theocracy; O'Brien, an inner Party intellectual, knows that Ingsoc is a fraud but can use doublethink to literally say 2+2=4 or 2+2=5 depending on what the Party requires.
“big brother is a kind of secular god and this is a sort of secular theocracy o'brien himself is intellectual and uh committed to ingsoc and to big brother but he knows at the same time that it's a fraud this double-mindedness this double thing um can be turned on and off he can literally say that two and two is four or five depending on what the party requires”
1984 sales have spiked twice in four years: once when President Trump took office (associated with concerns about fake news and changed facts) and recently again (associated with political claims about the US becoming an Orwellian dystopia), showing the book is perceived as relevant to contemporary political concerns across ideological lines.
“1984 sales have spiked for the second time in four years one the first time being uh when president trump took office and a lot of the spike was was associated with the um fake news and um you know changed facts all of that stuff and then the second spike actually just came recently”
Over the past 30 years, economic gains from the internet economy have overwhelmingly gone to the top 10% of American society, and their interests are generally represented in mainstream media; neoliberalism has been good to the credentialed class but they have not done a good job meeting responsibilities to the rest of society, which is why many are politically angry.
“over the past 30 years the uh gains economically from the internet economy have overwhelmingly gone to the top 10 of american society and their interests are generally represented in the mainstream media all right so uh yeah i think that neoliberalism has been actually pretty good to the credentialed class and that they've done pretty well they haven't done a good job in meeting their responsibilities to the rest of society and that's why we have so many people pissed off”
News media organizations like Fox, CNN, and others are all players staked out in ideological territory rather than neutral observers; this hyper-politicization of media is not a service to listeners seeking truth.
“particularly because um we now live in such a hyper-politicized age that even the news media regardless of whether it's fox or cnn or who it is all of them are players now they're not just neutral observers all of the mistaken staked out in ideological territory um i'm not sure that that is a service to the listeners”
Political poetry (ideological statements and grand visions) guides election campaigns, but governing requires prose (practical tradeoffs and messy reality); this means political systems never match their foundational rhetoric.
“one of the nice things about people being uh flawed is that they can't even get totalitarianism right in other words nothing works out no matter what your governmental system is nothing works out the way it's supposed to everything takes too long and costs too much and if you try to implement anything it doesn't matter what ideology you bring into it um i think with mario cuomo that said you uh you run for office in poetry but you govern in prose”
Explicit bias training programs represent attempts to control the inner person through modification of thinking with intention of modifying actions; whether this is justified depends on circumstances, but blanket programs for people without demonstrated bias are probably not justified.
“um yes they're trying to change to modify people's thinking with the intention there from that of modifying people's actions there might be circumstances in which that's a good thing there might not be my guess is probably depends upon the circumstance um in the same way that uh say at least we can do it down here if you get a traffic ticket you instead of of taking the ticket you can go to traffic school and they'll teach you how to drive again like they did in uh driver's ed but it's only three hours and that actually is found to reduce people's accidents well maybe it's justified with people that have tickets all right people that have exploited that have displayed some overt or uh um controversial bias but in general uh i don't think most people need traffic school”
Most libertarians are not well represented in mainstream media; instead one finds them more on radio shows, while mainstream media is primarily concerned with controlling speech and organizing categories with which we understand reality, and is not libertarian but rather represents interests of neoliberalism.
“with the exception i would say of fox news particularly fox business news there aren't very many of them in the mainstream media yeah i would say you you more usually see them or hear them actually on radio shows right the mainstream media is still concerned with controlling speech and that means organizing and controlling the categories with which we are we understand reality all right but they're not libertarians um i would say they're the avatars of neoliberalism”
American history is currently a football being fought over politically, and there is a lot of bad American history being circulated; historical narrative disputes are not merely academic but have real political consequences.
“it is nowadays our our the american history is a football and there's a lot of bad american history going around”
There are racist people who use language abusively, but it's unclear there are very many of them; blacklisting people through cancel culture for things they said 18 years ago can become counterproductive and crazy.
“there are some verbally abusive racist people um i don't know that there are all that many of them i agree that language is important and it matters um and i'm certainly willing to call people out about language but at the same time um blacklisting people on account of language which is what tantra canceled culture amounts to stuff they said 18 years ago or something i mean it um it can become counterproductive and crazy um fairly quickly”
Removing classic texts from school curricula is cultural vandalism; classic texts should be kept in schools and libraries rather than pulled due to concerns about their content.
