causal

Constitution's Original Sin Doomed Early Flourishing

Enlightenment forecasters who predicted America would soon blossom as a new Athens misunderstood the basic premise of 18th-century republican government: they failed to see the original sin of the Constitution—the three-fifths clause and constitutional sanctioning of slavery—and could not foresee how the first century of American history would be consumed almost entirely by the struggle over slavery, making the predicted cultural flowering, contingent on the ease of equality, impossible.

causalpending

Speaker

Jill Lepore

Evidence Quote

“it seems naïve to suppose, looking back, that the flowering, the great flowering of culture, which is contingent in that notion on the ease of equality, could be possible”

Source

Jill Lepore— Conversations with Tyler
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:19:01 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...