three-fifths clause
The original constitutional provision counting enslaved persons as three-fifths of a person for purposes of representation and taxation, since abolished.
As defined in Richard Epstein on the Constitution
Where it comes up · 3
- Jill Lepore1 claim
- Richard Epstein on the Constitution1 claim
- 296 - Repairing Our Country1 claim
Most important claims · 3 of 3Search all claims for “three-fifths clause” →
- The story America should tell is not that it is evil because it had slavery, but that it is great because it ended slavery at great bloody expense; slavery existed worldwide for thousands of years, and what ended it was the classical liberal philosophy of individual sovereignty and human dignity—and the hypocrisy of a country founded on equality while holding slaves ate at its conscience until it corrected itself, which is what MLK invoked by demanding America live up to its own promissory note.296 - Repairing Our Country
- Enlightenment forecasters who predicted America would soon blossom as a new Athens misunderstood the basic premise of 18th-century republican government: they failed to see the original sin of the Constitution—the three-fifths clause and constitutional sanctioning of slavery—and could not foresee how the first century of American history would be consumed almost entirely by the struggle over slavery, making the predicted cultural flowering, contingent on the ease of equality, impossible.Jill Lepore
- If you ask which constitutional provisions have durability outlasting their creation, a very large fraction do—especially the structure of enumerated powers and inter-state competition policed by federal anti-blockade power, which works as well in the age of the internet and airplane as in the horse-and-buggy era—while the ones that failed (the three-fifths clause and fugitive slave provisions) are all gone.Richard Epstein on the Constitution