“that's cultural vandalism okay i mean that's all i mean i don't know what else to say about that”
Orwell's central concern in 1984 is whether politically manufactured make-believe can stand in for reality, and Stephen Pinker's principle that 'reality exerts a powerful selection pressure' provides the countervailing force against this—eventually make-believe collides with external reality and collapses unless constantly reinforced.
“it's this control of reality that orwell is most concerned with concerned with examining um is it possible to have make-believe stand in for reality and i think the answer is that it's possible to do so temporarily over an ex a period of time but sooner or later um i think stephen pinker is the one who said it's the greatest uh greatest understatement of the 21st century i've been counting he said a reality exerts a powerful selection pressure and that's the countervailing force to the insistence on politically manufactured make-believe”
Language is dangerously prostituted to politics in Newspeak; truncated ability to speak is a limitation on political freedom, and the goal of totalitarian regimes is complete control not just of actions but of the psyche and inner person, with language control being the most important element.
“language is dangerously prostituted to politics and it enables and reinforces and legitimizes political evil and he is certainly right about that uh the truncated ability to speak is a limitation on political freedom and the goal of the regime is not merely acquiescence the goal of the totalitarian regime in 1984 is complete control not just of the actions but also of the psyche the inner person and the most important element in this is the control of language”
When institutions like universities and mainstream media control language usage, they set benchmarks for what can be said and thought, but the question is whether these institutions are particularly able to discern the true nature of reality well enough to justify restricting speech.
“institutions that control it you know i'm thinking primarily of universities but also of the mainstream media the usages that they deploy all right often become benchmarks right and uh well the question is are they particularly able to discern the true nature of reality so that they don't cost us anything when they restrict what we can and can't say”
Tech giant companies have taken the place that multinational energy companies used to have as big heavy hitters in global politics; control of information is even more powerful than control of gasoline, and eventually tech giants may need to be broken up the same way old monopolies like Standard Oil were.
“the tech giants have taken the place that uh multinational firms like uh oil companies used to have they're the big heavy hitters now not the energy companies and uh it seems to me that eventually they're gonna have to be broken up in the same way that the uh uh old monopolies like standard oil and the old trusts got busted because they were dangerous to the market but also dangerous to the uh political equilibrium of society our control of information is uh even more powerful than control of gasoline”
The threats and difficulties Orwell describes in 1984—the connection between politics and truth, the control of language, the surveillance, the attack on individuality—are no longer 'looming' threats; they are problems we have already encountered and run aground on.
“the difficulties the disasters the looming threats that he talks about aren't looming anymore we've encountered them we've run aground on them and uh the connection between politics and truth is still a vexing one”
The 24-hour-a-day surveillance of Party members in 1984 represents a totalitarian regime from which there is no way out; once such regimes are created, it is unclear that any solution to the problem exists because the proletariat cannot be mobilized to revolt.
“there's 24 hour a day surveillance for the members of the 24 hours a day surveillance members of the party um what this means is that there's no way out once these totalitarian regimes have been created it's not clear that there's any solution to the problem uh winston smith and o'brien talk about the possibility that the proletarians may revolt against this but the totalitarians of ingsoc are much more effective at controlling the the proletarians than the prior capitalists have been and there's no chance of them becoming politically mobilized”
The novel has given us vocabulary to deploy when talking about concerns about centralization of political power combined with mass surveillance technology and encroachment on individuality and privacy; well-intentioned activities like COVID control measures can have unintended consequences of expanding surveillance even without totalitarian intent.
“i think it has it's given us a vocabulary uh to deploy when talking about our concerns about the centralization of political power comply combined with uh the technology of mass surveillance and it the encroachment on individuality and on privacy doesn't even have to be malicious or totalitarian in intent i can see lots of the current covid crisis lending itself to surveillance of people uh not with the intention of depriving them of their liberty rather as a means by getting control uh a means of getting control of a public health crisis so uh you know often even our well-intentioned activities have unintended bad consequences”
The debate about whether Julia (Winston's love interest in 1984) was a spy sent to entrap him versus genuinely in love with him is unresolvable because in a totalitarian regime you can never know what reality is; O'Brien may be lying about her betrayal, and the ambiguity reflects that totalitarianism creates epistemological chaos.
