technocratic
Relating to governance by technical experts or specialists rather than by elected representatives or the general public.
As defined in 57 | Astra Taylor on the Promise and Challenge of Democracy
Where it comes up · 4
- 57 | Astra Taylor on the Promise and Challenge of Democracy3 claims
- Yuval Levin on Burke, Paine, and the Great Debate2 claims
- Thomas Leonard on Race, Eugenics, and Illiberal Reformers1 claim
- Peter Thiel on 'Anti-Anti-Anti-Anti Classical Liberalism' | Oxford Union1 claim
Most important claims · 7 of 7Search all claims for “technocratic” →
- After WWI, when German connections became politically untenable, progressive economists conceded they were wrong about Germany but not about the necessity of the administrative state and experts in charge; economics then evolved toward a more technocratic model where experts are given goals by a political process and decide the best route, differing from the heroic Progressive Era conception in which experts also told you what your goals should be, like preachers.Thomas Leonard on Race, Eugenics, and Illiberal Reformers
- On the surface the sides appear to have switched — conservatives now want to transform governing institutions while liberals protect every inch of the welfare state — but this is only a second-order argument about change: the Right still begins, as Burke did, in gratitude for the good and skepticism about rebuilding from scratch, and the entitlement system liberals defend is itself an instrument of the Progressive, technocratic vision Paine would recognize.Yuval Levin on Burke, Paine, and the Great Debate
- The core Left/Right disagreement on an inefficient health care system reflects the Burke/Paine split: the Left says make it efficient by centralizing it under expert control, while the Right says make it efficient by decentralizing it and letting it be the sum of its parts run on the ground between buyers and sellers — a very Burkean reliance on evolved institutions versus a technocratic, Painean reliance on expertise.Yuval Levin on Burke, Paine, and the Great Debate
- Universities' technocratic defense against humanities critics—that flaky debates about Shakespeare and Rigoberta Menchú are irrelevant because the real progress happens in science and technology—has become exhausted, as science and technology have themselves stagnated since the early 1970s.Peter Thiel on 'Anti-Anti-Anti-Anti Classical Liberalism' | Oxford Union
- Expertise is essential in a complex society but becomes a problem when abstracted to the level of letting technocrats or experts govern, because they become a self-serving group with no accountability—there is something inherently undemocratic about expertise since not everyone can be an expert.57 | Astra Taylor on the Promise and Challenge of Democracy
- The purpose of democracy is not to find the single technically correct answer (which would favor smart people) but to ensure everyone's interests are represented; representative democracy works well when elected representatives then consult experts to implement policy.57 | Astra Taylor on the Promise and Challenge of Democracy
- Much of the attraction to populist movements stems from democracy being seen as not working, as in Europe where the EU has shifted power to technocratic elites, leaving ordinary people feeling nothing they do affects what the government does.57 | Astra Taylor on the Promise and Challenge of Democracy