“you can't trust anyone and although o'brien says she betrayed you it's not clear that o'brien is telling the truth and the betrayal may be in the fact that she was never in love with him to begin with and there's always been an operative for the state one of the problems with uh the totalitarian nature of the regime that winston smith lives under is that you never know what reality is nothing is as it seems”
There is no neutral umpire to call balls and strikes in debates about language and truth; everybody has an opinion but it is unclear who has the best one or where the right zero point to start is.
“unfortunately there's no as far as i can see no neutral umpire to call balls and strikes here everybody's got an opinion it's not clear who's got the best one or you know where the right zero zero point to start out is”
1984's themes of control of language, thought, past, and psyche exist to some degree in all societies including democratic ones, but free regimes are distinguished by making mistakes on the side of freedom—cutting back restrictions only narrowly and carefully to preserve maximum liberty.
“i think that there's an overlap between the forces that are let loose in our kind of democratic regime or our cognitive republican regime the u.s um that are also seen in totalitarian regimes right um there's a a tendency to enforce certain kinds of norms and certain kinds of mores i'm inclined to think that every society does that what distinguishes a relatively free regime from a totalitarian regime is that we do our best to make our mistakes on the side of freedom all right we know we're going to make mistakes but we'll make our mistakes allowing for freedom and then cutting back in a narrowly tailored way in order to preserve as much freedom as we can”
1984 is a great defense of freedom of thought and also a defense of making sense during a time of hysterical inability to make sense; it illustrates how politics sometimes forces people into extraordinary contortions in their reasoning.
“orwell's book is a great defense of freedom of thought and it is also a great defense of making sense during a time of his story of hysterical uh inability to make sense uh politics sometimes forces people into extraordinary contortions”
I am liberal in the archaic sense: I accept that I am not omniscient and often wrong, which means it is smart to allow people to disagree with me because fallibility requires epistemic humility; this is opposed to anyone claiming certainty and demanding others cannot speak.
“me i mean i'm a i'm a liberal in an archaic sense um uh i'm someone who thinks that yeah i'm not always right i have to accept the fact that i'm not omniscient and that means that sometimes i may be wrong which means that it's smart for me to allow people to disagree with me because well i'm fallible”
In a pluralistic society with many different accounts of what is good, the critical problem is who gets to decide what you can say and what is within the window of what is discussable—this is an interesting and difficult problem.
“the problem is in a pluralistic society with many different and necessarily many different accounts of what's good who gets to decide what you can say who gets to decide what's within that overtin window of what's discussable okay and that's an interesting problem”
Technology can be both liberating and restricting, and people can now get access to information on the internet in unprecedented ways, suggesting that 'two cheers for technology' is warranted while remaining concerned about what will be done with companies that hold all our information.
“it's possible that technology can be both liberating and restricting and it's only fair to recognize that um it has done a lot for people to be able to get to the kind of information that we can all get on the internet now so uh you know two cheers for technology and uh the worry is what what are we supposed to do with the big companies that have all our information”
Distinguishing between words and things is essential for civil society: words are 'firing blanks' (harmless speech) while physical violence causes real harm; civil society requires allowing people to use words as they want because we must assume people can handle disagreement expressed in language without escalating to violence.
“for the most part we want to extend people's right to speak as far as possible and what that means is distinguishing between words and things in other words when someone disagrees with you using words that's different from someone disagreeing with you using a stick all right and civil society requires that we allow people to use words the way they want because they're firing blanks there or at least we have to understand that's what it is we don't allow them to beat each other up as a way of expressing their dismay right”
Society requires commonly agreed-upon reality; without agreement on what is real, society breaks up because communication breaks up, but the critical question is who among us is wise enough or inspired enough to claim they know the true nature of reality and can tell others—prophets are in short supply and there are far too many of them.
“we need a com a common agreed commonly agreed upon reality um otherwise we can't get anything accomplished uh we break society breaks up because communication breaks up but here's the question lurking behind that who was who among us is wise enough or you know um inspired enough to know to actually claim that they know the true nature of what's real and that they're able to tell us regular folks the true nature of reality i mean you would have to be something like a prophet and uh in one sense they're in short supply and in another sense there are far too many of them”
Setting boundaries between acceptable and unacceptable speech happens through individual judgment and consensus-building rather than top-down imposition; worrying is that some words are given magic powers they don't really have.
“i think that disagreement both in terms of the content of thought and in terms of the way thoughts are expressed that's going to be intrinsic to a free society where people go across the line well um i think we set that as individuals and then we come to some consensus about that um what worries me is that we're given two words at least some words magic powers that they don't really have”
I maintain an old-fashioned belief in liberalism and freedom even though politics has recently been messy, because the core principle remains sound—prioritizing freedom with narrow exceptions is the best approach.
“i still uh i still like that old-fashioned idea of liberalism and freedom that's why i like orwell's book”
An example of trade-offs between liberty and other values: allowing planes to take off and land whenever pilots want would increase liberty but cause airplane crashes endangering people living near airports; thus we restrict aviation liberty to preserve public safety.
“we would have somewhat more liberty if we allowed planes to take off and land from airports uh when they happen to hit the airport in other words when the pilot wanted to land or take off unfortunately that would cause many problems for public safety on account of airplane crashes weighing them together we say well still liberty is a good thing but we can't let you have this liberty gentlemen and ladies because it is very unfortunate for the people who live near airports”
Thirty to forty years ago, using the F-word would be catastrophic, but now nobody cares because we have taken the sting out of the word through widespread use (as Lenny Bruce advocated); this shows that words don't control us if we drain their power through desensitization.
“think about say 30 40 50 years ago if someone said the f word it would be the beginning of the end i mean this was a big deal now nobody cares why we've pulled the fangs from the blasted thing and now it's just a thing you say when you hit your hammer with a thumb or you hit your thumb with a hammer so um in a way what lenny bruce liked the idea of taking the sting out of words means that the words don't control us anymore”
Government implementing anything is difficult—nothing works out the way it is supposed to; everything takes too long and costs too much; this suggests that perfect totalitarianism, like any system, will have gaps and inefficiencies that provide opportunities for resistance.
“one of the nice things about people being uh flawed is that they can't even get totalitarianism right in other words nothing works out no matter what your governmental system is nothing works out the way it's supposed to everything takes too long and costs too much and if you try to implement anything it doesn't matter what ideology you bring into it”
In Oceania (Orwell's fictional superstate combining the New World and Anglo-sphere), the Party uses totalitarian politics enabled by technological advances to create complete surveillance society of Party members, with Big Brother as a deathless, menacing personification of the eternal state.
“in oceania which would be i guess the new world plus the anglo-sphere so it would include uh the british isles and australia and such um this is uh where winston smith the main character lives and uh it is a world in which totalitarian politics have been enabled by technological uh advances so there's a complete surveillance society at least among the members of the party”
George Orwell's 1984, published in 1949, is an examination and extrapolation from the catastrophe of Stalinist Russia in which a dystopian world has emerged where three major powers fight endless pointless wars and force intellectual and personal homogeneity on their populations.
“george orwell's 1984 is a landmark post-world war ii novel published in 49 uh it's uh it's an examination and extrapolation from the catastrophe of stalinist russia uh in 1984 uh a dystopian world has emerged in which three major powers fight endless pointless wars and force intellectual and personal homogeneity on their third of the world's populations”
Doublethink is a term originating from 1984 referring to the ability to think one thing while simultaneously knowing the opposite is true—telling a lie but persuading yourself it is not really a lie because whatever suits your political purposes becomes the truth.
“the source of many commonplace words in the english language now like uh doublethink where you have to think one thing but also know the opposite is true at the same time that's when you are telling a lie but persuading yourself that it's not really a lie because um whatever suits your political purposes is the truth”
The Inner Party represents roughly 1% of society, the Outer Party about 10%, and the remaining 90% are proles (proletarians) who are kept busy, distracted, and politically quiescent, allowing the Inner Party to remain inscrutable and maintain power.
“winston is a member of the outer party which is uh perhaps 10 percent of the society the inner party is perhaps one percent and the remaining 90 percent of the proles the proletarians and they're kept busy and they're kept distracted and so they're politically quiescent”
As a historian, Sugrue has great affection for librarians as the historian's best ally because of their commitment to preserving and providing access to information.
“for me not so much because because i'm a professor um i love librarians and i keep a very close connection with them because they're the historian's pal right”